{ "reviewed_at": 1788856305.7624066, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 527, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 42, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 55, "tool_calls_reviewed": 526, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_iBcssUaXSFRIwIsLbu9hJz95", "call_zuhM46yQfTITdday0JCCxDFY", "call_U8rBHIq4Kb00qPn5F2x7RFQE" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1, 44, 54 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; cohort saturation decision is computed from all ten admissions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1208, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 277.26691722869873, "keys_used": 1068 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2341, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 224.88513779640198, "keys_used": 2677 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 220, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 31.67789888381958, "keys_used": 240 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 3049, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 423.1470453739166, "keys_used": 6154 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Grimhawk", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1064, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 44.847962617874146, "keys_used": 912 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1210, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 55.852476596832275, "keys_used": 1304 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Gorgol, the Butcher", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1395, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 44.506978273391724, "keys_used": 1519 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1568, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 26.354562997817993, "keys_used": 1633 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 450, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 450, "player_turns": 3164, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 806.5104579925537, "keys_used": 3593 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Grave wight", "depth_feet": 400, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 400, "player_turns": 4105, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 8418.32487821579, "keys_used": 6709 } ], "notes": [ "All526 complete tool calls,42 visible assistant texts and55 available reasoning summaries were read. The completed exports exactly match the reviewed live evidence. All nine final Python files were read, including complete revision diffs; final notes and code snippet were read, and saved results match the service summary. Encrypted reasoning was not inspected and root never executed agent code or pickle.", "All ten games ended in native death, with no jewel or escape. Scored games reached450 and400feet. Exact replay reproduced all25819 native frames;22111 normal HUD checks had no discrepancies. All native distinct-message content and120 final keys per game were reviewed. The final game\u2019s1335 distinct messages are bound to six fully read contiguous windows by exact reconstruction against the completed journal.", "Practice games explored melee/evasion, smithing and song builds. Trials1and4 repeatedly rested under damaging plant or arrow attacks. Trial4 also had1490 fear-blocked inputs and a long aiming-prompt loop; the agent corrected those controller behaviors. Trial8 spent782 inputs bumping a door, then died while fighting stationary plants. These input counts are not equivalent to native turns. Some characters forged useful armor; others spent on smithing without using a forge. No controlled build-effect claim is made.", "Scored trial9 forged mail and shields, recovered after a Mountain Troll fight using Blocking, learned Delvings and reached450feet. It killed a Snow Troll and recovered to36HP before arrow damage and a routing loop. A retreat through a closed door met an Orc captain. The character drank an unidentified poison potion, then a stale inventory letter selected poison again. A later tried potion did not heal; native poison reduced HP to0 at3593 and terminal3594 followed.", "Scored trial10 used Alchemy and identified consumables. It survived several severe encounters: Light, Quickness, Warding and Elbereth accompanied an8HP descent to350feet and later recoveries; two retreats from400to350feet reached19HP and7HP. It killed isolated champions and trolls and returned to full or near-full health. These local successes are retained alongside the final death. Warding, light, speed and fear effects were temporary, and repeated Grave Wight encounters drained Strength.", "Trial10\u2019s inventory classifier initially omitted Studded Leather and retained heavy spare equipment. Manual drops removed slowing, but later Strength drain produced402 rejected movement inputs at the same native turn4064. The model revised its parser to confirm the player with Look, then discarded equipment to move again. At1HP, an additional Song point and attacks preceded both trolls fleeing; the character moved west, survived an Attercop encounter and reached5HP. Slowing returned. During the final attack\u2019s pending resolution, the Grave Wight hit for the fatal damage at6709; terminal6710 records HP\u22121 and playerturn4105.", "The controller\u2019s ordinary adjacent-attack return became unreachable in call315 because it followed a return inside the focused-attack condition. Setting focusedFalse later did not restore that branch. Other movement choices could still resolve as melee, and the model used manual attacks extensively. The final report\u2019s claim that Easterling/player color overlap materially corrupted navigation is not established by the inspected6500\u20136504 screens, which show playercolor11 and hostile@color9. No counterfactual survival or causal learning effect is inferred.", "Three nonzero agent-code exits and a further TypeError visible in piped output were reviewed. They do not represent engine failures. Three clipped outputs were reviewed only through retained text. All575 numbered screens and3671 additional public-data projections matched native sources. Thirty-nine controls accept original evidence and reject37 deliberate alterations. Full client views cover every native frame; there is no capture gap in this session.", "Native information has limits. The armor sidebar intentionally excludes Blocking while the character sheet can include it. Orcish Liquor heals and removes fear but adds stun; an earlier root working-note error about curing stun was corrected before admission and preserved in a correction record. Territorial recall abbreviates a line-of-sight pursuit condition, so its wording should not be read as immobility or a fixed six-square territory. The native description\u2019s omitted condition is disclosed; observed corridor pursuit is consistent with the pinned engine. No adapter corruption or material game-contract defect was found.", "All527 requests used Astra medium with128000 output allowance and997500 effective context; peak input524952. No compaction, model error, missing usage, boundary finding, rejected game request, retirement or resource guard occurred. The longest game took8418.324878seconds; maximum6709keys. Estimated request-priced cost was$267.639850. Reviews and direct play are by the development agent, with no independent human winning baseline." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 25819, "exact_replayed_frames": 25819, "matching_public_views": 25835, "unique_full_json_frames": 25819, "additional_missing_full_views_matched_numbered": 0, "not_captured_as_complete_client_views": 0, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 575, "additional_signals": 0, "supplemental_native_projection_checks": 3671, "normal_hud_checks": 22111, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 267.63985 }