{ "generated_at": 1788909258.00265, "cohort": "research-silq-v3", "cohort_manifest_sha256": "390b2e6afb441f228c2de7c2456acf033f92baae354f63b1a3c0a880f91f53a5", "conditions": { "astra-medium": { "status": "complete_valid", "expected_sessions": 10, "attempted_sessions": 10, "admitted_sessions": 10, "reviewed_excluded_sessions": 0, "statistics": { "sessions": 10, "sessions_with_scored_win": 0, "best_of_two": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "any_scored_win_exact_ci95": [ 0.0, 0.3084971078187607 ], "mean_scored_win": { "mean": 0.0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0, 0.0 ] }, "scored_games": 20, "scored_wins": 0, "scored_losses": 20, "mean_scored_max_depth_feet": { "mean": 250, "ci95": [ 187.5, 317.5 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 150, 200, 400, 225, 125, 375, 275, 175, 150, 425 ] }, "attempt_curve": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "win": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "max_depth_feet": { "mean": 195, "ci95": [ 155.0, 235.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 200, 150, 250, 250, 250, 300, 150, 100, 200, 100 ] } }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "win": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "max_depth_feet": { "mean": 150, "ci95": [ 105.0, 200.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 100, 250, 50, 100, 150, 50, 150, 150, 200, 300 ] } }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "win": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "max_depth_feet": { "mean": 200, "ci95": [ 120.0, 305.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 100, 600, 200, 100, 100, 250, 100, 50, 300, 200 ] } }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "win": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "max_depth_feet": { "mean": 205, "ci95": [ 145.0, 270.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 200, 50, 300, 150, 200, 100, 200, 150, 400, 300 ] } }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "win": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "max_depth_feet": { "mean": 180, "ci95": [ 140.0, 225.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 200, 100, 200, 250, 250, 300, 100, 150, 150, 100 ] } }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "win": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "max_depth_feet": { "mean": 200, "ci95": [ 150.0, 260.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 150, 50, 200, 150, 400, 200, 200, 150, 300, 200 ] } }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "win": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "max_depth_feet": { "mean": 155, "ci95": [ 95.0, 220.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 300, 350, 50, 50, 100, 100, 200, 50, 200, 150 ] } }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "win": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "max_depth_feet": { "mean": 155, "ci95": [ 105.0, 215.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 100, 100, 100, 300, 50, 100, 150, 200, 350, 100 ] } }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "win": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "max_depth_feet": { "mean": 230, "ci95": [ 145.0, 325.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 150, 300, 500, 150, 100, 300, 200, 100, 50, 450 ] } }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "win": { "mean": 0, "ci95": [ 0.0, 0.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0, 0 ] }, "max_depth_feet": { "mean": 270, "ci95": [ 205.0, 335.0 ], "unit": "independent session", "method": "percentile bootstrap", "resamples": 100000, "analysis_seed": 730291, "values": [ 150, 100, 300, 300, 150, 450, 350, 250, 250, 400 ] } } ], "estimated_request_priced_usd": 2094.74762, "requests": 4390, "usage": { "input_tokens": 13170, "input_tokens_cache_write": 5558507, "input_tokens_cache_read": 1114134187, "output_tokens": 1844571, "reasoning_tokens": 1354447 }, "rejected_requests": 6, "game_seconds": { "median": 369.0564124584198, "max": 11180.471844911575 }, "max_keys_used": 27085 } }, "astra-max": { "status": "complete_with_exclusions", "expected_sessions": 2, "attempted_sessions": 2, "admitted_sessions": 0, "reviewed_excluded_sessions": 2, "interpretation": "All retained attempts are reviewed. Excluded sessions have no capability outcome; the retained condition is not a complete valid sample.", "admitted_case_summaries": [] }, "astra-max-control": { "status": "not_completed_scope_reduction", "expected_sessions": 0, "attempted_sessions": 0, "admitted_sessions": 0, "reviewed_excluded_sessions": 0 } }, "comparisons": {}, "medium_gate_recommendation": "valid_unsaturated", "runs": [ { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-medium-01", "condition": "astra-medium", "bundle": 1, "admitted": true, "status": "complete_valid", "best": 0, "mean": 0.0, "scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Madthorn", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1088, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 455.2182066440582, "keys_used": 1110 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 2009, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 169.20124745368958, "keys_used": 2150 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Gorcrow", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 134, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 60.563406467437744, "keys_used": 223 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc skirmisher", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1883, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 161.20081758499146, "keys_used": 2160 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a fatal wound", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 3510, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 270.8489682674408, "keys_used": 3669 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Wolf", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1222, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 14.53704047203064, "keys_used": 1368 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Easterling warrior", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2223, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 106.60594844818115, "keys_used": 2488 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 863, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 38.14357876777649, "keys_used": 939 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc skirmisher", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 420, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 4.800354480743408, "keys_used": 526 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1136, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 107.85690474510193, "keys_used": 1165 } ], "requests": 168, "usage": { "input_tokens": 504, "input_tokens_cache_write": 157960, "input_tokens_cache_read": 16251881, "output_tokens": 35170, "reasoning_tokens": 13683 }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 19.989921, "peak_request_input_tokens": 157963, "scaffold": { "captured_at": 1788820877.8816342, "model_context_windows": [ 997500 ], "last_session_timestamp": "2026-09-07T22:41:12.349Z", "compactions_observed": 0, "scope": "last read-only live snapshot; authoritative full model history remains in Inspect" }, "rejected_requests": 0, "execution_failures": [], "structured_tool_errors": [], "replayed_frames": 15808, "qualitative_review": { "reviewed_at": 1788821196.8567574, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 168, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 23, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 51, "tool_calls_reviewed": 167, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_EccqGVpnhknejo6PhtjG1ziO" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; saturation gate requires all ten sessions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Madthorn", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1088, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 455.2182066440582, "keys_used": 1110 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 2009, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 169.20124745368958, "keys_used": 2150 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Gorcrow", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 134, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 60.563406467437744, "keys_used": 223 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc skirmisher", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1883, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 161.20081758499146, "keys_used": 2160 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a fatal wound", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 3510, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 270.8489682674408, "keys_used": 3669 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Wolf", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1222, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 14.53704047203064, "keys_used": 1368 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Easterling warrior", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2223, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 106.60594844818115, "keys_used": 2488 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 863, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 38.14357876777649, "keys_used": 939 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc skirmisher", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 420, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 4.800354480743408, "keys_used": 526 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1136, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 107.85690474510193, "keys_used": 1165 } ], "notes": [ "All 167 tool arguments/results, 23 visible assistant messages and 51 available reasoning summaries were read. Completed exports exactly match the reviewed live records. Agent code and notes were read as evidence, never executed on the host. Native checkpoints, every distinct message and depth transition across the ten games were reviewed; independent replay checks every frame. This is root-agent review, not an independent human review.", "Call 1 bundled the guide, manual and overall status into one default-size exec result and clipped the manual. The complete guide and retained manual prefix/suffix match frozen source exactly; subsequent ranges 130\u2013610, 610\u2013930 and 930\u20131030 also match exactly. The full manual remained available. This model-selected output clipping is retained, not classified as an environment failure.", "Trial 1: Fingolfin 2/4/5/3, Melee5 Evasion5 Perception3 Will3 and Finesse. A controller navigated by native screens, fought, picked items and rested. Thrallmaster disarm caused 71 unarmed-attack confirmations before manual recovery; wielding the floor sword and then leather armour worked. At 4 HP the agent retreated around a corner and rested to full. A supposed dead end at150ft resolved when waiting revealed a secret door. Crebain bleeding preceded Madthorn confusion at200ft; an unidentified potion did not heal, and movement while confused ended in Madthorn death. Several useful items remained unused.", "Trial 2: a stronger melee/evasion build and automatic equipment comparisons equipped leather, cloak and bow. Mewlips reduced torch fuel; prolonged exploration and navigation consumed the remaining light. No replacement logic existed until the character was attacked unseen. Equipping a fresh torch restored visibility but left little health. Emergency potions identified Slowness and Disconnection, followed by Orc soldier death at100ft. Native zero-quantity inventory during potion More prompts was accepted correctly.", "Trial 3 descended to100ft without body armour. A Gorcrow blinded the character; the controller treated the unseen threat as absent, and resting or attempting to close an occupied doorway did not provide safety. Native death was a Gorcrow at134 player turns. This is a perception/control failure under native blindness, with intact observations.", "Trial 4 found leather, a battle axe, arrows and gauntlets and reached200ft. Unseen whispers repeatedly reduced torch fuel. Alternating exploration targets caused a two-position loop; the agent diagnosed it from its history and persisted a goal. After exhausting all lights, its pathfinder could not traverse remembered dark corridor spaces and waited while attacked. The attempted return upstairs failed; an Orc skirmisher killed it.", "Trial 5 switched to Finarfin, Keen Senses and a lower-health build. Another loop arose when scrolling hid a target; preserving off-screen terrain and goals resolved part of it. The agent then treated plants as path costs and rested beside one, reaching11HP; moving away and resting restored41HP. Native minimum-depth pressure caused the first descent to jump from50 to150ft. At200ft, White wolves and Orc archers overwhelmed the character. Three White wolves were killed, but pursuit inflicted a fatal wound after the late retreat.", "Trial 6 retained the perception build and acquired gloves, cloak and greaves, but no body armour. It passed a usable forge. At150ft, Wolf attacks and Spider hatchling poison caused native death; the recorded final cause was a Wolf. The controller did not successfully use a healing or antidote supply.", "Trial 7 invested in Feanorian smithing and Armoursmith but never used a forge. Found mail, glaive and Helm of Defiance improved displayed equipment. A trap caused the descent from250 to300ft, so the deepest point is not evidence of deliberate strategic progress. A full pack rejected a lantern and bows. Light-slate hostile @ glyphs were mistaken for the player, producing36 wall collisions. After correcting player colours, the enemy detector still selected alphabetic glyphs only and ignored Easterling warriors. An Easterling warrior killed the character at300ft.", "Trial 8 tried Alchemy and added conditional supply use, but only found a Herb of Rage before the final encounter and never obtained body armour. It died to an Orc soldier at100ft. The experiment does not establish that Alchemy is ineffective; this trajectory did not realize its proposed benefit.", "Trial 9, the first scored game, selected Fingolfin2/3/6/3, 59HP and Power. It equipped leather and a helm, reached150ft at full health, then died surrounded by Orc skirmishers. The second scored game used Fingolfin2/4/5/3, Power and Song of Elbereth with a persistent controller. Both are legitimate scored losses; no game was retired, substituted or left unfinished.", "Trial 10 demonstrated native Elbereth use: frame200 explicitly shows the Mewlip fleeing when the song begins. The controller frequently toggled singing, trained Song4 and equipped cloak/helm/arrows, but retained melee5. It died to an Orc soldier at150ft with voice3/34 after repeated encounters. All805 diagnostic normal-HUD candidates retained the correct current depth on row25. Native song row21, depth row25 and minimum-depth row26 remained separate; ordinary character-menu overlays are excluded from that diagnostic.", "All168 outgoing raw requests and responses verify Astra at medium, each with128000 output allowance. The captured client reports997500 effective context; peak request input157963, no compaction. There were no model errors, missing usage, execution failures, rejected service calls or boundary-access attempts. Two Python invalid-escape SyntaxWarnings in a model editing command were nonfatal. Agent loop messages labelled BUDGET are voluntary program iteration limits, not evaluation resource cutoffs.", "All15808 unique native screens were captured as full public observations and replayed exactly. The general audit checks15967 full views; an additional format audit checks148 numbered screen/signals and15943 controller HTTP records covering15806 unique frames. The first two frames missing from the custom controller log are present in CLI history. All104 sampled row tuples and the four coloured @ positions in call148 reconstruct exactly. Internal bot-memory and DECISION prints are agent computations, not authoritative coordinates.", "The ten games used15798 keys in total and ended by native death well below43200 seconds and100000 keys each. Estimated request-priced cost is$19.989921, far below the$1200 session guard; hosting, root development and invoice adjustments are excluded. No throne room, Silmaril or escape was reached. One admitted session with0/2 scored wins does not establish the ten-session saturation gate or a learning effect." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 15808, "exact_replayed_frames": 15808, "matching_public_views": 15967, "unique_full_json_frames": 15808, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 148, "sampled_native_tuples": 104, "coloured_player_candidates_checked": 4, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 19.989921, "evidence_sha256": { "assistant_text.json": "5184c5c3554c09b4921ca470b803bff1b1391d56b7834dae46fa894c56c85d37", "available_reasoning_summaries.json": "7defc4953eee635284a37efd5b6926f5421dcf1e3d55e6fd29375d96a38845bb", "live-final-review-continuity.json": "f7b74b75082bc89353df7ffde50534bb62867ea98621fab865b24723171bb7bd", "manifest.json": "3dac907a9e471cd19282be6f96dc6369dc83d68172a1ba2af27002dc0a9627b0", "manual-read-audit.json": "e157a9330559a170358b877523afef89b2b88f70d526084dfa0cb199c52db27e", "projection148-check.json": "cfb113f4c1429d368ec07a6dd2cb3b23ab886dd3f8f1230841cebea3a031443a", "public_observation_audit.json": "d4fbcbc50d12fd8479dc8a37b789826e03588078c18c6ecd2fe01de7b93aa400", "qualitative-working.json": "a607f526e05736a70b7da86ae24121fa02f7d90d2178df864be96087d9b210ad", "replay.json": "e58626a80ffb42d660cf63723926bfd097d0a53d624e40a9756f8b092c60d022", "review.json": "a3dce19bdb2c877eac02ac612919666027229b48da2de141c2d4b22979660ff3", "song-hud-audit.json": "2deb01d8e36bf1315fcc728998f2b41761da9cfed2d1f0a9a010435d5aa38220", "state/events.jsonl": "aa15a7c685b91904945b74a370f75c134089668811c2b6516f9136d9cef6da1f", "state/summary.json": "355acbbd1be0b8e3c3283dbfaee4543f930bc35922fb36d52936ddb51c4e7740", "tool_calls_complete.json": "8d583bf2367436e4678a612df0010bc0b4c2a4586a8f1dc24833cfea29c09fcb", "tool_review_coverage.json": "fec81db2e0b7fa579e9abf586a5c149b1a10e0b30fc95b2da8b1d67dd93a8d09", "trial02-04-native-messages.txt": "7a2e8a36c61b68ca252e759bb4dd04295311063e8594447c68ce8f3f07f9861f", "trial05-06-native-messages.txt": "a451072de0ec555795b0639e8ab7377de419fb3543aea4d0911659c398b2e7a8", "trial07-native-messages.txt": "f672f92e123005566067938843221f22412b072de6ac48ee660040c4d7cde743", "trial08-09-native-messages.txt": "58e6e3fe948f13774dbc4bb53e1dc64cb623bef2d42f6031038e8f44abbe5615", "trial10-native-messages.txt": "75bdee2e551a8f70483ec753b1c57711654d205de11678eb328a013849017235", "v3-controller-audit.json": "ee2713987ec2afd2899e78313263165e4e5b0cda0ea5eaf2a77bc1ffc0a091c2", "v3-projection-audit.json": "204726943edaa0598dbb1235748b1e49fc68895ba5e6a135b76fd64c9f414742", "workspace-file-review.json": "869ca3dc45fe989ca29c5ad97662eee54d67810b00d3e95050247dc811eff04c", "workspace-snapshot.json": "a3dcca73c09c7cda09758769059b4e00e41937f89798fd9a9dd329d157ec3458" } }, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "3dac907a9e471cd19282be6f96dc6369dc83d68172a1ba2af27002dc0a9627b0", "qualitative_review.json": "d0f28d81f4c866552551fdae07339b0bee178194929478479c90006fcaef0d58", "review.json": "a3dce19bdb2c877eac02ac612919666027229b48da2de141c2d4b22979660ff3", "replay.json": "e58626a80ffb42d660cf63723926bfd097d0a53d624e40a9756f8b092c60d022", "state/summary.json": "355acbbd1be0b8e3c3283dbfaee4543f930bc35922fb36d52936ddb51c4e7740" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-medium-02", "condition": "astra-medium", "bundle": 2, "admitted": true, "status": "complete_valid", "best": 0, "mean": 0.0, "scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 831, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 528.0852243900299, "keys_used": 868 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Boldog, the Merciless", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -20, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 7515, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1171.1030533313751, "keys_used": 8866 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Shadow spider", "depth_feet": 600, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 600, "player_turns": 7769, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 3049.5099759101868, "keys_used": 10695 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 50, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 466.8328676223755, "keys_used": 137 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 2869, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 110.63471817970276, "keys_used": 2490 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "retired", "result": { "win": 0, "ending": "retired", "native_ending": false, "max_depth_feet": 50, "depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 2885, "hp": 41, "diagnostic_source": "last recorded native state; service retirement, not native defeat" }, "seconds": 789.9753201007843, "keys_used": 2386 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mountain troll", "depth_feet": 350, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 350, "player_turns": 7630, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 2536.7382142543793, "keys_used": 6314 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Gorcrow", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 483, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1032.8335735797882, "keys_used": 491 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Attercop", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2969, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 11180.471844911575, "keys_used": 3401 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 654, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 791.1888339519501, "keys_used": 774 } ], "requests": 741, "usage": { "input_tokens": 2223, "input_tokens_cache_write": 1826689, "input_tokens_cache_read": 284764437, "output_tokens": 471798, "reasoning_tokens": 390205 }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 599.399715, "peak_request_input_tokens": 898747, "scaffold": { "captured_at": 1788843993.6607482, "model_context_windows": [ 997500 ], "last_session_timestamp": "2026-09-08T05:06:27.673Z", "compactions_observed": 1, "scope": "last read-only live snapshot; authoritative full model history remains in Inspect" }, "rejected_requests": 1, "execution_failures": [ { "call_id": "call_nT6YAT9yCzgQ2RtDJWHVkHvh", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_icCVZWeBYSD70u6Nk5wnfLvI", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_LWYDyoWo7Q2bgImq5cHfvwX3", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_rWE8LDQnA2foDjOLntd5f7ot", "function": "exec", "category": "command_nonzero" }, { "call_id": "call_ZuoJ7s9uI7D6jQMWStvy48YE", "function": "exec", "category": "command_nonzero" }, { "call_id": "call_Cdnq3jHbGJP3cIaGPhbb6H1a", "function": "exec", "category": "command_nonzero" }, { "call_id": "call_969075eHB5hmMsObIab7XTey", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" } ], "structured_tool_errors": [], "replayed_frames": 36432, "qualitative_review": { "reviewed_at": 1788845206.310836, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 741, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 95, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 65, "tool_calls_reviewed": 739, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_EG2hOIQMWCfzCbP7NSBCkQ6H", "call_RMiPsa1zSAmwq7ZMN5FexdZo", "call_TQVzSwIujBuSBKoYupS7eKTG", "call_XC2HDKVt43Eh0sxxykUbF4mI" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1, 306, 369, 715 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; saturation gate requires all ten sessions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 831, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 528.0852243900299, "keys_used": 868 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Boldog, the Merciless", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -20, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 7515, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1171.1030533313751, "keys_used": 8866 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Shadow spider", "depth_feet": 600, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 600, "player_turns": 7769, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 3049.5099759101868, "keys_used": 10695 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 50, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 466.8328676223755, "keys_used": 137 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 2869, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 110.63471817970276, "keys_used": 2490 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "retired", "result": { "win": 0, "ending": "retired", "native_ending": false, "max_depth_feet": 50, "depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 2885, "hp": 41, "diagnostic_source": "last recorded native state; service retirement, not native defeat" }, "seconds": 789.9753201007843, "keys_used": 2386 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mountain troll", "depth_feet": 350, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 350, "player_turns": 7630, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 2536.7382142543793, "keys_used": 6314 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Gorcrow", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 483, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1032.8335735797882, "keys_used": 491 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Attercop", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2969, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 11180.471844911575, "keys_used": 3401 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 654, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 791.1888339519501, "keys_used": 774 } ], "notes": [ "All739 tool calls,95 visible assistant texts (including the full compaction summary) and65 available reasoning summaries were read. Encrypted reasoning was not inspected. The live prefix699/87/59 is unchanged. All30 final Python files and notes were read, with full diffs for related variants; immutable guide/manual and final result JSON match their sources.", "Nine games ended in native death and learning trial6 was voluntarily retired at50 feet with full health after a routing stall. Retirement consumes the scheduled game and is a zero, distinct from native death or a resource cap. Both scored games died, with no jewel or escape. All36,432 native frames reproduce exactly, including the retired trial\u2019s last nonterminal frame. All32,215 normal HUD checks match.", "Learning trials1\u20133 used physical builds. Trial2 forged armor but wasted turns in full-pack loops, darkness, archery and equipment changes; Boldog killed it at250 feet. Trial3 reached600 feet after adapting equipment and emergency consumables, then died to a Shadow spider. Trials4\u20137 tested songs/stealth. Lorien visibly put foes to sleep, but waking groups and weak defenses remained dangerous. Trial6\u2019s controller missed a scrolling stair transition; the agent retired it and corrected its own navigation. Trial7 later descended from50 to300 feet after the native minimum-depth clock advanced, then died to a Mountain troll at350. Trial8 returned to a smith build and died to a Gorcrow before forging.", "Scored trial9 forged mail and the Venom\u2019s End and Free Action rings at100 feet. It reached300 feet, used unidentified and identified consumables during a troll/spider/crow pursuit, and recovered from3 HP with a Quarterstaff of Mithrim. Confusion traps and renewed pursuit led to another emergency. Late Song training and Elbereth did not prevent an Attercop killing it at frame3401; frame3402 is terminal although a More message remains. The controller\u2019s subsequent input was correctly rejected with HTTP409. The native ending, not the controller\u2019s exception, determines the zero.", "Scored trial10 began with Will2 and Smithing4, intending to obtain Indomitable earlier. It learned Jeweller but never reached a forge or equipped armor. At100 feet wolves and a Mewlip trapped it in a passage. The agent resumed after one context compaction, killed a wounded wolf, then tried to retreat. A spider hatchling inflicted18 poison; the next attack killed the blocking wolf but poison killed the character at frame774, with terminal frame775 confirming HP\u22122. The intended defenses were never tested.", "The broad audit matched734 numbered screens and734 filtered color views, plus36,421 archived HTTP views covering36,416 unique frames. The general public audit found36,447 matching views covering36,428 complete unique screens. Three additional full screens match numbered displays. One controller view, trial2 frame7672, was not saved when the agent killed its own navigation process between input and local append; the protected frame is present and exactly replayed. This capture gap is disclosed and is not represented as a model-read observation. A further270 source-transcribed projection checks passed, including259 newer checks;17 corruption controls accept the original and reject16 alterations. Four clipped outputs retain only the material actually shown.", "All741 requests used Astra medium with output allowance128000, effective context997500 and peak input898747. One context compaction occurred. There were no model errors, missing usage or resource-bound games. Seven tool failures were agent code/command errors, including the correctly rejected postterminal input; all were reviewed. Longest game11180.471845 seconds, largest key count10695, estimated request-priced cost$599.399715. Navigation, player/hostile classification, equipment scores and causal claims remain agent inferences. No human winning baseline or causal learning conclusion is claimed." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 36432, "exact_replayed_frames": 36432, "matching_public_views": 36447, "unique_full_json_frames": 36428, "additional_missing_full_views_matched_numbered": 3, "unarchived_controller_views": 1, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 734, "additional_signals": 734, "supplemental_native_projection_checks": 270, "normal_hud_checks": 32215, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 599.399715, "evidence_sha256": { "assistant_text.json": "7c4a6e478bbcd938ed0e97c7bdc9754151fe2d5de8f5b5d5a338a91724d50ea4", "audited-reading-proof.json": "4384f67e468ad7137278449b26b5052d87f1f983bfeeb9e2e9f167f2a2c50109", "available_reasoning_summaries.json": "4fbbbc94dbb96df6ea3252fcbbcc3f82537c165031f402535cbc7d69e29fd892", "controller-findings-review.json": "7a5d58c4be205034f6face266f331781bda1c99d577f77ed95f71715f17b5ea6", "live-final-review-continuity.json": "a331e61f728d39476f593357bc532002daba857bab56b151c6eaff33af4aa283", "manifest.json": "e794210eaab2d73097d5c3b12227b88b137fd1b34bb98c16003097283f4b05ab", "native-review-working.json": "d1ca829978a688925c6512257f410c5321aa556552455c9590688ba9d778148f", "projection-counterexamples.json": "ebf56026d24243b38c1f8b2a3e9a5a2118963cd4bcca8aa163f84b2d3e997e7f", "projection377-manual.json": "62ce8d997d4ddbf750b1e48cb71d0da0446d72aa4acd19d89a033afaeaae6f17", "public_observation_audit.json": "07938a3c570f413f18dd48cf59400c4a8b2cfe41341a4e7be7109f209b716a6d", "qualitative-working.json": "8533b611e1948414483ebf1f055e37025fc862484e76da3c2a0338e3da5a8565", "replay.json": "72d1958ae4f9411953cab6f55d95bd78e3a32a6d8eab736422a451fdf65f71da", "review.json": "a8d49c09b9cb06af73ba5fad202a53453b62cf6029995b6f61eb8d1a85e0873d", "source-read-audit.json": "b48b0debf33eb00b400455c9d9828133c81216a6ee0a1f76989b21e1df5c1f54", "state/events.jsonl": "b5e51c465b8aac0628a47ed5e0357adf79df640b27109c8811545260b867aede", "state/summary.json": "9423826846265ca663bf4d9c9db4f90bda4fae545b7fb59d4dcf4046538d2c5e", "tool_calls_complete.json": "c0fa5b006e582d246145c8ec0dd52f98a77c2403f27d4b635a1b06f6f6e78b85", "tool_review_coverage.json": "f76fe6c286de7db9f01f231d9b1319b77788c83d843a585e93385b0b6a1882fa", "trial01-native-messages.txt": "bdc8da5443521e0275e8a8931b916af8c3354f388b409466bc5cf56e32b4dfde", "trial02-fatal-key-review.json": "2e050c02750ca535a8ff5354a9a50f7d95c79a6dea4868a1dcc52d17d36704cf", "trial02-native-messages.txt": "dd0f08183970eaaeabe83aa33de5cb64391e8877c43ef96504d21b9aa597d472", "trial03-fatal-key-review.json": "cb7b2f365abb6d1788f267b15b47b648bb05ef2b222bf94190a9df2594e4a678", "trial03-native-messages.txt": "eb23e8868dd13b631481bc9eb9046886cb91eb3c6e8f05769c7c561071f1d076", "trial04-native-messages.txt": "369470570ad2e6e7b13146214ed7c949a940ede418da5f04bf87579c132ef2dc", "trial05-native-messages.txt": "48290bc3a7cf862c20204345d11f6271c3ebbb6806005f29554f5754d5c1ad0c", "trial06-native-messages.txt": "e448680cb755ffd0eca5744d306540b73e5d2daa6f13e88df4cfc42eb183b318", "trial07-fatal-key-review.json": "cd60300c0603c9548f7a798fe91887a153c2c7d46beabe2456f5c36de37b869d", "trial07-native-messages.txt": "9a847616cc5fea7ab625a097ed0ae74ae9b2e070dfa52eb022d752f2aa072320", "trial08-fatal-key-review.json": "c5f0ffdca1eb429b20007359147d00f0cd0a3cc5581392df5f815ca350fb3af3", "trial08-native-messages.txt": "e8ffa3378fcdd4e9a4bb7e55534318f4a31ed6a06c6b0f071eb139f47ba27bd9", "trial09-fatal-keys.txt": "63128179fe0c20b30782217a43e719ca76038cf94bb2ba54c76a68d3281729d1", "trial09-native-messages.txt": "1e764379b0dfc9ea343ea062e5fa17d11b2f268b781bc35ff7e2b932d5396a1f", "trial10-fatal-keys.txt": "a5917d9698c51968df7620fd90a18bf4438538f2cc1151670e7e584dcbf6f1e1", "trial10-native-messages.txt": "b5866b69a376c3ffedbe592e0cdefb55cd36cb6adf511f1e574e3ae671cabbcc", "v3-controller-audit.json": "b31ae74e2945b601fe7e395065f2616f1ca856200e39406b809da818df721e63", "v3-medium02-projection-audit.json": "04e5dffa537ac83d70881ea50810533e20ab4569fb7a4ba55c069758d50ad8da", "v3-native-projection-audit.json": "af6ebc1471c07489ada75da86e07a47e34695a8c1c448875e74d382169807c30", "workspace-file-review.json": "b22f12bbd61f28200a6f509f6bac43563eec4c92bf54a4db5be43a993f8e90ca", "workspace-snapshot.json": "7e5fb6a392d00df71f25e48af83e25b4d84b6659cef94a8695241a2d5b7c5b64" } }, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "e794210eaab2d73097d5c3b12227b88b137fd1b34bb98c16003097283f4b05ab", "qualitative_review.json": "4303bae6354405843a4c61466da9f52de4e5e08e40062584fdc9d45ebfcdc9a5", "review.json": "a8d49c09b9cb06af73ba5fad202a53453b62cf6029995b6f61eb8d1a85e0873d", "replay.json": "72d1958ae4f9411953cab6f55d95bd78e3a32a6d8eab736422a451fdf65f71da", "state/summary.json": "9423826846265ca663bf4d9c9db4f90bda4fae545b7fb59d4dcf4046538d2c5e" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-medium-03", "condition": "astra-medium", "bundle": 3, "admitted": true, "status": "complete_valid", "best": 0, "mean": 0.0, "scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -6, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 963, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 491.002464056015, "keys_used": 1044 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 132, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 93.38460969924927, "keys_used": 143 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Gorcrow", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1546, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 173.46211433410645, "keys_used": 1654 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 1579, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 184.71208214759827, "keys_used": 1939 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 3311, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 628.4943001270294, "keys_used": 4256 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 3073, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 407.68086767196655, "keys_used": 3599 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mewlip", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 248, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 26.116955757141113, "keys_used": 359 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Wolf", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 537, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 425.01220178604126, "keys_used": 567 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Shadow", "depth_feet": 500, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 500, "player_turns": 11901, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 10315.074077129364, "keys_used": 27085 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Nightthorn", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2316, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 730.468752861023, "keys_used": 3103 } ], "requests": 482, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1446, "input_tokens_cache_write": 660257, "input_tokens_cache_read": 139522766, "output_tokens": 314275, "reasoning_tokens": 245888 }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 282.301945, "peak_request_input_tokens": 660260, "scaffold": { "captured_at": 1788835479.7346272, "model_context_windows": [ 997500 ], "last_session_timestamp": "2026-09-08T02:44:07.097Z", "compactions_observed": 0, "scope": "last read-only live snapshot; authoritative full model history remains in Inspect" }, "rejected_requests": 0, "execution_failures": [ { "call_id": "call_5f29HBpO5pyc18ip2RC10Zuu", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_rxjNdjn86lFDhZOx6STwswqx", "function": "exec", "category": "deliberate_interrupt" }, { "call_id": "call_X13r2Rs9BDEsyWpvUjOV38ce", "function": "exec", "category": "command_nonzero" }, { "call_id": "call_NxDXyPcW4cgWnD9MRVHH3acv", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_ul8Vwzs5QZAorpp7DG7voG1f", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" } ], "structured_tool_errors": [], "replayed_frames": 43759, "qualitative_review": { "reviewed_at": 1788837366.195003, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 482, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 57, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 49, "tool_calls_reviewed": 481, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_ewPCRz0BTbnleJXppA494QRN", "call_KXZdNbvKtkFYYnkbNZfnS6lT", "call_rxjNdjn86lFDhZOx6STwswqx", "call_u4jSqiFJICySzWDq3V4p0ZVN" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1, 198, 242, 413 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [ { "call": "call_WvUIiulW4VLDvAO2rmTnHAA5", "category": "engine_or_oracle", "outcome": "benign", "evidence": "Full tool call 374 read. Writes its own RUN_NOTES.md stating No hidden state/debug/save/load, then runs the previously read public-terminal controller nav2.py. No request for engine, oracle, private state, debug, save or load access occurs in the flagged command. Report retained unchanged; this is a lexical false alarm, not an attempted or successful bypass." } ], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; saturation gate requires all ten sessions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -6, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 963, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 491.002464056015, "keys_used": 1044 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 132, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 93.38460969924927, "keys_used": 143 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Gorcrow", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1546, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 173.46211433410645, "keys_used": 1654 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 1579, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 184.71208214759827, "keys_used": 1939 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 3311, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 628.4943001270294, "keys_used": 4256 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 3073, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 407.68086767196655, "keys_used": 3599 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mewlip", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 248, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 26.116955757141113, "keys_used": 359 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Wolf", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 537, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 425.01220178604126, "keys_used": 567 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Shadow", "depth_feet": 500, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 500, "player_turns": 11901, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 10315.074077129364, "keys_used": 27085 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Nightthorn", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2316, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 730.468752861023, "keys_used": 3103 } ], "notes": [ "Initial visible texts and available summaries read. Live model/effort/output allowance and997500clientwindow verified; full request audit still required. Repeated immutable guide/manual source already read during development; exact excerpts and retained clipped ends independently verified by source_checked_review. Clipping remains explicit; no omitted middle is presumed visible.", "Read tools 1\u201318 in full except independently source-checked repeated guide/manual. Call5 requests missing before action;6 switches to urllib. Call7 cost-column/stat confusion corrected via native birth ESC before dungeon generation, same trial. Final native birth 3/4/4/2 M6 Eva6 Per3 XP200; name Aerin normal frame59 HP41. Initial helper archives only batch frames, single-key HTTP responses not saved. Sparse lowercase numbered rows/colors need exact supplemental comparison.", "Tools19\u201388 fully read in native-matched reading copy with all code/row changes/filtered colors retained; root old21\u201322 clipped output reread. Original full attributes independently exact. T1 rubble loop75\u2013225 then excludedcolon; map memory/globaloffset/nav2 rewrites; BattleAxe352, Greaves643, StuddedLeather893 after200, Eva7Will2train908;250OrcarchersHP10frame1036\u2192Darktried1038noheal\u2192HP3frame1042\u2192retreat8death1045. T2 same3/4/4/2 M6Eva6Per2Song1 Elbereth53; drops&frommonsters afterplantdamage124, native T2 all38distinctmessages/depths read, death144Tanglethorn50HP-5; keyscan pending verifies rest. T3 hazard buffer70, autoequipLeather/Boots, loopsno frontier then upstairs fallback74, same-depth staircase requiresmapclear75; stuckdoorhundreds at200; Orcarcher/Gorcrowfight1558\u20131565, rest23\u219241 thenblind Gorcrowdeath1655. T4 archivelog singles fixed86 afterdiagnostic84 no frameobjects for3>1600, 85 lastframe47poem exact. M5Eva5Per2Song5Elbereth, wrongsongrow[22:] repeatedalreadysinging172;89pendingrowfix. All captured customnumberedscreens86 andsignals86exact in latest audit; filtered mode explicitlyverified, native records allreplayexactclosed1\u20134.", "All8visibletexts and20available summaries throughrequest84 read. T2 native keys corroborate fatal rest: Orcskirmisher slain131 HP41; moves1/4 then8Z keys134,135,136,137,138,139,141,143 in plantreach, HP27\u219221\u219226\u219220\u219214\u21928\u21922\u2192-5. No modelcontrollerlog single frames beforeT4; immutable native journal intact, exactreplaypassed. Available summaries contain loose paraphrase/nonspecific UI planning; treated as summaries rather than authoritative actions.", "Read all distinct native messages/depth transitions T1(121),T3(175),T4(256);T2(38) previously read. T1StuddedLeather726 collected\u2192893equip,Gauntlets921unused; unseen arrows1016\u20131033 beforevisiblearchers1034; Darktried1038noheal death1045. T3Leather65 Boots106 Greatsword684 Gloves752;395stuckdoor messages1132\u20131542 endswhen doorbursts1543. Gorcrow1625blind, unseenpecks until1654death; recover-with-no-visible-enemy controller suspect pending exactkeyreview. T4AmuletRegeneration527,boots369cloak545gloves761; no bodyarmor, BattleAxe1216GreatAxe1595Helm1227. Song successfulflee messages throughout. Depth3001697full41,torchgone1831, unseenwhispers; MountainTroll/WhiteWolves1931HPdrop, late song1933, killsoneTroll1937 thenWhiteWolfdeath1939/1940. ControllerT4continuationstillpending.", "Read89\u2013171 all code/output;99,116\u2013118,166\u2013169 reread after rootdisplay clipping. All14texts and32available summaries throughrequest166 read. Arrays in laterreadingcopy explicitlylabelled afterexactsource-transcribedfilterednativecomparison;originalsunchanged. 172pending. T4song row21readfix89; blindtrap994\u21925wait1005clear;250via1355at26HP,3001697; waitsvoice thenTroll/Wolf1931HP21;sa1933,4killsTroll1937thenWolfdeath1940HP-4. Nohealingused.", "T5Feanor3/5/3/2 M5Eva4Per2Smith5Song3,Armoursmith59Elbereth66 HP34. Wolf264HP19\u2192270HP12;FLEEchanges109 stairs100283HP14Voice0. 200800RedSerpent/spiders/orcs28HPpoison9\u2192FLEEup150820HP21. No forge100beforeleaving. HandAxevalueheuristicoverestimateslowweight;116weight-awarefixrestoresCurvedSword1294afterOrcishLiquor1281stun20\u219231HP;WhiteWolfkill1303. 200archers1614HP22, PaleGreen1616triednoheal;FLEE1501634HP4, BrightOrangeBlindness1637\u2192>2001638\u2192waitblind1663HP10safe thenrestfull34. Helmfound/equipped, battleGorgol/Orcs1835 andCrebain1872cut;up1501880HP11. BirchstaffwhiteLight1925/1930 frightensOrcs; fights1980archer. Rest/explorationstall2000\u20132988partlyterrainstairretention/visitationthreshold;138preserveunder-monsterstairs,139immediatedescent;2002998HP14. All actions native, noreset.", "T5darktorch3659accountseveralroom-edgeoscillations,14124positions+messages and142full27rowframe3635 need supplemental exactprojectionaudit.144torchautofuel/equipment checks;fresh3660s, then500actionsopenoccupieddoorloop4228;145mons-on-door terrainoverwritefixed. Hungry4229Lembas4231. Wolves4243HP12cut3, VermilionDexterity4245Dex8HP11;forcedfight148death4257HP-4max200. No bodyarmor/boots acquired. NativeT5allmessagesstillpending.", "T6Feanor3/4/4/3M5Eva5Per2Smith4Song3,Armoursmith+Elbereth67.151safeZrecovery,153usespublic[ monsterattitudes toignoreFleeing/Unwary/Asleep whenallnonadjacent. Forge100919,Leather0,1d5completed929equipped938;firstHelminterrupted947thennewbasecancels952\u2013957,167craftretrycompleted977,Shield+1,1d3complete1013equip1022. PublicforgeCostrightedge nativewidthtruncation preserves visibleusecount,difficulty/time; noadapterloss. 169forged-triallocalmemorycontrols100exploration;2002171Hungry,2174Lembas.2362multiple@afterhumanenemies,samefirst@controllerissueas01,172pendingfixusesattributevalues. NativeT6/7messagespending, exactreplayT1\u20137=13001allpassed.", "Reviewer HUD check mistakenly included native Equipment overlays with long Gauntlet description covering left Health digits (25T5frames, e.g.3659). Exactnative replayalreadyconfirmsallframes. Excludedexplicitinventory/equipmentmenuviews fromnormalHUDcomparison, addedtestsnormal/overlay/changedHP/changeddepth; allcurrentclosednormalHUD0diff. No persistent HUD collision or gamecodechange.", "Read172\u2013217 full code/output;20visibletexts/33available summaries throughreq209 read.172@colorfix uses nearestprevamonghealthcolors;750DejectedElvenThrallblockedmoves through3121\u2192173green@terrainFnonwalkavoids. T6Orcgroup3556HP19,trainEva6/3568Eva+12,24FLEEto3592HP4 includesoccupiedsquares;175adds100costoccupiedthenFLEE12\u21923600OrcWarriorHP0,3073turns3599keys. NativeT6allmessagespending.", "T7Feanor3/4/4/3 M6Eva6Smith3Song1 normal50XP100 Armoursmith+Challenge64. Gloveszeroprotectiononly,50WolvesMewlip352HP21cut3;Challengeactive;FLEE177goes3deeperinto room thenMewlipdeath360HP-4cut4,248turns359keys. ClaimChallengeworsenedencounter isagentinterpretation, nocausalcomparison. T8Finarfin1/4/4/5Eva3Stealth8Per1Song1normal47XP600Disguise54+Elbereth61;stealth62slow,50Wolf100HP32song102thenrestinreach121HP14. ManualN/W/door140stop142Z143full41. Navreset189returnsnearWolf154HP18;19012framepos/msg/statusprojectionpending.191fullnavcodeconfirms restbranchstillrunsinstealthwithmonsters;192guardfix. FLEE183HP10,manual7/7/W to191HP6,close192/Z193full41.196blockeddoor37,7memory,100native400;Wolves533HP26cut4,YellowQuickness535,Song2train549Elbereth551,HP12afterMore552;Wfightto568WolfdeathHP-1,537turns567keys.198agentoutputclipped8tokens30charsrow17;newreviewerretainedendscheckexact andallcolors exact,missingmiddle staysmissing,fullHTTParchived. Counterexamplespass.", "T9scoredFingolfin2/3/6/3 M6Eva6Will1Song1normal48XP600;Challenge61free,Armoursmithfails54/79/596becauseSmith1not3.100forge593HP59afterboots/cloak. UnknownCopperSpeckledSlow600,BlackHerbSustenance603full grants100XP;207trainSmith3cost500/Armoursmith623cost500,Leather0,1d4complete641/equip650. HelmprojectcanceledforShield675interrupted,forged-trialslocalflagpremature679. Manualresume69754turnsleft;Challenge701/finish_forge212fightsapproachingOrcskirmishers,Shieldcomplete827equip836;Helm848equip857defense4\u201310.215150by2669,216Will3/SiA2689andBattleAxe/Gauntletslater, treatsallmashazardsandslateoasignored (agentpolicy).217prolonged150unseendamagewaiting,HP33at3609cutnogroupC/s.218pending. Supplement19012coords+184/194/201/207/208/209/212/213row0+forgedraftprojections stillneedexactnativechecks; nativeT5\u20138allmessagespending.", "ReadallnativeT5\u20138 distinctmessages anddepths. T5bodyarmor/bootsabsent, Cloak187specialGauntlets695Helm1774;530openfailures3699\u20134228confirmed. Actualdepthentries100281,150542,200741,up150817,2001579,up1501632,2001638,up1501876,2002994. OrcishLiquor1282heals,torchgone1609fresh3666late,BirchLight1925/1930nativeOrcscringe. T6craftwearLeather934Helm982Shield1018 actual;acid1826damagesHelm;GarnetRingBauglirsVanguardidentified2168increasedhunger, food2173restores.747DejectedThrallblocked2375\u20133121;2Orcthrallmasterskilled3149/3170,othersabyss3212/3213. FinalOrcwarriorcharges3598/3599nativefatal. T7nativeChallengeagitationexplicit216/338/342/345/347/350;no causalcounterfactual. T8nativeWolfdeath567/568,oneWolfkilled560thenanother567sameactionasdeath;preserve terminal0 score. Native HUD0differences allclosedT1\u20138,13569framesexact.", "Fatal key review trial03-fatal-key-review.json: all36keys/frames1620\u20131655read. SecondGorcrowblinds1625HP39;20Z and10More throughblindpecks toHP0native1654/terminal1655. Supplemental native projection audit proves63lines141/142/190 exact.", "Tools218\u2013273 fully read;274pending. All23visibletexts36available summaries read. T9 at150unseenattacker3610/3612; equipment3613revealsdeadtorch, fresh3625revealsOrcs/Wolves. Code220removesBattleAxes doublebonus andincreasesgearchecks, Power3690, full59by~3750. Fullpack4151\u2192explicitdestroy4155/4164+cleanup4219eightitems; benignnativequantity andconfirmhandled. 241navremovesmashazard, equipmentGreatsword\u2192Shield\u2192Dagger\u2192CurvedMurder recurses; agentinterrupt242actual990tokenclipretained, KeyboardInterrupt131repeatedstackframes,5172HP23min150. 243seen-signature+2handblacklist,244Murderbonuses Curved5189,resetnav245;5231full59. stairspriority246\u2192200then2505481HP28Gorgol; north5482then6hits5483\u20135488killGorgol, regainfullafterclose5612/stopsong+Z5615. 256KeyError adjacentmonsterblocked47,12\u2192257directdirectionandpersistfix,6278full59.3006572HP26confusedEasterlings; retreat4+8eastattacks6582killsEasterling/Orc,rest6607full59. RingBauglir hunger6610food. Will4trained6627, plannedWill5/Indomitable266abilitygained350; acquiredstatusmustnativeverify. Spider doorwayoscillationthrough8090mostlyfull; arrowsnotquivered267\u2192268equip8094,ff8098hit,8102kill.273addsrangehelperbutDirectionprompt8213remains,274diagnosticpending. Additionalprints249/252/261/268/272 native row0/inventoryprojections pending;241inferredstairsmap counts separated. Allcontrollerrows/signals exact onrefresh,2agentclippingevents now198smallrows+242equipmentloop; whole native action record retained. No resourcecaps or scaffoldchanges observed.", "Tools274\u2013288 fully read;289pending. All24texts37summaries read. T9 rangedhelper275 cancels persistentDirection prompt8214 rather than claiming shot success; auto8285HP28 at350 surroundedBalcmeg/Lug. West8286 cornersplayer. Gnarled8290Darkness (native8289), Yew8298Light (8293\u201395 namedOrcscringe), but hits leave13HP. MurkyBrown8303heals26HP, Blockingability8310. Five8attacks8322HP28 then8more8339HP15, further8attacks8340/8345HP13,look8346openfloor. Agentclaim Blocking helped is observational, not causal. Supplemental27410row0,277inventorydict,278/280nine-row0,283/284attackrow0 pendingnativeprojectionproof. No scaffold edits or root hints.", "Tools289\u2013314 fully read315pending, all25texts38summaries. T9look8347/recall8348Balcmegpublicvulnerablebrightlight+8,3d8;YewLight8352Cringe8353/54thenstillHP14afterhits. 8attack8361killBalcmeg\u21928364HP10, wolvesblocknorth. Violet8367visioncloudsforamoment; SparklingBlue8374Grace+3Vce103; Dark8381triedAutoinscribe8382n8383. Light302follow4attacksWhitewolves2kills8402HP13;8north8403Glovesspot/Lughits;Pale8408tried,Thorny8414RageHP16:71Str6Dex5Con7Gra8, Russet8421tried. 8/9/8north8425\u201327HP18.311ESCAPEmode avoidsmonsters and disablescombat/breakconditions;Voice|Vceparserfix;8462HP28movingnorth/eastLugOrcsWolfbehind,8523HP49returnedoldareaNOFRONTIER.313FIGHT65to8604full59,314rangedonlymbC,auto900active. Customprojection292inventorydict,293fiveMoremessages,295killrow0,299/302/304HP-row10 and attackrow0 pending; no task-scaffold edits or root hints.", "Extended supplemental native projection audit exact for 91 printed lines; all listed calls/formats/ranges in v3-native-projection-audit-live.json. Reviewer code corrected first-visible-@/None projection in equipment overlay, source endpoint02call2257410\u20137424 (state7425separatelyshown), and tupleformat02call226; no game or agent input changed. Two notes-prefixed screens02calls246/305 independently exact, notes remain agent assertions. Eight original/changedHP/changedCOLOR/wrongframe counterexamples pass in analysis/v3_prefixed_view_counterexamples.json. Other projections still require review.", "Calls315\u2013347,4texts3summaries fully read against hashed audited copy. T9 gear penalizes melee347? actual316 correction yields Helm/Gloves8973ev12prot5\u201311; cleanup9001Willow9002Eva7by9009. Navigation10968 oscillation with Easterlings;322retreatonlyadjacent,323hungry11594HP39.325E+a activates Rage stats3/2/7/2HP48:71;326twelve attacks (projectionpending) kill firstwarrior116xx and327exit11625HP54.328tightHPcolorplayer, retreat>=3orweak/protlow, negative remembered coordinates329GROUPcontrollerinference. Trap disarming333 then fullpackLesserJewel11874;334\u2013339nativeinventory/equipment/examine identifies Bauglirhunger and SwordMurderstealth+2/Assassination (not damage bonus).340reducesbonusweight/destroyshelmaxes;LesserJewel11901examine11904permanent1radius, equip11909;removeBauglir11912MoonstoneProtection11916+1d2.346Perception3train401XPleftLongsword11938+11. VermilionCon+3f11941Hth103:103; agent348pendingaliasfix. Root native HUD reviewer must also recognize Hth alias to avoid silently skipping this normal HUD; game remains unmodified. Supplemental32424historyrow0 and32612attackmessages await exact verification.", "Tools348\u2013377 fully read,5texts4summaries;378pending.348Health|HthfixKeenSenses11950XP1.11950ConbuffHth103 fades59by119xx,350navigate12930Hungry350ft,351actualLembas12934arrow.352\u201355Lpan, survey.TypeErrorNonewall354? actual355, corrected356. Survey infers226floorcells and routecostunknown359, not native explored info. Reached13044then800lootloop fullpackstaves/Mallorn to14104; cleanup14142drops6sets.364agentmapoffset[33,-168] repeatsrooms6092cells;365consume-lastmovementonceplusbaseline-save+survey883cells229inferred fixes its memory bookkeeping.367400ft15084Slowload;369sixgear/dagger/arrowdrops15117clearsSlow.371HeavyArmourattempt15608failsreq9(v8)seen15611,373Eva9XP12615625.375autoXP1003HeavyArmournativegained15958,376/377Hauberk39.5lb worn15962HP56def11prot8\u201322.374allRUN_NOTES fullyreadincludingrereadclippedsection; self-estimatedbases/mechanics remainclaims, knownMurderstealth etc corroboratedpriornative. Agent m-are-spiders overgeneralization mustnotapplytoallglyph; nativeMewlips useH. No root hints/interface edits, T9active noending yet. Supplemental survey maps are inferred controller state, rawpanstates capturedexact; manualprintednon-native projections still pending.", "Tools378\u2013394 fullyread,395pending;2texts2summaries(total36/47). Heavybodypin378,500f16170HP59Hauberk8\u201322,FinalRest16173nativeonlyslayundead+freedommovement; summary381preventsraised-soulsclaimnotestablished.383inventorydictf16179pending exact, dropsLeather16182BattleAxe16183,385plainLongsword+duplicateKitedropped16191.387notesfullyread plannedT10notyetresult. Navigation reaches500f16708HP28poison12,DarkPotion16711triednoverifiedcure;16713HP19poison9Shadow/DistendedSpider,OrcishLiquor16719HP31poison10. Retreat6/3/6/close16720\u201323HP24poison3;partialnoendingyet. Supplemental383fullinventory+388filteredinventory and385droppeditemprints pending. No root hints/scaffold changes.", "Tools395\u2013439 andtexts37\u201345 fully read;440pendingoutputexcluded. T9 500ft afterescapeHP25, one5rest16736ShadowtouchHP15;lastOrcishLiquor16741HP29,StaffLight16744HP24, native[16745blankglyphShadowSW;Mallornradius3native16752equip16757and2attacks16758/59destroyShadow. Othrod17158disarmFinalRest,agentdeclinesunarmed17162,pickup17165,re-equip17172;auto recover code414. RepeatedShadows17720/17798?/17842?/24945? killed using native[direction andMallorn, not alphabetic-onlyheuristic. Native24975recall confirms blankglyph/armor-ignoringtouch,5of6slain. Spendingloop42517847\u219224922~7075keys mostlyunaffordableskillmenu;agent426costcachefix. InnerLight24965XP1035\u219235;StaffLight/2attacks24986kills, stale broadShadowguard433haltsondeathmessage then434narrows. FullpackOrcishLiquor25896cleanup3spareKiteShields25916pickup25917;50026130HP59keys26129nofrontier,SilverStaff26133cowers. Current T9 unfinished/T10notstarted, no cap inference. Additional row0 histories397/411 andprinted combat/Light prefixes399/417/418/421/423/427/428/431/432 plus415publicmetadatapending sourceprojectionmatch; broad controller allnewrecords0diff andclip413retainedends checked.", "Final continuity439tools45texts47summaries exact; all42new calls440\u2013481,12texts46\u201357 and2summaries48\u201349 fully read. T9 MahoganyUnderstanding26139identifyAntidote26143/TrueSight+Weakness446, staffempty26157ShadowHP53; Song3train26170TrueSight26174HP44,Light+fight26195ShadowdeadHP33. nav450None terrain errorfixed451; returnroute equipsMithrilGauntlets by26382prot8\u201323,Shadowkill26402HP45,Delvingslearn26409/sing26412. Shadow26759HP44flee26834new500areaHP59; nav459stairfailure handlingfix and460depth1000comma fix. Shadow27016HP44fight461kill27047HP30,nav462dies27086HP0.463last35row0history shows SnowTrollkilled27066 and newShadowdownstairs27053; ShadowtoucheslostamongMore normalmessageblank, restloopnativefatalpending. T10 controller464EVENTSpreservesmessages acrossMore;465remedychecks dangers but excludes tears from list; birthFingolfin2/3/6/3M5E6Smith3Will1Song1XP600,Armour57Challenge64. Blindtrap190waituntil201full59;100413caltropSlowclears424; forge1470Tanglethorn7attack1471\u201377HP52cleared; Leather1489/equip1498Shield1510/equip1519Helm1531/equip1541. nav479150\u2192200\u2192250\u2192300final3104Nightthorn-1:1050stepHP36keyZmsgIt tears at you; last30rows3075\u20133104continualunseenattacks. Everygame native death, noescapejewels. Agent causal build/learning claims not endorsed; nativefullT9/T10workspace/supplementalprojections/finaladmission pending. Native read count T1\u20138 unchanged.", "Native T9 all1705lines and T10 all464lines fully read. Native timing supersedes approximate after-action working notes: T9 Final Rest equip15387/identified15417, Hauberk Nogrod17475, Lug killed8759, floor collapse16066-69 reaches500. Swordplay Gauntlets26301 grant Parry26302/03. Sulrauko destroyed26999, Shadow27085 kills. T10 actual depths100385/1501583/2001698/2502062/3002348; forged Leather equip1494, Shield1515, Helm1537. Unseen serpent killed3006; Nightthorn tears begin3007 and kill3103/3104 while controller rests. Murky Brown potion2570 is present but not natively identified there. All43759 replay frames exact; further fatal-key/source projections/workspace/admission pending.", "Final workspace all14Python? exactfilecounttoverify plus2Markdown staticallyread; RUN_NOTES ongoingclaims outdated, finalresultsJSONexactprotectedsummary. Source finalrun T10 emergency list omits tears and restguard does likewise. Fatal77keysT9f27010\u201386+125keysT10f2980\u20133104fullyread. T9newShadow27053,14Z27068\u201385afterSnowTrollkill,Morecleans warnings. T10unseenserpentkilled3006thenNightthorntears3007,allsubsequentturnactionsZ (except4inventorykeys),HP55\u2192-1. NativeHUD3flags are menuoverlays allfull+adjacentviewsread/resolved separately; raw reviewer retained.", "Final review complete: 13Python+2Markdown staticallyread and hashverified. 882 supplemental native checks plus91 older projectionlines all exact;8adversarial controls passed. Full extra fatalwindows1(36)/4(36)/5(29)/6(40)/7(37)/8(36) read: T1 16Z1017\u20131032 unseenarchery; T4 twoTrolls plusWolves despitekillingone1937; T5Dexnothealing and7attacks;T6NWattacks thenWretreat thenElbereth5HPcharged;T7Challengeagitation/moving3;T8quickness+songlateandWattacks. T2eightZ fatalalreadyread, T3all36keyspreviouslybound. No native, service, scorer, interface or scaffold error found;3HUDmenuclassifier flags and1lexicalboundaryflag explicitlyresolved benign. 4agentcodeerrors5/256/355/450;242deliberatecontrollerinterruptcorrected equipmentrecursion without reset/retirement. Clip1manual plus198/242/413 visible retainedends/source read; omittedmiddle never treated as modelobserved. All10nativedeaths, largest27085keys and10315.074s/43200, cost282.301945/1200,0compactions/0modelerrors/0missingusage/0resourcecaps. All pending live-review questions resolved by final evidence; no session learning-causality claim." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 43759, "exact_replayed_frames": 43759, "matching_public_views": 40951, "unique_full_json_frames": 40938, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 552, "additional_signals": 552, "supplemental_native_projection_checks": 882, "older_projection_lines": 91, "native_hud_menu_flags_resolved": 3, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 282.301945, "evidence_sha256": { "assistant_text.json": "b7b0bbf0a01faa6c858d1f93555f099f089d44321fa2b4eafdd69fc8c53c0dc7", "audited-reading-proof.json": "addd2cacb337f450ec9cd768ce6f184852ad623cf6a8074e45f9b00c4b9be48a", "available_reasoning_summaries.json": "6934df38c7221a5ae6aabee1a1ea47bf4da24462f9347f755c211681bd71087b", "hud-findings-review.json": "c81a103a4d7f14bb6170a0589653f1eb629e6d39a0a980917a5bad6b39520a4f", "live-final-review-continuity.json": "bca1be5b090df2e5b37c16cf0699f6b2a5ef70fd681a44250aeede24de647390", "manifest.json": "83fb7526695b48c81fa016e2a6843a1ec7409413087931c47d50fdd978953bd8", "native-review-working.json": "9a564069bf028cdad9cdb734c0bae2b8546a52efe9b442967a5b7ad7bb8e4af1", "projection-counterexamples.json": "e1d85798c79e65b406277fdea38bdcddd209eabb1100fd9dcdbad4073937d0f0", "public_observation_audit.json": "0d1b06a4e7a03ab0b2a0836dd140c9f60a14a889a0e0e73a28efb56f569931ee", "qualitative-working.json": "bc7b5405d8f7b535afaa06d7ba79e05cb6d159005717e731fff851fe49ce8236", "replay.json": "082403f0bcbe0e98af196b23b8335cd3e30adb2fe00c79c362ee0ad8d469b6cf", "review.json": "d478cacd176dce83b58db26ffb71d71707816dc4dab983d2a9e66c2005a9377f", "source-read-audit.json": "b04ceb27a757a253ca44ad29a2565495641c4d5608de26d8fd3e8e3305d7d71b", "state/events.jsonl": "8112e921c1b428c5a941c98c249bf90363882a0c6869dfdfafee6f810050e305", "state/summary.json": "71c11cfd18e14529469069edc2d654ce531d3ba3fd9ba53e637413dd369154fd", "tool_calls_complete.json": "44400d4230b7bd422971df21e93ff4ff0973fab2c52adc5acca7813b9cb74d69", "tool_review_coverage.json": "e5e9d12fa11663909eab3065924b6f755f371e3305d76087699d91c6db6e854c", "trial01-fatal-key-review.json": "b700261465906cd9d358e37da2ddb6345355f7aa486dca1ce33995bc75223602", "trial01-native-messages.txt": "7c631543173938f7eb383379119d902ab857b1ec0658fc3ef48c1158b69b807d", "trial02-native-messages.txt": "76a4dbfe600a15d11e3098772a5b4a1ae8a95a874fe807485d979bb30b56450c", "trial03-fatal-key-review.json": "7e7f8ca4312c0f29efef937a91c2349e790808a3988f6586dcea8c7ff3d2844f", "trial03-native-messages.txt": "b5092c44c550aeda3ee77ee6c472684f15a2ed626dfcc831f9e6fefd84dca86e", "trial04-fatal-key-review.json": "08b475030ee75afeed74643328fbf8ff0277a6c2d0eeee7ab3aacc8edb137972", "trial04-native-messages.txt": "52e652211d35941cea3a3ec4b262dbcdb1714f95c8c518434f7693a8857c6847", "trial05-fatal-key-review.json": "c6c0dcf462fac37e3b722895c5d2deb76894ecb62fcd64d1247a23cf6fe986e7", "trial05-native-messages.txt": "5e92a988d7332b6685baf75377af17d6ce0f5956a6e824644546800e9d525192", "trial06-fatal-key-review.json": "ba22966bd3fba5e85aa5fc8f730e64a27be54ca6cdf47c3aec6e4aa21a64a99b", "trial06-native-messages.txt": "e8ecd99a482f60e587273a6ff51406b51ff985afe65466d719920f7b0e095efe", "trial07-fatal-key-review.json": "5ea950b97a6dc44f6120c6b1b7185e0ddd3ce2080bef5c91b0aae61fa29926cb", "trial07-native-messages.txt": "c1def9045683d8d9077311163b80d450b41ee0138f23f32d94459531cb7d0f96", "trial08-fatal-key-review.json": "085436fe674cb295594e625b4d7cea721be4bf52f725d6de40f925cdd35a32f3", "trial08-native-messages.txt": "014b1c6dfd73d4eb9a389549c4cc7cf73f11448de2ad965b2353718d95625149", "trial09-fatal-key-review.json": "7f57866b2b2c48970b79997b2a54cc3be1ea6f1405d0d57ab3fdd4eb9200b6bf", "trial09-native-messages.txt": "4dee6bf9b9001438944029d189713fe8a4a348fad2d430a821a995bb1bf7a487", "trial10-fatal-key-review.json": "c5f311a8101d15da63a53b9d64f9a26ad57ae7f77504620e6f9f713fa61b316d", "trial10-native-messages.txt": "f1ab5ec69a04545a67f5faf02ce58aa039f00b39ca5295a3852688691f686c4f", "v3-controller-audit.json": "dbfefbfdfef1484bfa9c1ca54d5025c8c66fff7d6a8a62ca39255c0782d97813", "v3-medium03-projection-audit.json": "a3d84979b5a1d6cd2fb0f71c39233ddc41a6f765914b1335198348db4c049e39", "v3-native-projection-audit.json": "27b57841f23c829142f825aa4c69d0bac7aa7993b0054413d7a042abd30bcbc8", "workspace-file-review.json": "63863e73fd8c06e99153a2734eaea3ffeeab4795063b2a5aa167b6ba006f5d25", "workspace-snapshot.json": "0f97de6c6c8956024d627ecd398ef2a31bdf7b1f5c51dfe07d7c7685a042b329" } }, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "83fb7526695b48c81fa016e2a6843a1ec7409413087931c47d50fdd978953bd8", "qualitative_review.json": "20a5102185145b96e5aeaa3af25ae9986ebd58f7ca4f62fecb80b2872c9ce3b1", "review.json": "d478cacd176dce83b58db26ffb71d71707816dc4dab983d2a9e66c2005a9377f", "replay.json": "082403f0bcbe0e98af196b23b8335cd3e30adb2fe00c79c362ee0ad8d469b6cf", "state/summary.json": "71c11cfd18e14529469069edc2d654ce531d3ba3fd9ba53e637413dd369154fd" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-medium-04", "condition": "astra-medium", "bundle": 4, "admitted": true, "status": "complete_valid", "best": 0, "mean": 0.0, "scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 2554, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 729.5284223556519, "keys_used": 2120 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -6, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 675, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 83.51438093185425, "keys_used": 943 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 345, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 10.722332000732422, "keys_used": 488 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc thrallmaster", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 216, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 72.12371897697449, "keys_used": 380 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 6340, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1581.978175163269, "keys_used": 10529 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 627, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 237.22089958190918, "keys_used": 2042 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Wolf", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 155, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 182.8405318260193, "keys_used": 254 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Nightthorn", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 3428, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1441.1262183189392, "keys_used": 4900 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Shadow", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1065, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 395.4703004360199, "keys_used": 1562 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 1710, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1022.6364085674286, "keys_used": 2535 } ], "requests": 407, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1221, "input_tokens_cache_write": 364685, "input_tokens_cache_read": 73090330, "output_tokens": 132367, "reasoning_tokens": 85308 }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 117.309616, "peak_request_input_tokens": 364688, "scaffold": { "captured_at": 1788827608.1148095, "model_context_windows": [ 997500 ], "last_session_timestamp": "2026-09-08T00:33:06.213Z", "compactions_observed": 0, "scope": "last read-only live snapshot; authoritative full model history remains in Inspect" }, "rejected_requests": 2, "execution_failures": [ { "call_id": "call_hT2KucGpLxIaGNRA6vgUqjLj", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_O3OYJ7LtDjqOk6vqHUcklO9w", "function": "exec", "category": "command_nonzero" }, { "call_id": "call_WZIQdIOU2GhZmr2Hqe9wZCZw", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_2poaXDJWKRr7GNgv1cIwIhQg", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_rXmuvAX9pXhLGmmtkCrLn4ao", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_WmcpSeD6AuJBbsJ1y4chiC2C", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" } ], "structured_tool_errors": [], "replayed_frames": 25763, "qualitative_review": { "reviewed_at": 1788828601.0294888, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 407, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 42, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 46, "tool_calls_reviewed": 406, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_eaR1uk9Sgr10f8QWntZ4MLxH", "call_rf0CGzGFzXF11LonOqv7lXl2" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1, 195 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; saturation gate requires all ten sessions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 2554, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 729.5284223556519, "keys_used": 2120 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -6, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 675, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 83.51438093185425, "keys_used": 943 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 345, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 10.722332000732422, "keys_used": 488 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc thrallmaster", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 216, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 72.12371897697449, "keys_used": 380 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 6340, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1581.978175163269, "keys_used": 10529 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 627, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 237.22089958190918, "keys_used": 2042 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Wolf", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 155, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 182.8405318260193, "keys_used": 254 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Nightthorn", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 3428, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1441.1262183189392, "keys_used": 4900 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Shadow", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1065, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 395.4703004360199, "keys_used": 1562 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 1710, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1022.6364085674286, "keys_used": 2535 } ], "notes": [ "All406 tool arguments/results,42 visible assistant messages and46 available reasoning summaries were read. The404 reviewed live calls match completed export exactly;405\u2013406 and2final texts were read from the hashed completed reading copy. All distinct native messages/depth transitions across10trials were reviewed; dedicated fatal-action sequences were read for trials8\u201310. Full replay compares every raw frame. This is root-agent review, not independent human review.", "Call1 clipped the bundled manual at a model-selected output allowance; guide and retained manual ends exactly match frozen source. Subsequent manual ranges150\u2013560,560\u2013950 and950\u20131040 match. Call195 omitted32tokens/128characters from native trial5frame7223rows10\u201312; every retained prefix/suffix character matches, and the complete frame remained in the public history. No omitted text is represented as model-seen.", "Trial1: Fingolfin3/3/5/3 melee7/evasion6, initially49HP. Agent unpicklable regex state failed and was repaired. Early plant damage was escaped by moving away and resting. Quarterstaff, studded leather, bow, boots, gauntlets and BattleAxe improved equipment; Strength in Adversity and fresh torches were used. At250ft unseen arrows caused low health; unidentified Poison and Blindness potions preceded native poison death.", "Trial2: Fingolfin2/4/5/3 melee6/evasion5/perception3/will3/song1 with Strength in Adversity, Elbereth and Keen Senses. A bow was found but no body armour. At100ft Elbereth began at low health, followed by continued fighting and native Orc soldier death. Trial3: Feanorian smithing6 investment, Armoursmith and boots; a found GreatHelm remained unused while Mewlip/Orc attacks killed the character at100ft before forging.", "Trial4: Finarfin1/4/4/5 evasion3/stealth6/perception3/song5 and Silence. An uninitialized flee field was fixed, then player colours were corrected. This build died to an Orc thrallmaster at150ft. These trajectories do not establish that stealth or singing is ineffective.", "Trial5: Feanor3/3/4/4 melee5/evasion5/smithing4 with Armoursmith and Power. It forged Mail Corslet2d5, Boots1d2 and Helm1d3, later adding a cloak. Mewlip attacks, disarms, torch loss, temporary unarmed states and multi-thousand-key navigation/prompt loops were visible. Native Elbereth sometimes caused fleeing; doors permitted recovery. The agent repaired target switching and friendly-thrall collisions. It remained at250ft despite minimum-depth pressure reaching300ft. At final combat a Troll died, but another Troll and Orc warrior killed it. A subsequent action was correctly rejected after terminal state.", "Trial6: Finarfin with Song8, Silence and Lorien. A controller initially parsed map characters on the song row as the active song; restricting the field corrected it. Native messages demonstrate enemies falling asleep and waking. No armour was obtained before Orc attacks and Brood spider poison at150ft; native final cause was Orc soldier. Trial7: Feanorian smithing and Power/Elbereth start, no completed craft; boots remained unused, wolves reduced health and killed it at50ft.", "Trial8: Feanor2/5/4/3 melee6/evasion7 reached300ft. Finesse, Dodging, Delvings and later Flanking were acquired; studded leather, boots, cloak and shields improved protection. A low-health retreat from200ft used a Herb of Terror, doors and upstairs recovery. The final native cause was an unseen Nightthorn. After the first unseen encounter, the controller issued31wait-5 actions among inspection/menu commands; health fell to-1. A visible-monster-dependent stop rule missed the threat. The original observations and attack messages were intact.", "Trial9, first scored game: same high-Dexterity melee build with Elbereth. Plant retreats/doors worked and Finesse was learned. A Crystal Amulet equipped at1384 was identified as Haunted Dreams at1478\u201380. At150ft a Shadow damaged the character; it removed the amulet at1551HP22, moved northwest1555HP16, then a travel route repeatedly attacked the unseen adjacent Shadow eastward until death1563HP-1. Travel then attempted another action and received the correct409. Haunted Dreams preceded the encounter; this uncontrolled trajectory is not a causal ablation.", "Trial10, second scored game: high-Dexterity melee/Elbereth build, shield and gauntlets, full health at300ft. A Sword spider caused a drop to21HP; Blocking was learned, the spider fled and doors/rest restored full health. The first MountainTroll died at2304. Equipping a Greatsword removed the shield, followed by106invalid adjacent-door-close attempts. Crucial correction to the agent report: the large drop to15HP at2470 was arrow damage; the recorded Orc charge at2488 occurred after the shield was restored. Liquor healed before further attacks. Continued fighting/retreat reached4HP; an inventory-letter shift led to a second Slowness potion, then BrownPoison and a Herb of Entrancement. Native poison death occurred at300ft, with no Silmaril or escape.", "All407 raw requests and responses verify Astra medium with128000 output allowance and997500 effective context. Peak input364688, no compaction, model errors, missing usage or structured tool errors. Six shell/code failures were reviewed: missing requests library(5), unpicklable regex state(19), missing flee attribute(110), post-death action(236), definition ordering NameError(329), post-death travel action(361). None is an evaluation infrastructure failure. Both rejected service calls were no-live-trial409after native death. No protected-state or external-network boundary attempt was found.", "All25763native frames were captured as full public observations and replayed exactly. General audit verifies25798views; controller audit verifies25768HTTPrecords covering25751unique frames and435numbered screens. The12frames absent from custom HTTPhistory were available in CLIhistory. Supplemental audits verify68message/nearby lines and65action traces plus position/adjacency/colour fields. Controller path/visit/target/avoid/memory outputs are inferences; three explicitly recorded memory cells differed from current native blanks, as expected from source. No inferred cell is relabelled as a visible observation.", "Final Python files and report were read statically; all code modifications were already read in tool history. Final save-results source exactly matches its visible here-document and saved result JSON matches protected summary. Snapshot102973342bytes,0omissions. The controller markdown overstates some strategic lessons and misorders the final charge; research conclusions use native evidence instead. Agent code was never executed on the host, and no hints were supplied.", "No resource guard bound:10native deaths,25753total keys, per-game maximum10529keys and1581.978174seconds, estimated request-priced cost117.309616dollars below1200. No voluntary retirement, replacement, missing game, throne-room visit, Silmaril or escape. Admission of this one session does not establish the ten-session saturation gate or a causal learning effect.", "Reviewer-only corrections were tested: high-health Hth alias coverage, native projection boundary cases, and exact distinction of remembered cells. Root stdout redirection overlapped three JSON review artifacts; original bytes were archived and exact report equivalence verified before restoring valid JSON. Native journals, replay results, game/scaffold and model observations were unchanged. See public review_artifact_io_repairs and counterexample reports." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 25763, "exact_replayed_frames": 25763, "matching_public_views": 25798, "unique_full_json_frames": 25763, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 435, "supplemental_native_history_lines": 68, "action_trace_steps": 65, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 117.309616, "evidence_sha256": { "assistant_text.json": "ef5ced7d4fb295c2ee907312307fe1a6ae72d7e48dca477d016329c0ecce38fc", "audited-reading-proof.json": "0b53af33b2884c019843f36d343dfc9083ed972294b05ebf1132c81b2ea5201a", "available_reasoning_summaries.json": "bef70cebaa2745a23e04cfaf0d9f76f99c334a79cc294134dab9af5ed9929fbb", "live-final-review-continuity.json": "1d39995528b34e2e9cd49b61e37fa0e5764eb7b75f821198e3942f7dbb32ab8b", "manifest.json": "bd0443a6a2f7830f405803e43c4921ea0ed4d5b92955f48f0e2443425940a452", "native-review-working.json": "e7ac1efafc66064ba6ba4bde742dda617ccf0d2946f840e8cdac44b9486191f4", "public_observation_audit.json": "e0ea91bfd0196aefa03309b11f477423868584fbe1651d49055d9edb98fa5f9a", "qualitative-working.json": "ea89caeda4472e86a3983b0ee4f3aa005a73154897ddf460d5f28bc73aa830ce", "replay.json": "c25a3508a5b485bd94d816a57e599e6e70ddf0fe1ecfafe4a7eee5cd947bb516", "review.json": "ebd8a72a7c9128fb98d0b5d7408de1ce29ba74b57cdc8afc487b7fd6b91e2534", "source-read-audit.json": "ec8a46b97acfa2ada2320c6036d349f7fc39c174677412c043b747dbd3b764de", "state/events.jsonl": "e2133f2665b405e5e0d6663cd4734e90e942a466cca13037ee3085e4b1617ddc", "state/summary.json": "b458901c6570b496b28c7d6a1f1fd678b2c2bb86fca6be00647e6a9af554adf3", "tool_calls_complete.json": "1fa27f0d1724fbcac274300b941756015069a941673dcdec808fd2893f9da40c", "tool_review_coverage.json": "b02c4c30b298dc6f4540e1d881d20f6f1964c4c30cb14b65c79a6a1b88e85d40", "trial01-native-messages.txt": "796cdf23ea1cbc1c981b52a3af8efe8d73a1df73d4d31d8862069fa7c1ec7e7a", "trial02-native-messages.txt": "8bb6626e33aa5ce828c5f7fc87d6c5ec113d2f196c4afd5fe2679533408b4979", "trial03-native-messages.txt": "1976c4925121a6cd2308fd9e7f3f4836767892ce343ccfb7d5e4c55246222228", "trial04-native-messages.txt": "198bb87461fde648963c925f67f55518fb3b835417dc02d7d4d1d1c74ea25ec4", "trial05-native-messages.txt": "b145e74508cb0bfacd5fe1033cc2e3296712fcbef003c35412515712566eb705", "trial06-native-messages.txt": "d84940ee26726c5fbe6dc4805c9ac503f930574a12c139ba7063cc4c96cd3c47", "trial07-native-messages.txt": "40263f49d77c6fbf78be29d7c63361dc64b542bdd1a5914043205e54641f22d2", "trial08-fatal-key-review.json": "b01cfab1e76bd7fefe3fba657e5b02512f6b62da1ade790dd94d9619b7653ac1", "trial08-native-messages.txt": "9bcca1879efc9d65640c7f2c6dedbde6a7ba683303fdc58191c4f759f2c7da07", "trial09-fatal-key-review.json": "7a5524eecfcd2e073dbb39f697e6d4ebf9717a181293e4993a154da74d1e8c47", "trial09-native-messages.txt": "edf77a4b76f664f88060e6ff8c5b295a326ac03c8bc07954ac570b94f55edbe3", "trial10-fatal-key-review.json": "e00e5d051884374ef842b6eea171d6ccd3d5163731c4e8121079d1a15c531535", "trial10-native-messages.txt": "911a4ae220c6d425ef0adbd4664eadf5f4bc05e8b6f8722a3cbde9bdac47ce4a", "v3-controller-audit.json": "198d215896c5b69afcf6b40d9849ce30e4c7a341cc1b0bc72304dbf772a38e2c", "v3-medium04-projection-audit.json": "96523786050e105d53bffe9a982736e8dcf8f5094ee10ed801d08a287b7d645e", "v3-native-projection-audit.json": "4b85a7c3a150e1748570790b2e59e6f1405eb388f1840eec6574f352e99b6375", "workspace-file-review.json": "a8011862107ef8a72166d24880d1a57ee0f1015e9c734b3a538733a8ed11be99", "workspace-snapshot.json": "10d348d9bf3e51f659b261af672e15cc13363d4eade09c8ff0be0f84dcbdd9ca" } }, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "bd0443a6a2f7830f405803e43c4921ea0ed4d5b92955f48f0e2443425940a452", "qualitative_review.json": "458c45cd3c87aa9ae9cf0576867218cadac9bd831b67540f4759f47cc326fd19", "review.json": "ebd8a72a7c9128fb98d0b5d7408de1ce29ba74b57cdc8afc487b7fd6b91e2534", "replay.json": "c25a3508a5b485bd94d816a57e599e6e70ddf0fe1ecfafe4a7eee5cd947bb516", "state/summary.json": "b458901c6570b496b28c7d6a1f1fd678b2c2bb86fca6be00647e6a9af554adf3" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-medium-05", "condition": "astra-medium", "bundle": 5, "admitted": true, "status": "complete_valid", "best": 0, "mean": 0.0, "scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -13, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 2746, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 641.4870038032532, "keys_used": 2807 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -12, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 385, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 92.525559425354, "keys_used": 439 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mewlip", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1892, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 241.48505330085754, "keys_used": 1990 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -10, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 4433, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 850.2071290016174, "keys_used": 4026 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 3869, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 525.1663255691528, "keys_used": 3627 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Orcobal, Champion of the Orcs", "depth_feet": 400, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -9, "max_depth_feet": 400, "player_turns": 6745, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1819.3094370365143, "keys_used": 8930 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a fatal wound", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 536, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 212.12240767478943, "keys_used": 626 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Wolf", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 809, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 843.2796747684479, "keys_used": 1251 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc skirmisher", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -7, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 353, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 481.61000752449036, "keys_used": 822 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mewlip", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1640, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 594.848504781723, "keys_used": 3139 } ], "requests": 385, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1155, "input_tokens_cache_write": 349307, "input_tokens_cache_read": 64630517, "output_tokens": 138088, "reasoning_tokens": 91842 }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 96.056586, "peak_request_input_tokens": 349310, "scaffold": { "captured_at": 1788828136.2161515, "model_context_windows": [ 997500 ], "last_session_timestamp": "2026-09-08T00:41:44.730Z", "compactions_observed": 0, "scope": "last read-only live snapshot; authoritative full model history remains in Inspect" }, "rejected_requests": 0, "execution_failures": [ { "call_id": "call_zbKhsMCo0HlP1utQuPQTZlTE", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_H1PFJZ4XmOuBFFDCO1TniowR", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_Q8HjSNbXf6eRTbix1i2999BY", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_P0ZE3sra4cWcjjjYe5JHcdws", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_mXL6gRimRKyoLe5vhXy0Ipwr", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_bSs9x45llLoY6i6oMbs9z92D", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_pka2lf2Apk8AMzDJA0tlOunw", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" } ], "structured_tool_errors": [], "replayed_frames": 27667, "qualitative_review": { "reviewed_at": 1788829836.1005597, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 385, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 25, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 47, "tool_calls_reviewed": 384, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_djLuED6DAdUiy69FzRK9895u" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; saturation gate requires all ten sessions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -13, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 2746, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 641.4870038032532, "keys_used": 2807 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -12, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 385, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 92.525559425354, "keys_used": 439 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mewlip", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1892, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 241.48505330085754, "keys_used": 1990 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -10, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 4433, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 850.2071290016174, "keys_used": 4026 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 3869, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 525.1663255691528, "keys_used": 3627 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Orcobal, Champion of the Orcs", "depth_feet": 400, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -9, "max_depth_feet": 400, "player_turns": 6745, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1819.3094370365143, "keys_used": 8930 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a fatal wound", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 536, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 212.12240767478943, "keys_used": 626 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Wolf", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 809, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 843.2796747684479, "keys_used": 1251 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc skirmisher", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -7, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 353, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 481.61000752449036, "keys_used": 822 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mewlip", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1640, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 594.848504781723, "keys_used": 3139 } ], "notes": [ "Initial visible texts and available summaries read. Live model/effort/output allowance and997500clientwindow verified; full request audit still required. Repeated immutable guide/manual source already read during development; exact excerpts and retained clipped ends independently verified by source_checked_review. Clipping remains explicit; no omitted middle is presumed visible.", "Read tools1\u201318 in full except independently source-checked repeated guide/manual. Call5 missing requests before action;6 urllib fix. Fingolfin3/4/4/2 M6 Eva6 Per2 XP500, Aerin normal41 HP41; buys Finesse confirmed46. Sparse uppercase TRIAL/STATUS and ATTR need exact supplemental audit. All code read.", "Read tools19\u201389 complete code/output (full attributes independently native-matched and labelled in separate reading copy); read all7 visible texts and25 available summaries through request85. Tool90 had no result yet, so is not marked complete. Custom ATTR changed to coordinates-only CURSOR at23, explicit native comparison passes. No game/interface edits.", "T1: 250-ft Orc-warrior death HP-13,2808 frames. Direct Orc scout hits221/223 reduce41\u219215; retreat1/c closes233, Z repeated restores and fighting resumes. Robe collected576 equipped818; Leather collected1732 equipped1846; Cloak1726\u21921850. Fresh torch1841 after gone-out1719; next torch gone2276 was not replaced beforedeath. Navigation blank/scroll fixes50\u201352 but long two-position oscillation1258\u20131660;216 afraid attack no-turn loop1947\u20132162 then wait fix60. Stuck-door repetitions232+34, bash fix61 works2527. 250 entry2614full41; enemy group down stairs2725. HP12 at2758, retreat4 then Vermilion tried noheal, Sparkling Slowness2767, late Greatsword2774; Grey Terror2780 temporarily speeds, Pale/Thorny tried without healing, retreat to upstair fails Orc charges2805/2807. Unused StuddedLeather/Greaves in2760 inventory. Counterfactual bettergear not established.", "T2 same3/4/4/2 M6Eva6Will2 (public birth key sequence); Power normal49. Call79 automatic train/loadout based solely public inventory/equipment, every70frames only without letter enemies. Armor collected399 remains unused amid enemies. FullHP41 enters100318 then150352. Blindness350 cleared367. Orcgroup425\u2013427HP8; Violet tried431 HP3, PaleGreen Slowness437 and Orcsoldier439death terminal440HP-12. Noidentifiedhealing. No armor equipped.", "T3 newFinarfin1/4/4/5, Eva5 Stealth5 Per2 Song6, Elbereth normal56. Reviewed native all214distinctmessages/2depthtransitions, but subsequent tools stillpending. 50\u2192100703; boots110 gauntlets864 Leather1149 Cloak1433. Frequent song starts successfully frighten Mewlip/Orcs; start/end loops987\u20131301 exhaust/recover voice, need controller continuation review. Torches replaced1145/1486; exhausted residues1796/1829/1847; invisible attacks1975\u20131990death. AllT1(258),T2(107),T3(214) distinct native messages and depth transitions read; normal HUD has0differences after reviewer regex fixed to accept native Health-13/Health-12. Exact closed-trial replay5239frames already passed.", "Read90\u2013243 all code/output and all15visibletexts/37available summaries throughreq244. No game/scaffold changes. T3Singer90 avoid/chasechanges;91fourteenrows14tupleprojectionpending;92five decisionprojections shows31,15\u219430,14oscillation;93persistentgoalfix.100recoveryfrom22HP1326to41HP1604, then fulltorchexhaustion.10330row0/HP/statusprojections1962\u20131991 show unseenattacks after1975 and rest1985/1989;Mewlipdeath1991HP-3,1892turns1990keys. Nativefatalkeys needexplicitcheck; all214messagegroups alreadyread. NonfatalSyntaxWarnings95 retained.", "T4hybridFinarfin1/4/4/5 birth71HP41 M5Eva5Per3Will2Song3 inferredkeysequence, confirmnativeinitialskills;Power+KeenSenses+Elbereth.100plant318HP17\u21923/2retreatclose322 andZ323HP24/Mewlipcomes;326HP19\u21928/8Mewlipflees328\u2192full448.114200by1190;1360\u20131763 nopath/adjacentcombatandwaitsHP13.118banlogicand120enemytraverse/nearrestfix,121screenboundarypriority.200SwordSpider2526HP21\u2192retreat3/3/6/6, Beechstaff2534tried,Grey2538noheal,DarkGreenTerror2543HP10;E/Nretreatto<2567 yields1502568HP11,2002698recovers.3096unseenclaw35/deadtorch,3103freshTorchHP29\u2192song3108\u219241HP3162;3844killsMewlip.151unseenhitguardreducedthen152removedarrowcase;3923WeakHP20\u2192Lembas3926strength1restored.3976HP11 corridorretreat/Elbereth/close3979+Z3982,3986Orcwarriorreturns,3992HP11\u2192west4007HP15\u2192staff4011/retreat4014arrowHP9. Smoky4022SlowHP2, song+2death4027OrcWarriorHP-10,4433turns4026keys. No bodyarmor (Helm+Greaves2\u20134 only) throughend. NativeallmessagesT4pending.", "T5Feanor3/4/4/3 M6Eva5Will2Smith3 frombirthkeys,Power+Armoursmithnormal61XP0.100332HP21group\u21929fightto33816HP;Song2/Elbereth36014HP,fear361,1812tile songtrigger/nonadjrest/feed;forge626full41Studded1\u20136.Helm0,1d2draftoverbudget634reduced635complete638;Gauntlets0,1d1complete647;Boots0,1d2completebefore672fullwear4\u201311.100navloops778\u20131096/1811\u20132129 correctedblockedterrain/recentgoals204,1502366,2002613,2502813nativeentry.2938HP15Wolves/Orcs\u2192fight2 andrest recovers3053HP41.210Weaponsmith3062bought500,211forge300planunreached;unseenarchery3437HP32\u21923543HP28\u21923628OrcArcherdeathHP-3,3869turns3627keys. All361nativemessagegroupsstillpending.", "T6Feanor3/4/4/3M6Eva6Smith2 birth58Armoursmithfailsprereq3 at56,214trainSmith3+freeability atforge100308;Shield0,1d4/Helm0,1d2complete thenBoots interrupted353.215 intentionallythrows Forgeinterrupted,217killscout363,218Resume showsBoots29turnsleft,219resumeandwear3784\u201312.220autoGreatswordthenShield522/523unarms,539+repeated[yn]movementcanceledthrough1202,22376row0/attack/bellprojectionpending.225twohandblacklist/confirmationstop,CurvedSword1208.100scrollboundaryoscillation2059\u20133134,232eightdecisionprojections alternating47,16\u219447,9;233persistentgoal+234offscreenmemory fixes,Blocking4055bought500.236100\u2192200by4166,4431unarmedpromptagainGreatSpear4416\u2192Shield4417;23736nonemptyrow0projections4364\u20134431pending.239addGreatSpearblacklist/Longsword4438.241cleanupdrop then242Quantity(0\u20133)unrecognized repeated4 to5324,243promptguard/quantityEnter drops3Shortbows5325. Agent code errors promptlyexposed bynative prompts; subsequentnativeT6reviewstillpending. Supplemental91/92/103/117/118/119/155/221/223/230/232/237/238 publicprojections or inferredmemory to audit.244pending.", "Read all364/361 distinctnative messagegroups anddepthtransitionsT4/T5. T4actualentries100294,150936,2001076,up1502567,back2002588; priornoteslaterframes areobservationpoints. Greaves1219Helm2258onlyarmor, no bodyarmor. Torches2000at1006/2598/3103,1215at3677,161at3842,138at3910,128at3958;Mewlip threatenslight repeatedly. T5Studded585,Helm664Gauntlets668Boots672;craftBootscomplete656. Repeatedupstairattempt1194/2166 unabletoascendminimums,notreset. Nativeconfirms allfights inclTroll3028slain,secondTrollfleesup3289; extensiveunseenarchery2831\u20133627 andfinaldeath3628. NoidentifiedhealingconsumptionT5; food2984/2985 works. Nativefullreplay12894framesT1\u20135exact;0normalHUDdifferences.", "Fatal key review trial03-fatal-key-review.json: all22keys/frames1970\u20131991read,9Z+9More throughunseenMewlipattacks, nativeHP may precedeMoreHUD faithfully. T5 trial05-fatal-key-review.json saves249items3380\u20133628;212Z counted, everyHP-changeandfinal13read, notclaimall249textread. All distinctnativeT5messagesalreadyread. Supplemental native projection audit proves169lines91/103/223/230/237 exact.", "Tools244\u2013305 fully read in verifiedcompacttext,306pending. All17texts42available summaries read. T6 ranged20-turnmemory245\u2192full5470buttwo@prompt;246color1player5thrall,247filteronlywhitefailsinjuredcolor11at6366diagnostic248;249relaxes5only,250by6488and300by6622HP25. close6626Z6627interrupted,6728forgeexplorationcannotcraftlight(no forge,JewellerreqSmith4vs3); no illegitimateitemcreated. Unseenarrowguards260/261loweredstop,7014HP15Dex1TatteredWight+2TrollHummerhorncorner. Crimson7023Poison7, Vermilion7030Grace6, Grey7042SlowHP7; OrcLiquor7050HP16stun. Song3/Elbereth7077, moreLiquor7086HP19/7091HP26. Pale7097Fulldarkensarea,Black7101AfraidSlowclears(noFastshown); Golden7106SelfKnowledge, retreat7108\u20137123HP23, Lantern7134radius2, IvoryAmulet7138, IvoryStaff7142/43WardingGlyph.285KeyErrorstate diagnosticcorrected286native8row0projectionpending. Elbereth7146+wait7150fear, goto7153/55/56/58 andclose/stopsong/Z7167HP33Trollreturns;Will3trained7179HP33thenauto7453full41butEasterling@9unknown\u2192296preferwhiteelseexclude5/9mapenemyh. 300forge7744;Cloak+2difficulty7interrupted7753 (299AssertionErrorcorrectnativeinterrupt,notinterface), Resume775469turns;303retry54keysuntiladjEasterling7807, Elbereth7817fear;305finish_workkills/finishesCloakthenShield+1Boots+1 final7918HP41def11,5\u201314. Dexremains1. NativeT6alltrajectory/replaypending. Supplemental246/248/271INV/2868row0/289ninecoords/291posmonster/295colors/301fiveworkrow0/302colorsplusmappedh stillpending. No scaffoldchanges or root hints.", "Tools306\u2013316 fully read;317pending. All18texts42summaries read. T6Alchemy7921reqPer5currently0, exits7923. Auto3508091/8201/8321/8470/8612full41 withDex1,4008749full\u21928895HP7 surroundedOrcobalandcaptains/warriors. Liquor8903HP18stun; Wardingexam8907glyphmechanics; [8909lists8Orcs. 7attacks8912/8914,315loop parseshp beforefinishedcheck\u2192TypeError NoneType afternative8931deathHP-9 keys8930turns6745max400nojewels. Service316state/overall correctlyterminal. Nativeallmessages/keydetailpending. Inventoryprojection309pending; no scaffold edits or root hints. Agentclaim forgedarmour/Blockingproveduseful remains observational.", "Fully read all853T6 distinctnative messages/depth transitions and119T7. Replay22452framesT1\u20137exact, T67818normalHUD0diff374More434menus, T7488normalHUD0diff31More38menus. T6actual100154, up501246/back1001265, forcedupstair1504082,2004149,1505382/2005398,2506446,3006494,3508032,4008688. InitialShield335/Helm344/Boots366; Studded1d7equipped4092, Gauntlets6352. Quantity4535\u20135324 repeats444444790times;333unarmedprompts539\u20134431. WightDexdrain6982/6998/7002; bothTrollskilled7335/7421 andWight7426, sustainedreturncombatafterearlierrecovery. Secondforge38interrupts353\u20137874mostlylate; Cloak7882 Shield7891 Boots7900completed/equipped7918. 179songselectionprompts7072\u20138866,89Elberethstarttexts plus variants,90ends. Native7099Terror saysmovingfaster,7099Slowcancellation/7101noFastso priorcommentaryspeednotindependentlyestablished; later7121slowdown7146speedup. Attercoptrance8363\u2192break8365/web8370break8372, later8646webbreak8648. T6all67finalkeys8865\u20138931read:3f8872charge41\u219230,7attacksnarrowspace27/24\u219211f8890\u21927f8894. Liquor8899/8901raises18, inventory/examineWarding8904\u20138907nogameturn, 7killsCaptain8915, otherCaptain8916HP16Orcobal8919HP7, continuing7attacksfinalOrcobal8930HP-9. Terminal8931nativeexact. T7forge581HP41nogearbody, interrupted590/593/596; attacks597\u2013610againstOrcs/Mewlip\u2192HP9f611; BrownSlowness617thenMewlipHP1f622; q625choosesb626sameidentifiedBrownSlowness (inventorylettershift), fatalwoundHP0 terminal627turn536. All47T7finalkeys581\u2013627readandretained; T7controllercode/decisionreviewstillpending.", "Tools317\u2013334 fully read335pending, all19texts44summaries. T7sameFeanorSmithPoweropeningnormal61,318prioritizesPer5Alchemybutxp485atforge581nottrained. Leather0,1d4diff5draft587; finishwork321unsafeat613HP9abort, nofinishedmarker. Inventory322Studded+Gauntletsunequippedconfirmed; BrownSlowness323thenq b324sameBrownlettershiftfatalwound627asnative47keyreview. T8Finarfin1/4/4/5M0Eva4Stealth5Per5Song5(frombirthkeysneednativebirthconfirm),Elbereth+Alchemyfree64,Stealth65. 327allcurrentauto.pyread: incorrectlychecksPoison/Bleedrow26 thoughactual20; unitmapallrow25 andplayercolorheuristic. 328puremarkers, awarenesspublicmonsterlist, emergency identifiedhealing/antidotes parseswholetext, disablesforge/Blocking, reservesDisguise/SilenceLorien, trainsSong8thenstealth, avoidsheavybodyarmor.50Wolves329HP22noarmor, manual4kill332/flee334,close335Z336full.334Dijkstraaddsnearbyenemycost+avoidd door50 andclosebeforeZ; 800loopthrough749full41active. No scaffoldchanges. Supplemental322inventorydictpending. Summary318mentionscompacting but only modelrequestauditcanestablishactualcompaction.", "Extended supplemental native projection audit exact for 182 printed lines; all listed calls/formats/ranges in v3-native-projection-audit-live.json. Reviewer code corrected first-visible-@/None projection in equipment overlay, source endpoint02call2257410\u20137424 (state7425separatelyshown), and tupleformat02call226; no game or agent input changed. Two notes-prefixed screens02calls246/305 independently exact, notes remain agent assertions. Eight original/changedHP/changedCOLOR/wrongframe counterexamples pass in analysis/v3_prefixed_view_counterexamples.json. Other projections still require review.", "Calls335\u2013368 and3texts2summaries fullyread. T8 Melee1train1175Wolfkill1178rest1181full;gotoQuarterstaff1200sleeping/unwary7wolves (awarenessprojection340pending)Stealth1203equip1209, retreat444781221HP36nativeidentifyBrethil1222\u201324,killWolf1228close1229Z1230full. Project348p59,15doorsx<45pending.349togglesStealth/goto36,11route instead returns through wolfroom1239surroundedHP40;fourmanual4attacks1242HP25,1244HP18,1247HP14,1252fatalWolf-1. T9 Finarfin1/4/4/5Eva2Stealth3Song8, nativeSilence/Lorien60/61 noAlchemy, 356Tanglethorn116HP32afterdescent100;357stopstalehp state358updatesbeforeguard. Lorien partialsleepthenalarmcascade713+,782HP22Voice2Shield1\u20136only;ExchangePlacesreq6/Disguisefails785,Assassinationreq4fails786;361inventory4items, WillowSelfKnowledge793emptyattributes795HP17. Melee2train804SongLorienVoice1;36576message/voice projections demonstrate sleep203/433/496/662/669 and repeated startstop12+ pluswarningcalls, pendingexactprojection.3664attack806HP12,367twenty4loopto823terminalSkirmisher-7. FinalT10birthmenuDoriath368notselectedyet;369pending.", "Final tools369\u2013384, three new assistant texts and one available summary fully read. All385requests actual Astra medium128k,997500context peak349310,0compactions/modelerrors/missingusage;384tools,25texts,47summaries. Native T8/9/10 all distinct messages and depth transitions now fully read; all27667nativeframes replay exact,27681publicviews cover all,27655controllerHTTP unique. T8 Mithrim staff identified1223, not Brethil as earlier working note incorrectly called it; wolves kill1251/52. T9 worn Studded Leather161 gives1d6; earlier Shield1\u20136 wording was wrong. Native50f44,100f95; 823terminalOrcSkirmisher-7. T10 native50f46,100f75,150f1369. Wore Studded141,Gloves145,Cloak1022; duplicates in inventory377 do NOT mean body/cloak unequipped (earlier carry-forward statement wrong). Silence41starts, Lorien36starts,787monsterlists; voice exhausted near Mewlips.373fullHP41f2360,374agentIndentationError and376fix;3116HP22, Melee1train3119 then attacks3127HP15cut1,3130HP10/3132HP6. Emerald3136tried no native healing message; Mewlip claws3138/39 fatalHP-4terminal3140. Do not endorse final summary381 Emerald-heals speculation. Controller/SILQ_RESULTS final exact endpoints, note claims strongest improvement observational not causal. Remaining supplemental projections, final workspace static read, fatal keys, resource/boundary/source/admission required. No root hints or game changes.", "Final review complete: all ten native message trajectories and ending outcomes read, plus T8 final22/T9 final29/T10 final43 key records now read. Supplemental auditor exact for6inventory dictionaries, three all-@color projections/cursor/message/health, nine cells, Troll/player, explicit @\u2192h controller mapping,15awareness records, doors,76song/voice lines,24debug positions/keys. Initial reviewer debug range wrongly included early-continue waits/song-casting; corrected to actual print sites1755 and1772\u201376/1781; native and inputs unchanged. Four mutated copies inventory/color/awareness/trace rejected, original passed. Derived maps119/155, remembered underfoot, goal rankings and boolean awareness remain agent inferences, not native fields. All final Python and markdown read statically (backup versions exact diffs); no host execution. Final JSON andCSV match protected summary, finalnotes exact to visible here-doc. Seven agent errors5/215/285/299/315/321/374 all explained by missingrequests, native interruptedforgeassertions, flat-history KeyError, guarded unsafe forge, postdeath NoneHP, or indentation. Full385requests actual medium128k,997500context peak349310 zero compactions/missingusage/modelerrors/boundaryfindings. Only clipped tool1manual retainedends exact and later160\u2013520/520\u20131020reads exact. 27667frames full exact,27681publicviews all27667 unique,360numberedscreens/CURSOR,27655HTTPunique. Native maxgame1819.309s8930keys; allten deaths,0/2scored,nojewels/escape/throne/caps/retire/replacement. No scaffold changes or root hints." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 27667, "exact_replayed_frames": 27667, "matching_public_views": 27681, "unique_full_json_frames": 27667, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 360, "supplemental_native_history_lines": 182, "additional_song_history_lines": 76, "action_trace_steps": 24, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 96.056586, "evidence_sha256": { "assistant_text.json": "01646705c1b014bc026d3574fb887edf89e9de8cb9e001174eebbcceb2baa628", "audited-reading-proof.json": "19924287a5acdb5273852e790acd3234a9b789a5ab5b5cc9433488c79c12206e", "available_reasoning_summaries.json": "7bce6a9eb10934654ac07120a5e7a6b6f3d1c9b20c54e48abed78758e3a5303f", "live-final-review-continuity.json": "44522486349a0c8a47801989e92943357981f13dfdd7ca4f96a3a38203a32afb", "manifest.json": "47b5501ab05be7ab3e2de7d7098816668ace39b4d3ab9a8da861ac24b8ccc76a", "native-review-working.json": "77c3f19f3008bdfacf36c594e705ac2a8e5a6dd0b3c99d3d08c67a161a5a2d29", "public_observation_audit.json": "c27d52d4b244b09ada0d0eb77bdb7fd43676a807a76e4710a8a6971dfd13484b", "qualitative-working.json": "e4b74cb61b7fdb3eb1cc72529766cb48f9fadcfcada0ce21a5b98f0e91b472cf", "replay.json": "9431827c87d2cbdbf20cf787d435a1ef472c4662e9cdd07b79fc44aa6de5a79a", "review.json": "18c2da9933f03c8d849534ce77871d108cf370d0c39fc51033a832dbf660dc5c", "source-read-audit.json": "8f7edb15a6368b97771b8f10acec0df6f41095ab4fc1016aedf4be955469a6f1", "state/events.jsonl": "f873528ec93640b34f950234a73f849ea24d0b811649f4cc95fe5439d89f28c9", "state/summary.json": "4511e7d51330b8718f6277e7521028993fae8d2f0dfc19fd443eb90f02ca587e", "tool_calls_complete.json": "2efbb60892d06c2025ebdf9906c8c9f1e822317aaf18bd12b9d27a49b39a40b1", "tool_review_coverage.json": "d223010dceebfebf2af8cb9c4da56beb809ef15eca21a4370d1ee9b3c1a29cbe", "trial01-native-messages.txt": "f139538e40e60720370c5996defb3c000be0d4eb9f5e89e8e81e0d4af13aaf73", "trial02-native-messages.txt": "0c9613e3f14f218ba6d07f453c3f0b87579ecc9249f01917f64ea213017e9117", "trial03-fatal-key-review.json": "336f62471cb0fe5c1d37647e69de3c8bfc244e86a88f1ddc958ec325def3a28e", "trial03-native-messages.txt": "9e76b22c0964b7095815ae807f7bc9ee1a59ef11ad33a825f8de3b58d9ecd6f0", "trial04-native-messages.txt": "5e8e5b38da6666561b64aa3213a80d75acddb7c85ab1983e4b1023eb95744b02", "trial05-fatal-key-review.json": "8b7ca87944d98e83c672f4ebd3d3528bbda68f2e1cbba8d28b24d942621c96ca", "trial05-native-messages.txt": "bdf5ffdb92a46fae6244ca6b875c0d2b94826d68baefd9065ac8395a3c658b33", "trial06-fatal-key-review.json": "38826da957ff51997a82f45c1756c6e3b5eb4507407fe83a52707c7f4b996f92", "trial06-native-messages.txt": "91ae6704c27ba4ca88675b8bac7d0d204629061130ce1f59a8cdb40955d8854c", "trial07-fatal-key-review.json": "1137f8230340556b2527fc28df1aaf1f18c681706538a19043ae26f2a80aa7ba", "trial07-native-messages.txt": "cc5fb2d587c73ca09ecc9c38e0d0981795c13e5f196a7b4edd28a02afd3d03c1", "trial08-fatal-key-review.json": "dd04f7e8189e2c3c0121bf2e5191da188e0822b2741e7d373a1d07737ed779e2", "trial08-native-messages.txt": "fd483421b0046007b6ffff5dd05a1dc5c0267277c7fb4e592db301918716f264", "trial09-fatal-key-review.json": "84f0daa47b0123b1c54f89880e0b884ea76e39a2ba4aa75fa51a33d1456b9115", "trial09-native-messages.txt": "5e2aa35ede3306a6d9d10d83f151adcada6f0e806d58b34e536e2837ffd32354", "trial10-fatal-key-review.json": "a6594527f38e267dba86fd6eab47a0e83aa664fa70a1dbc32b87d248483de41d", "trial10-native-messages.txt": "3d8ad9e0679352535d9c1f56c37489a42f1b46c2c2b4e42c6cfe8011ddd872f2", "v3-controller-audit.json": "5451bfbef81cfb4804697c154edcd98df5b4567653e391296943e066f8da5391", "v3-medium05-projection-audit.json": "2510cd33c2889070c0ddd8080e8e42e973de99acf2323ead2a025b931486128e", "v3-native-projection-audit.json": "0686ee9c4bf27a7b82578c913c5a06fd16f7b908ed68ddf7df076ed34f7d2abe", "workspace-file-review.json": "356644067fdf12d52fab237996c9eb51af65e06753db68ba6b4ca3616d4f6d71", "workspace-snapshot.json": "680c3de61ad25bb4c85aec181712fea0d5be3bd8bbf2f3343fb9eb32311cce3d" } }, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "47b5501ab05be7ab3e2de7d7098816668ace39b4d3ab9a8da861ac24b8ccc76a", "qualitative_review.json": "b57a8f1c4548fa0ed7ae7776e6ae2e8aa1d81f361bafd729fe5d5e67ea6f0209", "review.json": "18c2da9933f03c8d849534ce77871d108cf370d0c39fc51033a832dbf660dc5c", "replay.json": "9431827c87d2cbdbf20cf787d435a1ef472c4662e9cdd07b79fc44aa6de5a79a", "state/summary.json": "4511e7d51330b8718f6277e7521028993fae8d2f0dfc19fd443eb90f02ca587e" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-medium-06", "condition": "astra-medium", "bundle": 6, "admitted": true, "status": "complete_valid", "best": 0, "mean": 0.0, "scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Easterling warrior", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2997, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 581.5203609466553, "keys_used": 3112 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 28, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 59.10205698013306, "keys_used": 79 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 979, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 352.28116059303284, "keys_used": 936 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mewlip", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1659, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 72.03099203109741, "keys_used": 1671 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Warg", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 5951, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1010.7522349357605, "keys_used": 9760 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 934, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 381.07507395744324, "keys_used": 1961 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -9, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 561, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 88.13293552398682, "keys_used": 707 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1946, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 211.27998971939087, "keys_used": 2128 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Boldog, the Merciless", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -7, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 5745, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1281.4432232379913, "keys_used": 6445 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Warg", "depth_feet": 450, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 450, "player_turns": 2811, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 6974.987779140472, "keys_used": 2622 } ], "requests": 587, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1761, "input_tokens_cache_write": 542866, "input_tokens_cache_read": 152807544, "output_tokens": 218093, "reasoning_tokens": 160360 }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 280.492676, "peak_request_input_tokens": 542869, "scaffold": { "captured_at": 1788839414.4973881, "model_context_windows": [ 997500 ], "last_session_timestamp": "2026-09-08T03:49:48.587Z", "compactions_observed": 0, "scope": "last read-only live snapshot; authoritative full model history remains in Inspect" }, "rejected_requests": 0, "execution_failures": [], "structured_tool_errors": [], "replayed_frames": 29431, "qualitative_review": { "reviewed_at": 1788840461.1791356, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 587, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 75, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 55, "tool_calls_reviewed": 586, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_yD8l0emJkQupwKrMvgjR0Q7O", "call_8lrP4KTjUfJ2V56Ff8dvy5tS" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1, 577 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; saturation gate requires all ten sessions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Easterling warrior", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2997, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 581.5203609466553, "keys_used": 3112 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 28, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 59.10205698013306, "keys_used": 79 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 979, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 352.28116059303284, "keys_used": 936 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mewlip", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1659, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 72.03099203109741, "keys_used": 1671 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Warg", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 5951, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1010.7522349357605, "keys_used": 9760 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 934, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 381.07507395744324, "keys_used": 1961 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -9, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 561, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 88.13293552398682, "keys_used": 707 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1946, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 211.27998971939087, "keys_used": 2128 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Boldog, the Merciless", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -7, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 5745, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1281.4432232379913, "keys_used": 6445 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Warg", "depth_feet": 450, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 450, "player_turns": 2811, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 6974.987779140472, "keys_used": 2622 } ], "notes": [ "All 586 tool calls, 75 visible assistant messages, and 55 available reasoning summaries were read. Encrypted reasoning was not inspected. The previously reviewed live prefix of 581 calls, 72 messages and 55 summaries is unchanged. All 28 final Python files, play notes and helper text were read; copied guide/manual and result JSON match their authoritative sources.", "All ten trials ended in native death. Both scored games returned zero, with no jewel or escape. Native replay reproduced all 29,431 frames; 29,449 public views covered all 29,431 unique frames. The 26,896 normal HUD checks have no discrepancies. Native messages and fatal key windows were reviewed for every game.", "Trials 1\u20133 used Fingolfin combat builds. Trial 1 died to Easterlings and wolves at 300 feet with little protection. Trial 2 issued eight rest commands beside a Tanglethorn omitted from the controller\u2019s alphabetic monster detector; the ensuing death is a policy error. Trial 3 reached 250 feet but died after late evasive training and unidentified consumables. Trials 4\u20135 tried smithing: trial 4 rested through an unseen Mewlip attack; trial 5 forged armor but spent many inputs oscillating, firing arrows, and bumping a harmless thrall, then died surrounded at 300 feet.", "Trials 6\u20138 tested stealth/song, a hybrid build, and a smith with Dodging. Trial 6 kept waiting under wolf attacks; trial 7 exhausted its song resource; trial 8 used an antidote but was poisoned again and died after an unidentified Slowness potion. Controller choices and later fixes are visible, but these trajectories do not establish causal learning.", "Scored trial 9 forged mail, helm and boots, identified a Quarterstaff of Mithrim, and reached 300 feet. Surrounded by Boldog and orcs, it tried potions, herbs, songs and repeated light staff activations. A healing potion temporarily raised health; the final native sequence ended with Boldog killing the character at frame6445, followed by terminal frame6446.", "Scored trial 10 used the same initial smith build, added Knock Back and Dodging, and reached 450 feet. The earlier transition from 250 to 300 feet followed a floor collapse at frames1812\u20131815; the transition from 300 to 400 followed a troll attack and fall at frames1829\u20131833. These are not evidence of planned descent. It later recovered to full health, revisited 300 feet, and descended through 400 to 450. A final pursuit led to encirclement. True Sight did not heal it, Copper Slowness worsened the emergency, a Terror herb induced fear, and a final unknown Golden potion preceded a Warg\u2019s killing blow at frame2622. Terminal frame2623 confirms HP -5.", "The broad controller audit checked 593 numbered screens, 486 highlight signals and 29,419 complete HTTP frames. Its single flag at call577 was a mixed screen/entity-list truncation; exact retained ends match native output and the original flag is retained. The supplemental checks verify 96 earlier projections and 255 further projections; ten adversarial controls accept original evidence and reject nine corruptions. Navigation memory, hostile/player classification, equipment scores and causal assertions remain controller inferences.", "All 587 recorded requests used Astra at medium reasoning, with output allowance128000, effective context997500 and peak input542869. No compaction, model error, missing usage, schedule retirement, resource cap or environment defect was observed. Trial10 took6974.987779 seconds; the largest key count was9760. Estimated request-priced cost is $280.492676. This admits one session; the medium saturation decision requires all ten registered sessions. No human winning baseline or causal learning conclusion is claimed." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 29431, "exact_replayed_frames": 29431, "matching_public_views": 29449, "unique_full_json_frames": 29431, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 593, "additional_signals": 486, "supplemental_native_projection_checks": 351, "controller_clip_flags_resolved": 1, "normal_hud_checks": 26896, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 280.492676, "evidence_sha256": { "assistant_text.json": "79e88a2286f569874e2b5e021b7e1c75f6b95bb89d901d09e50f628a694adb45", "audited-reading-proof.json": "7ffab2d3588e1b8bb154f4ca08385f8d2343791db5d4410a00921ae94fa94ef5", "available_reasoning_summaries.json": "4b107108d7c88634947a986a52f0d219d4f2924812be77e826b1e8a51a6c1df4", "controller-findings-review.json": "0f6f93afe2b244365205976ed4ddabf84582b513f09d01980c70a019fa10e9ed", "live-final-review-continuity.json": "23a0388f1ba6fc8a18c8f159f0f5ff08dae6ae0b04aeaeb318d39a15d68ac3b6", "manifest.json": "79351115c62e5f798fbfb2c3cba7ba031bd192805ad2633dd1b5b21669643bc5", "native-review-working.json": "c9fb932925943aaf23ee16bcd860a39c36f03a5435dcd1d14ad739a5d9fa530d", "projection-counterexamples.json": "c920acd946a59ac2c9635b3735615e974391b676a3f83534c7e314a6e41795e7", "public_observation_audit.json": "53df890d82a7e75b693e37a3c55587ea086e7f2311e7127aa637726b1b1fcffc", "qualitative-working.json": "73f13d84e94e01aa5218756a6b6e5bb3f3ab8714e8760e5b835018e432f71b22", "replay.json": "5607b93dd3d8b0fbd1c91e25ea72d01d8083363795c4a10b9fd23fcf7e37c833", "review.json": "c8877f93abcf8cbd2ec7c36e17b5423e03f98f3ce061008d7a82daca9a997352", "source-read-audit.json": "2d2026e48b97b8c46fe212ff42d18078e9d1ab5f89e8a42425bc31cda8c607c8", "state/events.jsonl": "a98069feb6ed9eee9d384c5226af7a8176c095313e2f022f5c25bf66e653e9fa", "state/summary.json": "0df1327bf80c0f17b1c60d19ef4160d0a17e56775675d7d11c40bc286dae27de", "tool_calls_complete.json": "365da7e12f6d43c17159e2efac9a7fcc782a6a0398f968fcc7751ea635537e99", "tool_review_coverage.json": "06ae114a292def578151f1742badd01f36f80d48ac718158677a57659abc6b82", "trial01-fatal-key-review.json": "72763b0a89c86c0cf34334daccb390bdcedc49681175a39b63783f5c670c1567", "trial01-native-messages.txt": "508a9f6a384149ebdaf3853a4cf28465a02b39df19a1df83ceacab729cfa82a5", "trial02-fatal-key-review.json": "48d9e2c85073d17ebab72733936bec1e8c14e34dc4ab85010e36dc589bc8703b", "trial02-native-messages.txt": "73d1191db46cc32b6c653bdbc83f16dc35c2ecb332727036676b90a8bfb1650c", "trial03-fatal-key-review.json": "55b3a5a41be57cf193432fdf8f0b20a45c6b1bac00acff6d1c30c09648fce76d", "trial03-native-messages.txt": "59a587ed6dae0437ba9c2d93cf78a85157164468d6edba1c9c126f521edef74d", "trial04-fatal-key-review.json": "592b2f9c055dce8b3368001eec937f05688d7d9572ccd8852bd0126bbc5027e7", "trial04-native-messages.txt": "dc9ceb5cc59381944b76d77d0ccf74ea73741219460a0cc5ed8176db69c2f058", "trial05-fatal-key-review.json": "442a93bc192df27474e48a21c2b736a49a355a403b4256103586902bf94ba358", "trial05-native-messages.txt": "b6024ecf6b1d89cd61d99ca727f5221bee5d4150f6165f103396ac5ed6eeac92", "trial06-fatal-key-review.json": "f47d16248cb17c37e32d4b1ea4d8153449b94d791658b4ebca553fc0bdc98e4c", "trial06-native-messages.txt": "d48127efb2c744c68e5acfdbda05f4362476916b3bd95587d51e1de5e2af4aaa", "trial07-fatal-key-review.json": "b098675c6bfac096d42874bde96216389e71c487b6f1ca393869b405250046d2", "trial07-native-messages.txt": "57983cf6316d62863ea3478fa45e1c3f2bbf3b94c822f2dc57930657e2c5a341", "trial08-fatal-key-review.json": "248bad299031f03d7dd9901fe9e0fb9abff85a89cedcb7cdff65628d14db3be1", "trial08-native-messages.txt": "e556e769c25c4ef12e3f04482fec5244134db4862d8738a783cf7c5d7efed77a", "trial09-fatal-key-review.json": "d3213816e9b895ecf907556fe551877472d4055fe582c466ade93165dd77b5c3", "trial09-native-messages.txt": "9707be3cf5078034eebd6ed8bfba9ef17cba7c07803675224bc9c508fc7e4c7b", "trial10-fatal-keys.txt": "b774d717f30fd85b3cf82f08a480dfe2072f1ae9a3bd967fe1d91844c0eb8aa7", "trial10-native-messages.txt": "739da770c0b8fc229c3389fdcb00d7716cb06a67cc6fa2023a010d15c36a3a6f", "v3-controller-audit.json": "2f8c892700030564b214ecbb40fdd921aea8053a9a5c9fb85a243e372a3396f9", "v3-medium06-07-projection-audit.json": "bc746f109b57cee156b8d54d920ee6642026c1f7634021333194c7fb5205e958", "v3-medium06-final-projection-audit.json": "1757b856c910df239da7dc8a6b35d7649a3fe2b3580437ec01c60ecda281e436", "workspace-file-review.json": "bf01d3ca32f628a17317c00d77e2a169491ff28c745b56a895a6d4f491f83a75", "workspace-snapshot.json": "76318f7f3f324c59d873b8dcb3c241b5c0d05307d27cb6cdaeb46d6a410a910f" } }, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "79351115c62e5f798fbfb2c3cba7ba031bd192805ad2633dd1b5b21669643bc5", "qualitative_review.json": "b7fd94933d64a8b2397eca02b020573a1ad65e3f93d89ee2f69c32ab919a9131", "review.json": "c8877f93abcf8cbd2ec7c36e17b5423e03f98f3ce061008d7a82daca9a997352", "replay.json": "5607b93dd3d8b0fbd1c91e25ea72d01d8083363795c4a10b9fd23fcf7e37c833", "state/summary.json": "0df1327bf80c0f17b1c60d19ef4160d0a17e56775675d7d11c40bc286dae27de" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-medium-07", "condition": "astra-medium", "bundle": 7, "admitted": true, "status": "complete_valid", "best": 0, "mean": 0.0, "scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 741, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 434.02109599113464, "keys_used": 811 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a fatal wound", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 2849, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 294.91969203948975, "keys_used": 3007 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Madthorn", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 557, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 18.777141571044922, "keys_used": 622 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 4093, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 633.8818230628967, "keys_used": 5030 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 143, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 40.523260831832886, "keys_used": 259 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -6, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1117, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 228.1049509048462, "keys_used": 1172 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Gorgol, the Butcher", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 2313, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 603.3242428302765, "keys_used": 2271 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1059, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 132.09994673728943, "keys_used": 1022 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Gorcrow", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 2704, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 517.8829572200775, "keys_used": 2187 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Easterling warrior", "depth_feet": 350, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 350, "player_turns": 5023, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 2375.5656769275665, "keys_used": 6233 } ], "requests": 348, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1044, "input_tokens_cache_write": 353443, "input_tokens_cache_read": 58813280, "output_tokens": 129830, "reasoning_tokens": 88314 }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 92.571526, "peak_request_input_tokens": 353446, "scaffold": { "captured_at": 1788834378.7933211, "model_context_windows": [ 997500 ], "last_session_timestamp": "2026-09-08T02:26:09.056Z", "compactions_observed": 0, "scope": "last read-only live snapshot; authoritative full model history remains in Inspect" }, "rejected_requests": 0, "execution_failures": [ { "call_id": "call_CdWIsmhhwIxrYudfqADCQ0am", "function": "exec", "category": "command_nonzero" }, { "call_id": "call_eMLFxMCgUTnbtVwFIeOjkpOo", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_PXNoyJGkr3nUJ1a2Y49twJcz", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_728c3UPIWi3cwk1C2TXbjIxv", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_yipwGXKwArr1yBcEHbgLR1Pv", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" } ], "structured_tool_errors": [], "replayed_frames": 22624, "qualitative_review": { "reviewed_at": 1788835644.2617614, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 348, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 40, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 48, "tool_calls_reviewed": 347, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_C2UXyd2SJh5RvN7hIHDWMoW0", "call_ygDE2yvvoYnK06rHOceAw3B6", "call_K5eLKSnnJwH40yszmZY6h3er", "call_xnf9Puv141rARRhxKHWdCsNU", "call_aIi4QMEBsgtaqGjN8M8wGC2G", "call_5BNsQHFzORHWDesvrxderRo5", "call_J6nxBTPQMISW2Iilb18uEwZB", "call_YcpD2zepKjEpNTQ33xWROaMZ", "call_StKXx7JCaqxZFwMEijHHT8F0", "call_I4Xy59e1nDTjJhnFFO8WOxum", "call_H3FRcKK75j0bnuXof9y7w4wh", "call_lTrSTlLGt6NSlchCxmY81Z9V", "call_1o1EhG9xO7KifPhfTR4z4CUF", "call_Xql6VRFNarOg1YGLYfkh70KK", "call_iKaGaH7CMm5lFCaAwULOO4AP", "call_E1KMp2RMRTrRGoiqMQY2SDKs", "call_6BFJTe5xWagwz61slhz6IMXr", "call_lSw9E60B5AzUX0An8uDE5QXK", "call_1q5SvWTrLpHnVMaXLqmSSSN8", "call_qzyoXl7ecMPPhle7la8Ryr0u", "call_wISfVtQm4CPJTlqvKY2bld26", "call_BEdKIohCi5F2wswFGtgQgiSd", "call_3hMmgbBlONFucKbkCjOokkED", "call_TjTaetQ7sn6256lxzUOSnSbd", "call_VfscCYO2uxMUU0OoHNWpwRkI", "call_HNPJdpIW8hVAKTw8k3sUl6g5", "call_hxuRGAG8UIuqd8jBxBwk8Gwh", "call_w8TvXBvHKV06uSuaxQda5D2n", "call_aFeFzCLdWDOlZvoKBkdPUN6D" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1, 149, 184, 204, 217, 218, 228, 229, 233, 234, 246, 249, 256, 259, 261, 271, 274, 278, 285, 297, 300, 301, 304, 317, 331, 336, 337, 339, 344 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; saturation gate requires all ten sessions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 741, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 434.02109599113464, "keys_used": 811 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a fatal wound", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 2849, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 294.91969203948975, "keys_used": 3007 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Madthorn", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 557, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 18.777141571044922, "keys_used": 622 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 4093, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 633.8818230628967, "keys_used": 5030 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 143, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 40.523260831832886, "keys_used": 259 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -6, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1117, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 228.1049509048462, "keys_used": 1172 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Gorgol, the Butcher", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 2313, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 603.3242428302765, "keys_used": 2271 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1059, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 132.09994673728943, "keys_used": 1022 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Gorcrow", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 2704, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 517.8829572200775, "keys_used": 2187 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Easterling warrior", "depth_feet": 350, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 350, "player_turns": 5023, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 2375.5656769275665, "keys_used": 6233 } ], "notes": [ "Initial source-read audit inspected: guide8587exact; manual initialretainedprefix10721suffix18747, subsequent printed ranges exact (06:170\u201369029275chars/690\u2013101017572;07:160\u201356023299/560\u201394020134/940\u201310506296). Initial controller audits fully inspected0diff:06captures15523uniqueframes220numberedscreens178signals;07captures9724HTTP9721unique147screens20signals. Complete tool/code/text/summary reading and native trajectories remain pending. Reviewer added source-transcribed06highlightcolor(%16in4,12,14,x>15) andkeys-firstheader;07frames.jsonl. No game/scaffold changes or root hints.", "Tools1\u201315 fully read. Initial guide/manual exact as source checked. play5 urllib public API archives all returned observations into frames.jsonl; printed full27 rows and all COLORS. T1Fingolfin3/4/4/2 M7Eva6 XP100, normal38(gen37), native inventory Lembas3/2Torches, movement6 leaves sunlight41. No ability yet. Controller construction16 next. No root input to run.", "Tools16\u2013136 fully read;137 pending in initialexport. T1bot first@ grid1:24,28fix1:26,fullCOLORSdisabled22butarchive retained. Poison100HP20f206 MurkyBrown208/209heals30Zfull; Studded156Gloves252,Finesse295,optionalweapons unselected until fatalfight. Indent35fixed37.49pickupprints pendingnative;771150HP17Orcs, trainedEva7f780, CopperSpeckled782nohealeffect, Longsword788, Cloak792HP11, Violet796poison10HP8. North3turns800\u2013805poisonHP2, Goldenfloor807Slow,811OrcSoldierdeath/812-3. T2Fingolfin3/4/4/2M6Eva6Per3XP200normal46. Alchemyattempt71wrongletter/prereqnative55need5,skillgoal74; XPwholemaprowValueError74fixed75[:12]. Memory preservesinferredfloor,83unknowncorridorfill; 1000sunlightoscillation1653\u20132653 dueborderfrontiers, projection82last5pending. NativeM1652showsstairsavailable. Reset83min150forcesnextdescent150; shieldalone2944HP19,EvasionnotupgradedPer5instead. Up2954mazeemerges150torchgone2957; freshTorch2963. LowerHPthreshold97,HP12f2973thenMewlipblockswest;Song1train2991Elbereth2995/99HP8,107ninekeyprojections3000\u20133008Mewlipkilled3004butcutfatal3007/8. T3Feanor3/4/4/3M6Eva6Smith3XP200 normal47Armour54; plantsremovedfrommonsters109then Madthorn100death623-2,35historylines111pending;bootsonly1\u20131 GreatHelmcarriednotworn.112addsplantavoid/flee andtorches gear. T4samebirth+Armour54,Leather/Boot2\u20135,derivedmap114/115inference,missing-gridfrontier116fix.100639HP12twoOrcs;manualkill640/648,retreatcloseZrecover41f659forge. Shield+1/1d3designed668,interrupt671,672one turnleft,673resume;137pending. Unnumberedpickupmessages49/75/77/84/110/113 andhistory82/107/111 andcoordinates60/lastkey118 supplementalnativechecks pending. Code warnings/errors are agent failures, no environment edits or root hints.", "All9initialvisibleassistanttexts and28available summaries throughrequest127 read. Controller planning/causal assertions remain agent hypotheses; perceived short token/time horizons in summary38 are not enforced resourcecaps. Thorns initialmisidentification andlaterrestfailure explicitly recognized. No unavailable reasoning read.", "NativeT1\u20133all distinctmessages/depthtransitionsfullyread;T2first25lines reread afterroot146tokenclip. T1Gorgolkilled732;138BeechStaffsee-loop432\u2013756 notacquired,lateCloak792. T2sunlight994enter+999exit58\u20132689torchgone1872,50\u21921502776forcedminimum,shield2794onlyarmor,Song/Elbereth2995cut3003fatal3007. T3Armour52Finesse556boots157only;Madthorn615\u2013622restfailure. NormalHUD697/2856/533 no differences, menus/More retained separately. Supplementalfatalkeywindowsstillpending.", "NativeT1fatal32keys781\u2013812read,actualHPupdateswithinMore18? exact78117,79211,7978,8006,8024,8042,8081,811-3;notlagbugnativeMore. T2fatal11keys2998\u20133008read,threewestattacks3001/3004/3007lastcut0. T3last16keys608\u2013623read,6Z615/616/617/618/620/622besideMadthornHP39\u2192-2. NativeT4allmessages/depthread:50f46\u2192100400\u2192150840\u21921001002\u21921501137\u21922003964;4146normalHUD0diff. Shield674/680Helm778/784Cloak796/802,Gaunt1167. 466BrightOrange+405Helmsee-loop1180\u20132497 resolvedpickup2206/2212,Curvedupgrade2233. Torch1723/3681DarkBread3738.200Greatsword4094leads116Wear/Wield andalternatingShield/Greatsword~58cycles underarchery until5030death;native5031terminal. Finalkeywindow/toolcodeafter136pending. Newprojection07checks60coords799,82sunlight2649\u201353,107fatal3000\u20133008,111tail589\u2013623exact53lines;derivedmap114/115controllerinference.", "T4last41keys4991\u20135031fullyread andbound. Allmovementstopped:fivegearwieldchangesat6/7HP,5029arrowhitHP-1,5030death5031terminal. Confirmsdeathfollowsnativegearloop, completeactions retained. Toolcodeafter136stillpending.", "Tools137\u2013165 fully read. T4 Shield674/equip680; forge guarded combat/resumption yields Helm778/784 and Cloak796/802. BroodSpider957killed then agent knowingly hits Madthorn960 despite native stationary/confusion recall950, retreats961\u201362/Z963 full981. Thorn-blocked frontier prompts risky flag160; 150-ft loops Helm/BrightOrange resolved under-cell oldg fix163. Native row0 history162 and all-@ color165 supplemental matching pending. Tool149 first leaf intentionally300tokens clips68tokens, retained native fragment needs exact supplemental matching (rows10..14). No human hints.", "Tools166\u2013174 fully read. Thrall fix166 onlycolor5 leaves color13 misidentified; 169/170shows alternating player positions due purple13 thrall,171fixesboth5/13 andfood. History168/169/170 and165 allcoords need supplemental matching. T4 terminal5031 from two-hand weapon/shield gear loop under OrcArcher, already native-reviewed fatal arrow5029. Agent173adds two-hand skip and gear enemy-distance guard. T5 sameFeanor3/4/4/3 nowM7/Eva5/Smith3XP100Armour54, starts700? actual54beforebot.", "Tools175\u2013232, all22 assistant texts/40available summaries through request211 fully read;233pending excluded. T5 M7/Eva5/Smith3 reaches100 poorlyarmoured(boots only),3Orcs HP25\u21922 then BrightOrange potion Slowness anddeath260. T6 Feanor2/5/4/3M6Eva6Smith3, Finesse acquired andEva7, Cloak/specialHelm minimalprot, reaches200; arrow1058HP14\u21925, Browntried1064 nohealing, escape1068\u201370close/Zrecover; new supply.py190 identifiesunknowns onlywhenfullHP, then returnsarcherroomfindsKiteShield1111?nativepending. Repeated unknownpotions193/195, Slow1137, Blocking1144, corridor attacksdie1173. T7 samebirth nowwaitforforge but foundMail/gaunt/helm/shieldprot5\u201314, consumes3unknownpotionshealthy, poison/Sloweffects nativepending; surrounds1501291HP20, SelfKnowledge1298, Song2+Elbereth1320successfear1323; swapsStudded1504removesGaunt1507, torch1513, fixesgearattackpenalty/archeryrest; 2002161voice0HP21, goto221NoneTypeerrorfixed222, attemptedchasmescape2263inspectionconfirmed. Leapingrequires500has431, staffattemptdeath2272. T8 replacesSmith3withSong3Feanor2/5/4/3, plannedLeaping andFinesse acquired, first901? nativepending,1501010HP6poison16. Seven additional native-screen clip fragments149/184/204/217/218/228/229 require exact matching of retained ends; no clipped middle is treated as read. Native replay T1\u20138 exact14202frames no diffs/frozenidentity. Causal build claims and speculative available summaries kept separate from evidence.", "Seven clipped screen excerpts149/184/204/217/218/228/229 are already independently checked by audit_v3_controller clipped_numbered_block; retained prefix and suffix match full native numbered screen exactly. Missing character counts270/404/607/1007/807/54/254 respectively, middle stays omitted from reading copy. No additional environment defect.", "Native T5\u20138 all distinct messages/depth transitions fully read, HUD168/964/1935/846checks0differences; fatal20/36/33/69keys fully read. T5 actualHP25\u219211\u21922within turn142 (HUD lags during More; exactnative), potionSlowness256/57 thenOrcSoldier259. T6 HelmBrillianceidentified1016,KiteShieldequipped1109; Brown1064/Golden1124triednoheal, CopperSlowness1128/29; Blocking1142then3/3/3/3/2/8/8/8combat, finalOrcArcher1171HP3\u2192-6. T7 Mail165Gaunt534Helm601Shield655; DarkGreen344tried, MurkyBrown436OrcishLiquor atfullHPstuns, BrightOrange641Slowness; Song2Elbereth1318, staffSelfKnowledge1297and1500. GorgolNOTkilled: final2OrcWarriors2248/51, Gorgol2256HP14\u21928,staffRosewood2271Gorgol-2terminal2272. T8 BroodSpiderfirstpoison959; repeated7/3retreat-return oscillation970\u20131007 interleavedinventory; naturalpoisonrecovery991/1003 thennewpoison994/1006; 6HP1010, staffMahogany1017spendturnHP2, GnarledSelfKnowledge1020/21 beforepoisondeath1022/23. No native/interface defect inferred from those deaths. Supplemental142history/coordinate lines exact current scriptfa5d838c117b567ef6a1b77339d27af698794483b3364bb35d32bf3ef512aa28.", "Trial 9 all 297 distinct messages/depth transitions and final 80 keys 2109\u20132188 fully read. Native depth 50 f46,100 f676,150 f1201,200 f1540. Studded Leather equip626/upgrade1383, no native Greatsword equip despite pickup1006. Strength882; DarkBlue1033 only tried. Elbereth21 starts (12+9 More),15 plain ends+others; archer escape Liquor2076/2083, kill2092/2123, full41 at2124. Fatal gorcrow blindness2170, ten Z actions2171,2172,2173,2176,2177,2178,2179,2180,2183,2186 under unseen attacks, death2187/2188 HP\u22121. 1960 normal HUD checks zero differences. Later controller/tool chronology not yet read; no admission implied.", "Read calls 233\u2013340, texts 23\u201338 and summaries 41\u201348 in full. T8 death1022/23; call236 KeyError trial in own mixed frames archive fixed237. T9 Feanor2/5/4/3 M6/E6/Song3, Elbereth, Leaping, Finesse; no smith investment. Camera/memory oscillation557\u2013568 fixed243 with persistent hazard/goal. Native quartz white% vs chasm dark% inspection259\u2013261 corrected terrain; final blindness Z loop is introduced249 and kills native2187/88, fixed264 for T10. T10 Fingolfin2/4/5/3 M6/E6/Will3/Song1, Elbereth+SiA; leather and Sapphire ring early, 150 dual Accompaniment1414/1421 main Curved1427, 10 Spears dropped1432 then repicked. Madthorn27arrows1777\u20131829 killed full HP; persistent ranged target prompts corrected294/297. Longsword and E7, Brood spider killed3848 fullHP; cleanup4546. 250 fullHP5080, Sword spider5701\u20135712 survived; 3006034, ring poison resistance verified6050, no ammunition6046, Ivy staff6076 Darkness, begins BattleAxe equip6078. Agent causal claims about skill payoff and summary336 claiming poison prevention are not established; native says resistance. Supplemental projections236/237 T7coords,240/242/258 history+debug(memorymixed),248/263/296/309/322/328/334/335 remain for source-matched checker. Clipped outputs233/234/246/249/256/259/261/271/274/278/285/297/300/301/304/317/331/336/337/339 retained ends read, generic native clip audit passing in current refresh; never filled omitted text. Call341 pending not counted.", "Scored projection extension passes: 237 lines, script SHA 2459b298a60a2adb5ffcc9c8cd5f8ad2ae83b77ca8e89c586d314609befe2417. 12 new counterexamples pass, including changed raw HP/item/frame, history/map, default-white quartz color, explicit spider color. First scratch counterexample script incorrectly required an explicit white run; corrected test construction to insert an attribute for native default white. No run evidence or production code changed.", "Final continuity: all340 live tools exact,38 texts/48 summaries exact; read all7 new final calls341\u2013347 and2 newtexts in full, no additional summaries. BattleAxe6079 kills GreenSerpent by6085 HP32, recovered6086; native Oath menu considered only, not taken. Finalcall345350nativeEasterlingdeath6234 HP\u22122, final347 report/results accurately records10deaths/nojewels/noescape; controller identifies hostile human @ omitted from monsters. Agent final claims survival improvement remain descriptive, not causal; trial6 lowest reported recovery HP3 claim requires native confirmation. T10 all native distinct messages/finalfatalkeys/fullworkspace read pending, noadmission.", "T10 all1030distinct native messages and depth transitions (1032lines) fully read;4973normalHUDchecks0differences. Native depth transitions50f47,100769,1501347,2002037,2504787HP47,3005950,3506170; controller normalHUD reports each one frame later except350. Armour273,VenomsEnd336 identifies999/1000 long before6050inspection (partial protection, not immunity), Helm1614,BronzeProtection1850/51,Longsword2451,Lantern5873. Broodspider poison2954/2958 before manualretreat; slain3848 then hatchling poisons/cuts3849/50; recovery3860. Swordspider slain5708,Greenserpent slain6084 withpoison6083/cured6085.1030messages includes518target prompts and116nothing-to-get; ordinary ammo recovery not item duplication. Final65keys6170\u20136234 fully read:15 Z actions6197..6232 under Easterling attacks, no melee attacks afterencounter;Liquor6203 heals12HPto42beforeenemy33. Native death6233terminal6234 HP\u22122. Session347report accurate outcomes; causal payoff/poisonprevent/withoutpoison wording not supported generally.", "Final review completed. All16 final Python files and report read statically; results JSON exactly equals protected summary. Native trial6 f1066\u20131068 HP3 verifies reported archer retreat recovery, without establishing a causal strategy effect. Five tool errors35indent,74XP map suffix,81state nesting,221None coordinate,236trial nesting are controller failures, all subsequently handled; no environment/boundary failure.303 supplemental native projection lines plus300 ordered live message prefixes exact; 5 prefix mutation controls and12 scored projection controls pass.29 clipped calls retain only exact native/source-checked ends; omitted middle is never imputed.348 actual Astra-medium requests,128k output997500context peak353446,0compactions/modelerrors/missingusage.22624full native frames exact,22639public views all22624 unique,22615HTTPviews22612unique,413numbered screens/20signals. All10 deaths,22614keys total, max6233keys2375.565677seconds,0/2scored and no jewels/escape/throne/retirement/replacement/cap. No root hints or environment changes." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 22624, "exact_replayed_frames": 22624, "matching_public_views": 22639, "unique_full_json_frames": 22624, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 413, "additional_signals": 20, "supplemental_native_projection_lines": 303, "ordered_native_message_prefixes": 300, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 92.571526, "evidence_sha256": { "assistant_text.json": "508f354583bc0c775dcd0dacc66a389ba421255fb5d1ac22bee41540c7dc26f4", "audited-reading-proof.json": "5e6425558104f96d264e91138e8ecfb7fcdb31fe2161f79fc52581c4492e08a6", "available_reasoning_summaries.json": "4964b21277d48f176c38df628c46a21c510c5854dabc7038f7590ea860c6d7ab", "live-final-review-continuity.json": "23c1939032e591a7b141c9b5a700ae54d07c3c86c66cd061b43cb99938c53f70", "manifest.json": "3c9e6fc7ea9ba0e6da5558bd46177ab3abd20116f00ccdfccb1fc50930d4c8ec", "native-review-working.json": "ca2734d4bc21d2c7ad6a52bd872468a4ea49dfeb2b9a726b72b488462c18781c", "public_observation_audit.json": "9387e997941fc12a62f39c34d96cbba74878f6f6b1551314db3caccd89c85020", "qualitative-working.json": "f3d4a0da79a5a28899c886357c552b305ce7376b60524401738fb6bd06da3d1d", "replay.json": "72d74e81c061a942333630ff9c80562573870b4d941a439712699ad7ca5728cd", "review.json": "6f4f299ca548688351ca4b7aece970cdf53c1596e404c668be187d7a7a5e8d45", "source-read-audit.json": "9f8efe9a8f2700957d0868f042c1800a982e74f231c79cfd23c90f23b24865cf", "state/events.jsonl": "149b153cc53a31b37cc43cdf5ad6a5029f8d548b80c66bc6bb85eb06a8b4c81a", "state/summary.json": "17dca568801107a1fd48b390557549c3f7aa57ba6b53065b814526a519ee4378", "tool_calls_complete.json": "e0ff3c970604339e6b84c0c48ce726d559c4fea9f7b5349e0d1730f59d1256a9", "tool_review_coverage.json": "1e048ae994923cc0d7a38e80d9618cea0f15e6b61acd68182172f9f05f3061b2", "trial01-fatal-key-review.json": "8122c53cf6fc4f8ba8290c711e744b1702165fc3d41e59e857fa427f257e35f0", "trial01-native-messages.txt": "c9a2b16c1e630c8012e4c6749fd3e30b5acbb6b7038b7a36145ed57768b487ca", "trial02-fatal-key-review.json": "ba537806bd8f9682f6e628072cc1ffb39519f993b54a2543646ab79c7acfd8ea", "trial02-native-messages.txt": "586c1b302fce64be68a1ee5ba37685cae60c28f56518b2b08c80c9fb84cee808", "trial03-fatal-key-review.json": "63a137313a4957974c97cc14bd321171e6c0c96f54209f7ecca545f1fbe5e3b3", "trial03-native-messages.txt": "9531328266ec56977140097b06a4450ff735ea3c279b5811c154cc75f43d0d78", "trial04-fatal-key-review.json": "a3859e06ff2facd9414104dd1be0778d73ec18aebb59ad035a5799885f41a26e", "trial04-native-messages.txt": "fb0c9b96c5b9150834b8d99f09387e25749c052cfc8ec52866df1e73502a7425", "trial05-fatal-key-review.json": "4fde11bfce024d1868bfdaa04d0dfa11a8faf17e40014bfb427134b6691a572b", "trial05-native-messages.txt": "4ff7c04bac84ce2a07ed0fd33cb8644dac1f1d7e9b92349c8fa2c7c0fbb62b8e", "trial06-fatal-key-review.json": "498dba9d98999bf3d20aa295fc33f872ce0b7a9d24916d9fe1f5895b01c31699", "trial06-native-messages.txt": "a8a7ab91bb36ce19a11585d757955a7a5727a1bce31df07300885dfd5fc88c54", "trial07-fatal-key-review.json": "ce0cb5fb794019a3a875beaf027a96fde2573dac95abe5ed2920a1bdeee0c46b", "trial07-native-messages.txt": "ee21564d40aa89ed0771c39565c39a75174d1d9d3d94c159ef7245104b0f14f7", "trial08-fatal-key-review.json": "f7948d87ae9b6b01e32f0081c5018773da3d9498f9499bb42640ecf9084942f7", "trial08-native-messages.txt": "83354a6cf5917f4a439a6e8b06d3852330ad250037a1613d818847dd7b628ee0", "trial09-fatal-key-review.json": "2aa267c8615f042e6cff90170babd6f61bc6e6d761f92056b83ce6da5ce8e17f", "trial09-native-messages.txt": "0704f066c17299346f9d58ad29c7a7bfbc7c17d58ac279b2b8de459bf7a5a6b4", "trial10-fatal-key-review.json": "ef624b8b683de0a0506492c1195a8e81c7848996a9a076d9fb8f64f26f823d77", "trial10-native-messages.txt": "43f03c2df4e84a9447dbbafdd045b1a1116b79c882ab4c36f068dc48bbd649c6", "v3-controller-audit.json": "415ac015741f924d5c43e12ae31f84e7b7557d171eba17d3615a21e20dd16ffd", "v3-medium06-07-projection-audit.json": "9ffa5eef7377c092689012cfc5dfca9b2ddd3c03e93062e3afe77dfec4ad307e", "v3-medium07-prefix-audit.json": "a2c81771f71f789312c335bf7244a48b804343363a5e6a7974769ff00768c482", "workspace-file-review.json": "b403a2a7fd58f3741b28104cc3c43ae885e8114a034db8e6f0e3d7030b656136", "workspace-snapshot.json": "762b04517d6b01b59aba073965008f2b4e76abcc584f38e9265d19089a3ce64a" } }, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "3c9e6fc7ea9ba0e6da5558bd46177ab3abd20116f00ccdfccb1fc50930d4c8ec", "qualitative_review.json": "9a9eb8710b138106898c23b330c2c47d10d07de1acf21d77e8c5ac45eaf295e3", "review.json": "6f4f299ca548688351ca4b7aece970cdf53c1596e404c668be187d7a7a5e8d45", "replay.json": "72d74e81c061a942333630ff9c80562573870b4d941a439712699ad7ca5728cd", "state/summary.json": "17dca568801107a1fd48b390557549c3f7aa57ba6b53065b814526a519ee4378" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-medium-08", "condition": "astra-medium", "bundle": 8, "admitted": true, "status": "complete_valid", "best": 0, "mean": 0.0, "scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mewlip", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 3380, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 543.3580458164215, "keys_used": 3389 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 2204, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 168.33188104629517, "keys_used": 1393 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a fatal wound", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 1713, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 33.681257486343384, "keys_used": 1179 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Gorcrow", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 2111, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 89.30583810806274, "keys_used": 1736 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 3672, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 376.241091966629, "keys_used": 3759 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1112, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 95.96915459632874, "keys_used": 814 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Wolf", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 33, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1.2690601348876953, "keys_used": 100 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Madthorn", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 161, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 65.76033329963684, "keys_used": 197 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 387, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 145.08591532707214, "keys_used": 392 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 1312, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 327.1571936607361, "keys_used": 1158 } ], "requests": 204, "usage": { "input_tokens": 612, "input_tokens_cache_write": 171416, "input_tokens_cache_read": 19185210, "output_tokens": 45812, "reasoning_tokens": 20423 }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 23.62463, "peak_request_input_tokens": 171419, "scaffold": { "captured_at": 1788836861.204528, "model_context_windows": [ 997500 ], "last_session_timestamp": "2026-09-08T03:07:25.790Z", "compactions_observed": 0, "scope": "last read-only live snapshot; authoritative full model history remains in Inspect" }, "rejected_requests": 1, "execution_failures": [ { "call_id": "call_iuyyxkyJLzdaozL3J6aoUo5p", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" } ], "structured_tool_errors": [], "replayed_frames": 14127, "qualitative_review": { "reviewed_at": 1788839072.4405046, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 204, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 24, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 54, "tool_calls_reviewed": 203, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_JBOunK8u6cIuXVbPVJKMx7Wn", "call_YjCrTnKb7wW0Uj4uMCFmeKDL", "call_5CHf16po5yHr5KitqJCoI9Lg" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1, 101, 199 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; saturation gate requires all ten sessions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Mewlip", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 3380, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 543.3580458164215, "keys_used": 3389 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 2204, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 168.33188104629517, "keys_used": 1393 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a fatal wound", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 1713, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 33.681257486343384, "keys_used": 1179 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Gorcrow", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 2111, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 89.30583810806274, "keys_used": 1736 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 3672, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 376.241091966629, "keys_used": 3759 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1112, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 95.96915459632874, "keys_used": 814 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Wolf", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 33, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1.2690601348876953, "keys_used": 100 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Madthorn", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 161, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 65.76033329963684, "keys_used": 197 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 387, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 145.08591532707214, "keys_used": 392 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 1312, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 327.1571936607361, "keys_used": 1158 } ], "notes": [ "Tools1\u201334fullyread fromhashboundreadingcopy. Immutableguide8587exact;manualprefix10721suffix18747and145\u201365028674chars/650\u201393515109charsexactalreadyreadsource. T1actualFingolfin2/3/5/3, intendedstatscode3/3/5/3butactualStr2dueownallocationinterpretation;M6E6Per2Will2Song1XP100gen43normal44HP49,Elbereth49. PublicHTTPurllib wrapper5archiveseveryresponseJSON, showall27textrowswithoutcolorsbyagentchoice. explore20restrictsmaprows<24thenauto24, Tanglethorn55native[. Gauntlets72/equip74HP39;auto picksOrcSkeleton154;28cameraalignwalls+rows1..26fixmapinferences;LeatherArmourSpecial188/equip190prot2\u20135. Trap265promptn266thenavoid^. HandAxe452,BlackHerb637,Vermilion1161,2specialDaggers1245. Stillcurrent50min100(notcurrent100). CustomENEMIES/ITEMS20pendingexactprojection, mapcachecontrollerinference. No othertexts/summariesread yet. Finalautomaticreview204mediumrequests128k997500peak1714190comp/modelerr/missingusage;broadaudit2flags101T4frames46/53needinspectclippingformat;3clipcalls1/101/199. Finalall203toolspendingreview.", "Tools35\u201345fullyread. NativeM1246overhead fullmap nohiddenstate;36vis/mapcountscontrollerinference.37fixdepthkey whole row25 includedmap resettingcache; changed[:13]. Arrows1331,1001353StuddedLeathercarried notworn;equipment1354native LeatherofStealth[-1,1d4]<+1>,torch420. GnarledStaff1401/1498,3freshTorches1595then1597oldtorch0equipsfresh(afterMorelater). Shortsword1619,Cloak+2pickup1634/equip1636. NO PATH1647fullHP49at100. All mapscreenrows exactbroad; noendhere.", "Tools46\u201374fullyread. T1localnavigationexpanded edge46 then1500actions1755\u20133255 remains100/full49Hungrymin150; whole-row-depthcache37fixed butblockeddoors causesNO PATH51;52dumpinferredmap,53permitknownfloor/doorsblocked fixes route butSoldiers3267HP15. Elbereth3269,More3270then3271HP12,retreat3279fleeHP14, Z3280endsong15. Melee7trained3283XP25. Restguard66near-distance then3287HP16Soldierapproach;Vermilion3289triednoheal thenAutoinscribe3290. Manageclear lackedAutoinscribe so inventoryi consumedatpromptandEscopensmenu3292, no forbiddenoptionchosen. Diagnostic70assumesframes[]emptyfive;71actualsingleresponseshape5rows3288\u20133292nativependingprojection.72clearAutoinscribe withn+assertInventory fixes,food3298LembasHP17.73autoElbereth+retreatpolicy spendsvoicethenMewlip3390death100HP-1Voice1,3380turns3389keys543.358s (derivefinalresourceagain). T2started1call74. Source13/2 menu vsdisplaydistinction maintained; ENEMIES20 lists and71historyfields needexact supplemental,36/52inferredmap notnativeclaims. No texts/summariesreviewed yet.", "Tools75\u201387 and all24 finalvisibletextsfullyread;54available summaries not yetread. T2Fingolfin3/4/4/2M6E6Will3Song1,Elbereth50/SiA57, earlyWolves nearspawnnormal43HP41XP118. MurkyBrown161/268unknown, Skeleton285stillpickupbugseparateon-coordinatebranch;freshTorches330HP39Voice21,stairpriority82,Greaves383/equip385. Native50;84memorylevel string250 ft is trial2 concatenated50 ft (not250depth). LesserJewel388/equip390More/391pendingnativeidentification, Mewlipnearby;Aspen399/Daggers404,100by760arrows. All24textsreadahead throughfinal: agentclaims2earlysmithstartsneverforge,stealthrunsdark,final250HPcrisisrecovery and0/2all10deaths; eachlaterclaimstillneedsfulltools/nativeverification. Avoid endorsing causal gear/stealthclaims or glyphcategorization such as moulds untilnativeinspection.", "Root fully read tools 88\u2013138 and all 54 available summaries (no encrypted reasoning). T2 Power763\u2013767 before soldier death1394 at150; T3 Feanor3/4/4/3 M5 E5 Smith5 Song1 Armoursmith54/58 but no forge reached, wound death1180 at50 after unseen attacks and bleed. T4 combat3/4/4/2 Elbereth46/50 Strength in Adversity53/57. Clipped101 merges row14/18 and row12/18; retained ends seen, exact supplemental validation pending. T4 torch churn, Leather245, HandAxe625, Cloak685, trap1681/crows, switches BattleAxe1715 at10HP before death1737. Tool110 continued More after finished -> legitimate409, clear guard fixed111. T5 stealth Feanor2/5/4/3 M4 E4 Stealth7 Song1. Auto raises melee, risk path oscillates100; history125 native projections pending. Disguise2933/2937 after first1502930. Boots only1 protection, low torches3285 inventory0turn reserves, staff self-knowledge3290, unknown DarkBlue3295 no health benefit at full41, unseen block3337. Controller conclusions and summary paraphrases are not native facts; final native review pending.", "Root read remaining tools139\u2013203, all tool calls now203, texts24, available summaries54. T5 finaltorch3340, Greatsword3373, Studded before3499, blind combat through soldier death3760 current150 minimum200. T6 Fingolfin3/4/4/2 M6 E6 Per2 Song1, Keen attempt56 rejected missing3skill, Per3 trained68, actualKeen712/716; Quarterstaff729/730, dark potion unknown, Archer death815 at150. T7 Feanor smith no forge used, Wolf101 at50. T8 Finarfin2/3/3/6 M3E3Per1Song8, Liquor142 to22HP, Delvings145/149, Madthorn198 at200 confused poisoned. T9 Fingolfin2/3/4/5 M5E4Song6 no armour; corrected camera inference168, hazard bypass169, Delvings266/270, poison393 at100. T10 Fingolfin3/3/5/3 M6E6Will3Song1 HP49, Leather+GreatAxe by654 current200 poison9HP33. Power657/661, AzureSlowness690/691, critical724HP8, BirchSelfKnow728/729, Soldierkills733/738, retreat745HP12, unknownBrilliantBlue andGreaves before1048 current250full49. Skillcard1049 shows melee8/E6; Elmstaff1054 unknown effect (summary guessing Slumber unsupported). FinalWarrior1159 at250 -4, 1158keys. Native fatal attribution, projection178/125/112/99/71/20, clipping101, and final workspace/evidence admission remain pending.", "Final native message/depth inventories read completely for all10 trials, plus exact fatal key windows60/45/40/58/70/65/43/40/55/88 frames. Native replay14127 exact; all12684 normal HUD checks match. Full public observations14141 views14127unique, controller14115 unique. Public view differences0. Broad218numbered screens has2false clipped flags101 separately resolved;49supplemental projection checks and9adversarial controls pass. Histories20/71/99/112/125/178 exact. Buffered stdout123 belongs to active command120/session31005 starting1672: independent state read122 at2429 precedes collection of earlier torch2084 stdout; correctly bounded1672\u20132909, documented and validated. No agent code executed by reviewer.", "T1 native actual50f43\u21921001348. Torchgone1530 replacement1598 and again3363, HP33 before Mewlip3356\u219226, joint hits3371\u21929, soldierkill3387HP4 then Mewlip3388HP2/3389\u22121, terminal3390. T2 actual50f42\u2192100667\u21921501100; LesserJewel391, Power765. Soldier encounters/retreat late18\u219210 at1386, Elbereth1392HP11, soldier1393zero terminal1394. T3 actual50f43 only, no body/smith forge unused,351 song prompts/345 plain starts, light1149out, repeatedZrest1167\u20131179 as claws and bleeding drop HP25\u21920; terminal1180. This is policy-level repetition, not a limit.", "T4 actual50f42\u2192100449\u21921501169. Torchchurn before fix, HandAxe625 with low sides, forge575 not used by combat build. Crows summoned1681 atfull41;2kills1696/1698, later trapped near thrall1718 afterBattleAxe1715,6HP\u21923\u21921 thenbrief3, Gorcrow1736\u22121terminal1737. 110calls More afterterminal caused legitimate409;111addsplaying guard. This is the sole execution failure, not service failure.", "T5 actual50f43\u219210056; lengthy risk path oscillation until upstair2928 leads deeper1502929, fullHP atarrival; minimumdepth200later is not actual200. Disguise2935, Boots1647only untilStudded3386; final torch3340out, Greatsword3353, long dark combat and movement, no healing consumed late, soldier3759\u22122terminal3760. T6 actual50f41\u219210052\u2192150464; Keen713afterfirstmissingprerequisite attempt, QuarterstaffMithrim730/753, Dark746triednoidentifiedhealing. Oscillating2/8underarchers755\u2013790 theneightZ791/793/794/795/797/798/802/804, eventualarrow813\u22123death814terminal815. Exact positive regeneration from staff is native; potion effectiveness is not inferred.", "T7 Feanor smith50f43,100keys33turns1.269060s; moves toward then among wolves, no forge/no armour. HP41 at70/72\u219220at76, inventory77nohealing, retreatmoves and Wolf100\u22124terminal101. T8 Finarfin song build actual50f42\u219210066\u2192150108\u2192200173; Liquor141heals22/stuns, firstMadthorn152killed, full34by161 and200173; secondMadthorn187confusesHP23, Brood189poison13, Madthorn197\u22121terminal198. Song fear did rout archers166\u2013167 but not stationary plant; no global build conclusion.", "T9 scored Fingolfin2/3/4/5M5E4Song6 noarmour, actual50f42\u2192100300; failed upstair158/159same50; Delvings268. Full41beforeMewlip35935, hatchlings375\u2013384 poison10\u219233 despite Elbereth, moves6fourtimes387/388/390/392 poisonkills392\u22121 terminal393. T10 scored Fingolfin3/3/5/3M6E6Will3Song1, actual50f43\u2192100327\u2192150380\u2192200552\u2192250919. Leather372GreatAxe410, Power659, poison638\u2013668, Azure690/691Slowness inWolfcombat, critical724HP8; SelfKnow729onlyslow, Soldierkills733/738HP9/10, eastretreat745HP12; full49at919. BrilliantBlue960TrueSight nothealing, Greaves1036. Swordspiderkill1083, RedSerpent1105 thenZ1106 recovers30\u219249; finalgroup1138, warriorflee1142/1146, Trollbatters1147HP38fire114834/114925\u219220at1150, attacking8/9notretreat before Troll1155HP9, Troll1157HP3 and Warrior1158HP\u22124, terminal1159. Last death occurred inside normal action/Moreprocessing, prior critical stop did not trigger before terminal.", "All204 actualAstra requests medium,128000 output,997500effective client context,peak171419,no compaction/model errors/missingusage/boundary flags. Ten complete native deaths,zeroSilmarils/escapes/retirements/resourcecaps,14117keys total,max3759keys and543.358046s vs100000/43200. Costestimate$23.62463 vs$1200. All21Python files and2Markdownfiles read, guide/manual exactfrozen, ownresults exactsummary. Agent claims about shields, medicine, presumedSlumber and learning remain hypotheses; native confirmations above govern analysis. Reviewer is developmentagent, no independenthuman validation." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 14127, "exact_replayed_frames": 14127, "matching_public_views": 14141, "unique_full_json_frames": 14127, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 218, "additional_signals": 0, "supplemental_native_projection_checks": 49, "controller_clip_flags_resolved": 2, "normal_hud_checks": 12684, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 23.62463, "evidence_sha256": { "assistant_text.json": "1be633f5b770699a982d4fd5788ea9d0364be716cc64e0a802e4db9a594ce64f", "audited-reading-proof.json": "259f61e796f498ba5171304edd4c0bb5a61886229dde67a9a0d916334b09d96a", "available_reasoning_summaries.json": "7d0b14a1ce6a607465585b5c1b1184f429ae7377b97a2affd6ba19ea8845f2c0", "controller-findings-review.json": "99b6ba59d3ecea03269a9a97bfd592ff03a7c7ecba6132538df3c899a67d2294", "manifest.json": "db1f576301c214688a083f19427b86f7def9ed16bc39273c33094aed927db35f", "native-review-working.json": "c5e122785c38ab6ada8644ecb1cafedd48c32a749cf7d552d572db191c1eeb67", "projection-counterexamples.json": "0853d2dd604b17a64bb6dfa6435fb00821343eaa0c11a4b86fde147578199f12", "public_observation_audit.json": "b8ee77c32ab4e1ca5ff6bf116f1e9b42974080ff59f0b3044c84a7b6e4d08c57", "qualitative-working.json": "81ce86c4632c681413af1981f05d6e6fc8d835f5975ec3a4d20a5bb8c63e539b", "replay.json": "ab255b19ebd5f387c71c4f50510c4e2be65068ce5e371affa766408473d14d93", "review.json": "d48b99640812ef2ac25598bdf3fdd061f8706a5c76394529408ab2523ab20238", "source-read-audit.json": "0eeed3f8a93846822045f94a39a269d46d7ed8fb26d7852b7b889e8abf39f038", "state/events.jsonl": "a8ab71de92d03ca7a0da98c93721f2f2299b394632c5f67ac556cf482a202785", "state/summary.json": "37f80c1acbc47eaa743e6c1d2bbd5587324ec50fd46d7773c46211a96c7a48af", "tool_calls_complete.json": "35d2489d44ee2865f422fb3cddec9c730e5b821f754c8237836f01b5f566042a", "tool_review_coverage.json": "214493ca224701713abc2d13fd074c715c7ad555fa9246d1dc93b5c4a8d4c40c", "trial01-fatal-keys.txt": "c9cfe5713eb9e8691751e4d04b97877a60452edb883cbb0987bbbfc3ae1309b0", "trial01-native-messages.txt": "16b864bc9bedc442a71765db23e810a0d26c23b61537fd43d942c51d768248df", "trial02-fatal-keys.txt": "a4af995d58dec4b3983a37e29eb1e7542fc1343e93d61468e53032a352451111", "trial02-native-messages.txt": "2892e42bb455c4010a639838287f5d7f22c4217ebc64d69f7a9ab1069866a280", "trial03-fatal-keys.txt": "fb107247ce8a4ee34b2d7ba895101c7cfe60f5512ba3c0b6c4c873f18557b0ac", "trial03-native-messages.txt": "49b6398a58d8e3c90ff97e520e17db38f086b3cf7741b31e3cd7366f0bd68831", "trial04-fatal-keys.txt": "018133d355a4c9abc47d979c9eeea7b215df18de923bf071bdf98bec1a58daf3", "trial04-native-messages.txt": "b64cdba46442405c6969c3c6ea4f5afe0800b95a55fa9b6a107cc2e960ae5e0d", "trial05-fatal-keys.txt": "940b8c38f2af8ebb6d709a0db191925a6d22f3f31275cf08cc942259bb1bf4e1", "trial05-native-messages.txt": "4a6e20653b4d4d9f58e98f7f5e92a8b5979f58156b7eb9facd0e1f83cb240eea", "trial06-fatal-keys.txt": "6e23222ee6a6c6ff3625f479de442790f60334adf539b2a9588bf5e1b5141404", "trial06-native-messages.txt": "8431a2ce6a7226a01bb6f2ea95d7a74e2af9856eba8a62d4b91617baf24b0031", "trial07-fatal-keys.txt": "baabb4a7a0a9d43a2738705875a1308bfcf914216a13a96bb0db00076a69fe3e", "trial07-native-messages.txt": "e53f5a9339b25f294cd72ddc93d86fb62f18fb18e269efe391d7ab07c68ae4ff", "trial08-fatal-keys.txt": "5f51ac0bd67f67cd606b35ceb7141d8dd65c018438c09173d5800c20b68e7db9", "trial08-native-messages.txt": "13a1680f01ecc50ff9b19c4ff3e12cb2a83971155ffb08378c25f50a4dfc0964", "trial09-fatal-keys.txt": "0816d2b039f94993ca6072c5d0eaa90098c50d0f2073726d9ccb0ce2884e348a", "trial09-native-messages.txt": "45f4b81214fa46243ee713dadb5779ea5fbce4324334bb0545ffaecfa0cd414c", "trial10-fatal-keys.txt": "90a7ea0bedbe0df1a0a7d520bc9bb472241723b487e6bf81c27a51702198db0d", "trial10-native-messages.txt": "d84299d5fc68b326e277e6c3f568ec868875fb0e64aabd725dbcdda6e3a8781c", "v3-controller-audit.json": "2bb63d37bba6894c0b9fae36a4dd28762cc271b9092e7194cbfe430fadc6c52b", "v3-medium08-projection-audit.json": "10c887e386ffe89e77ca401e1ee9a5068143c0f6476655140675b7d04a527708", "workspace-file-review.json": "d970d476773823382e7f8cb2bcb78f16fdaf409f7e242c444cffe97535344155", "workspace-snapshot.json": "42d62048a4f590e2b240931bc97daa7e701e3c842e03cf2d320a6ca8d6c38a7b" } }, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "db1f576301c214688a083f19427b86f7def9ed16bc39273c33094aed927db35f", "qualitative_review.json": "0404827a238998104055959b7de66a777607d8571da7253237f772ea39d020bf", "review.json": "d48b99640812ef2ac25598bdf3fdd061f8706a5c76394529408ab2523ab20238", "replay.json": "ab255b19ebd5f387c71c4f50510c4e2be65068ce5e371affa766408473d14d93", "state/summary.json": "37f80c1acbc47eaa743e6c1d2bbd5587324ec50fd46d7773c46211a96c7a48af" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-medium-09", "condition": "astra-medium", "bundle": 9, "admitted": true, "status": "complete_valid", "best": 0, "mean": 0.0, "scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1050, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 400.5759754180908, "keys_used": 1512 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 5201, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 599.819094657898, "keys_used": 4602 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc champion", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -6, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2336, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 346.25345849990845, "keys_used": 2469 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Whispering shadow", "depth_feet": 400, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 400, "player_turns": 8775, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1647.5874288082123, "keys_used": 9920 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1092, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 529.7616400718689, "keys_used": 1141 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Boldog, the Merciless", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2245, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 361.87173295021057, "keys_used": 2628 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1942, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 361.4187455177307, "keys_used": 1610 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc champion", "depth_feet": 350, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 350, "player_turns": 2578, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1310.8693306446075, "keys_used": 2834 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc skirmisher", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 164, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 592.310403585434, "keys_used": 245 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 1143, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1175.602131843567, "keys_used": 1552 } ], "requests": 541, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1623, "input_tokens_cache_write": 606935, "input_tokens_cache_read": 164210242, "output_tokens": 139731, "reasoning_tokens": 89443 }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 315.361155, "peak_request_input_tokens": 606938, "scaffold": { "captured_at": 1788844741.4508653, "model_context_windows": [ 997500 ], "last_session_timestamp": "2026-09-08T05:18:44.691Z", "compactions_observed": 0, "scope": "last read-only live snapshot; authoritative full model history remains in Inspect" }, "rejected_requests": 2, "execution_failures": [ { "call_id": "call_2tfpD4JEx7M864LnKQuBIuPB", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_LMvUBheYt1nVQa6b0Tw3ruO8", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" } ], "structured_tool_errors": [], "replayed_frames": 28523, "qualitative_review": { "reviewed_at": 1788845622.0861902, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 541, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 30, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 62, "tool_calls_reviewed": 540, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_JwSV1o1dnrZE6nc7x2hnto7g", "call_RYzE5RP3mFUUS71lGuQUu2V1", "call_efaAvdYmD7YyUem2oQTPg3iy" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1, 186, 212 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; saturation gate requires all ten sessions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc soldier", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1050, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 400.5759754180908, "keys_used": 1512 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 5201, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 599.819094657898, "keys_used": 4602 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc champion", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -6, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2336, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 346.25345849990845, "keys_used": 2469 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Whispering shadow", "depth_feet": 400, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 400, "player_turns": 8775, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1647.5874288082123, "keys_used": 9920 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1092, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 529.7616400718689, "keys_used": 1141 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Boldog, the Merciless", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2245, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 361.87173295021057, "keys_used": 2628 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1942, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 361.4187455177307, "keys_used": 1610 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc champion", "depth_feet": 350, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 350, "player_turns": 2578, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1310.8693306446075, "keys_used": 2834 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc skirmisher", "depth_feet": 50, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 50, "player_turns": 164, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 592.310403585434, "keys_used": 245 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 250, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 250, "player_turns": 1143, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 1175.602131843567, "keys_used": 1552 } ], "notes": [ "All540 tool calls,30 visible assistant messages and62 available reasoning summaries were read. Encrypted reasoning was not inspected. The previously reviewed live534/28/62 prefix is unchanged. All35 final Python files and notes were read, including complete diffs for six birth variants; supplied guide/manual and final result JSON match their sources.", "All ten games ended in native death with no jewel or escape. Both scored games return zero. Native replay reproduces all28,523 frames and24,897 normal HUD checks have no discrepancies. All native distinct messages and fatal key windows were read. No environment defect or resource-bound game was observed.", "Trials1\u20132 used Fingolfin fighters and died at200 feet. The first controller confused friendly and player @ glyphs and spent412 inputs on wall bumps before correcting its parser. The second lost its torch and later repeatedly rested under unseen archery. Trials3\u20136 used smithing builds; trial3 reached300 feet, trial4 reached400, trial5 died from residual poison after killing the Brood spider, and trial6 died to Boldog after emergency consumables included Slowness and Poison. Trial4 corrected several controller loops but later rested under Shadow attacks. Trial7 added Alchemy and reached200 feet before a wolf killed it.", "Trial8 explored archery, forged a Longbow and armor, and recovered from8 HP. It reached350 feet. While Lug and an Orc champion were adjacent, firing at Lug permitted an opportunity attack by the champion, followed by the champion\u2019s regular killing blow. The agent then restricted point-blank shooting to one adjacent enemy. This sequence records a attempted correction; it is not a controlled learning-effect estimate.", "Scored trial9 was trapped by wolves at50 feet before finding armor or a forge. It survived the initial emergency, killed five wolves along a narrow passage and recovered partly. Orc skirmishers attacked from both sides and killed it at native frame245, followed by terminal246. The improved corridor behavior and the later loss both remain in the record.", "Scored trial10 forged a Longbow,12 arrows and a Cloak, and recovered arrows repeatedly while fighting through150 feet. It reached250 feet with partial armor. A prolonged Orc fight exhausted ammunition. After melee reduced it to14 HP, the character retreated, drank an unidentified Slowness potion and used a Terror herb. The herb\u2019s speed effect briefly offset slowing; slowing returned at frame1550. A final northward move let an Orc warrior charge and kill it at frame1552; terminal1553 confirms HP0.", "The session-specific checker matched668 numbered screens,668 color lists and26,416 complete archived HTTP views. Another111 source-transcribed checks cover ability screens, item descriptions, forge designs, histories and coordinates. Eight controller controls and sixteen projection controls accept original evidence and reject22 alterations. Three clipped outputs were reviewed using only their retained text. Player/hostile classification, remembered maps, equipment scores and causal assertions remain agent inferences.", "The general public audit matched26,440 views covering26,428 full unique screens, with79 further native screens recovered from exact numbered displays. The early controller saved only the optional batch-frames array; call77 corrected it to save scalar responses too. Consequently2,016 protected native frames (1,439 in trial1 and577 in trial2) lack an independently captured complete client view. This logging limitation is disclosed rather than claiming those views were reviewed. The full protected native replay, exposed views, controller source and native death sequences were reviewed; no alternate or replacement game was run.", "All541 recorded requests used Astra medium, output allowance128000 and effective context997500; peak input606938. No compaction, model error, missing usage, retirement or resource cap occurred. Two agent-code failures were postterminal HTTP409 responses, which correctly preserve the native deaths. Longest game1647.587429 seconds, largest key count9920; request-priced cost$315.361155. No human winning baseline or causal learning conclusion is claimed." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 28523, "exact_replayed_frames": 28523, "matching_public_views": 26440, "unique_full_json_frames": 26428, "additional_missing_full_views_matched_numbered": 79, "not_captured_as_complete_client_views": 2016, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 668, "additional_signals": 668, "supplemental_native_projection_checks": 111, "normal_hud_checks": 24897, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 315.361155, "evidence_sha256": { "assistant_text.json": "8e857b3d7fb612f28d8a03a5d64964316484d826f29a0d8738de8e07f4a20438", "audited-reading-proof.json": "d6f74f081961ec458d8b270df05cba0757b635b6469f66a5a004c38bb21bbf9d", "available_reasoning_summaries.json": "fa561beb989edc3421eebb5c1f735681b6568ad0d07aed64dd10c5a02d594b29", "controller-counterexamples.json": "e1f1a0833c291177f5641242102c699202c54ca8d895b849c28cabc82a84c336", "controller-findings-review.json": "3cbacdb17c2a5f55b8d733745f0702e4b08b5aea2197ef0c0ce74d51c4943e66", "live-final-review-continuity.json": "f5ac1e2e98176a4476e6e72d99835b1dbf6ad1be2516ced8c1c9a58823f5d160", "manifest.json": "21743b1d6e4829dca83586f21354639d85795cd3d996e31825030991d567e5e5", "native-review-working.json": "93d5e6158aa0b956dbd81ff1463e48a8e6731dce6f34f38de2b4415fc998a8f1", "projection-counterexamples.json": "c80a12cf4c59fe1aa6f40df9800b5181662e4da17157a37e63524d86892cf4ef", "public_observation_audit.json": "319608f1e136feac92348e9ac2e95ca26fc160acebf6b93492bedd8f22bbcc79", "qualitative-working.json": "8c5b60868e48bca1b77fc0a7cb6dff71464cf7d07c012e86afc4db4d3e0e4a65", "replay.json": "e879a27d1dbe961587647011bab51ca72f2656c28cc96f50af37bf97f504f2a1", "review.json": "6fbaae607922f462963ba0894129bd6f1705dea89bface22c647d6c9f4f80c2a", "source-read-audit.json": "8ea08f99112b6945d67f04bdc8f4cf7028f6476aa86049d249f2c745deec4bc8", "state/events.jsonl": "4d0c51b025461db5acf978bc49c8a343069b87b19bb9b40b5e615fba841bd2a5", "state/summary.json": "3d1c4758f3d83974407a940b977a3a7817cabbd41b54655b30ced41873dfc45c", "tool_calls_complete.json": "c07668e907c5f163d7b8f693ff6dd6b0450f173806baed7190617442a10762d8", "tool_review_coverage.json": "39066aff069582920fe59071eec9e72ba08c9eaf1487607cc433c604ff49a4cc", "trial01-fatal-keys.txt": "8788ceef8523772a1cc8d145e323d3224ad98aa7ea63329393da75cf76cfdda1", "trial01-native-messages.txt": "ae26fc5f2b13123a4991fb96fa86dcc40f5c3eddbe4795e468e164dc8c828ca1", "trial02-fatal-keys.txt": "75a825a9f4d367c66624c5b63e51326d6dadc10815c7d8bb487363cc16a95da1", "trial02-native-messages.txt": "c42c33de1d3d05890ebdd86fbd2d780d84d2eaa1bb0fa87e86cabf94fdc7b4ec", "trial03-fatal-keys.txt": "f3b56dc55643619882e5fadb92ebb9a1ffc92baa5bb9f4142ddf0072dfecc194", "trial03-native-messages.txt": "6eb189c84cadf2b62b27ad3c6bef960be40ce6938c162991895a4e393dccc356", "trial04-fatal-keys.txt": "e944ea1f1c8f2e473816a79e3a0bfea5665d30dcfa1f8a494710cf8553f3ecf4", "trial04-native-messages.txt": "d56a895db25f47cd2f95af144fa8e994d46658c1fd0b3276d41468a8f5ba2b3a", "trial05-fatal-keys.txt": "4f28ec350294934aa102e84917acbfa8993e72a70e7dcab29d81520da6143b86", "trial05-native-messages.txt": "c57cddc8922932d26e2185fc41af37633be592c1f7273d470366fdacacb2f83a", "trial06-fatal-keys.txt": "e809d0b9426db7d644e712ecc2bf28a2937550630cbde1199feb888d8c19767e", "trial06-native-messages.txt": "496cd43dbdd6debcfd7592a649c8fb4c65eaab2b64217c02425c538f826ac43b", "trial07-fatal-keys.txt": "d1f22b2f2ed63dca27d86aa269e4b5e57e301cbd4300fa8e47cacd6aa2772378", "trial07-native-messages.txt": "18a7092284c31267e5419669fb3ec3c89473079b01a56c3d93d84f5afa32b2f4", "trial08-fatal-keys.txt": "16c3ae46428d82bf1d5d0c40a41be58c779006b8a1be6f712a5e238254841b28", "trial08-native-messages.txt": "0622902edc2ff6fd9a5cfe141d149390d3eb04af78679a542a8b09de9ebbabb1", "trial09-fatal-keys.txt": "a1c39e9f0e4d553fecd8a1d3f619f8c02d9d92cacb445b8955ed917d3d7c464b", "trial09-native-messages.txt": "0b6abddccedb89c48eaac7eadb55f76075c5e8a5c23b673480679b9467cd89b7", "trial10-fatal-keys.txt": "93eb033589ac88a833e5aad04a3e36451bba3fe17636b43fb91d39f943dc137f", "trial10-native-messages.txt": "ac4d9bbd9b1183ae290dba6ea6d7711aa434b8c6b4fce357c897d016f7041182", "v3-medium09-controller-audit.json": "3d66071cf2baaab04630059d8e9cd2a4daefedbb46547924d239365021ef4be1", "v3-medium09-projection-audit.json": "9ef0411265b10f3588a7744372d9cd2511ae124f2e9f7b9640bf63e50d1d5b02", "v3-medium09-reading-proof.json": "aa2b06c2f87ea2beccef2f7b0a92019603fcfdf0c062d6114b19308f51e135d1", "workspace-file-review.json": "8c315ee0c1f81a9edb6b1a147661934fbeef23ca9df25152d0835eafb603cfab", "workspace-snapshot.json": "19d54929e77aeeea362c0289b3d3ad41fa8e6700b2aa06bb80d5bb262d1d39f7" } }, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "21743b1d6e4829dca83586f21354639d85795cd3d996e31825030991d567e5e5", "qualitative_review.json": "159c4980f28eda90d4cf5da4469ba7b878f1e23e9c5c33f9f64c9da550e3311c", "review.json": "6fbaae607922f462963ba0894129bd6f1705dea89bface22c647d6c9f4f80c2a", "replay.json": "e879a27d1dbe961587647011bab51ca72f2656c28cc96f50af37bf97f504f2a1", "state/summary.json": "3d1c4758f3d83974407a940b977a3a7817cabbd41b54655b30ced41873dfc45c" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-medium-10", "condition": "astra-medium", "bundle": 10, "admitted": true, "status": "complete_valid", "best": 0, "mean": 0.0, "scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1208, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 277.26691722869873, "keys_used": 1068 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2341, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 224.88513779640198, "keys_used": 2677 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 220, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 31.67789888381958, "keys_used": 240 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 3049, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 423.1470453739166, "keys_used": 6154 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Grimhawk", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1064, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 44.847962617874146, "keys_used": 912 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1210, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 55.852476596832275, "keys_used": 1304 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Gorgol, the Butcher", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1395, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 44.506978273391724, "keys_used": 1519 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1568, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 26.354562997817993, "keys_used": 1633 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 450, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 450, "player_turns": 3164, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 806.5104579925537, "keys_used": 3593 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Grave wight", "depth_feet": 400, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 400, "player_turns": 4105, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 8418.32487821579, "keys_used": 6709 } ], "requests": 527, "usage": { "input_tokens": 1581, "input_tokens_cache_write": 524949, "input_tokens_cache_read": 140857980, "output_tokens": 219407, "reasoning_tokens": 168981 }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 267.63985, "peak_request_input_tokens": 524952, "scaffold": { "captured_at": 1788855832.3243392, "model_context_windows": [ 997500 ], "last_session_timestamp": "2026-09-08T08:23:39.200Z", "compactions_observed": 0, "scope": "last read-only live snapshot; authoritative full model history remains in Inspect" }, "rejected_requests": 0, "execution_failures": [ { "call_id": "call_0i9yziDR7Qn1RRSkDu66NSII", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_Y1ngDxJNXEWtFYtpjbw5S95a", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" }, { "call_id": "call_LmOBEeT5mPRoyDoneFZXxVKW", "function": "exec", "category": "agent_code_error" } ], "structured_tool_errors": [], "replayed_frames": 25819, "qualitative_review": { "reviewed_at": 1788856305.7624066, "reviewer": "root development agent; no independent human review", "review_complete": true, "admitted": true, "requests_verified": 527, "visible_assistant_messages_reviewed": 42, "available_reasoning_summaries_reviewed": 55, "tool_calls_reviewed": 526, "reviewed_truncated_calls": [ "call_iBcssUaXSFRIwIsLbu9hJz95", "call_zuhM46yQfTITdday0JCCxDFY", "call_U8rBHIq4Kb00qPn5F2x7RFQE" ], "reviewed_truncated_call_numbers": [ 1, 44, 54 ], "resolved_public_view_findings": 0, "boundary_findings_review": [], "environment_errors": [], "resource_limits_bound": false, "scaffold_context_verified": true, "capability_result": "One valid Astra-medium session; cohort saturation decision is computed from all ten admissions.", "recorded_scored_wins": [ 0, 0 ], "trials": [ { "trial": 1, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1208, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 277.26691722869873, "keys_used": 1068 }, { "trial": 2, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a White wolf", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 2341, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 224.88513779640198, "keys_used": 2677 }, { "trial": 3, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 220, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 31.67789888381958, "keys_used": 240 }, { "trial": 4, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc archer", "depth_feet": 300, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -4, "max_depth_feet": 300, "player_turns": 3049, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 423.1470453739166, "keys_used": 6154 }, { "trial": 5, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Grimhawk", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1064, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 44.847962617874146, "keys_used": 912 }, { "trial": 6, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "an Orc warrior", "depth_feet": 200, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -2, "max_depth_feet": 200, "player_turns": 1210, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 55.852476596832275, "keys_used": 1304 }, { "trial": 7, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "Gorgol, the Butcher", "depth_feet": 150, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -5, "max_depth_feet": 150, "player_turns": 1395, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 44.506978273391724, "keys_used": 1519 }, { "trial": 8, "phase": "learning", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Tanglethorn", "depth_feet": 100, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -3, "max_depth_feet": 100, "player_turns": 1568, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 26.354562997817993, "keys_used": 1633 }, { "trial": 9, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "poison", "depth_feet": 450, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": 0, "max_depth_feet": 450, "player_turns": 3164, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 806.5104579925537, "keys_used": 3593 }, { "trial": 10, "phase": "scored", "status": "finished", "result": { "cause": "a Grave wight", "depth_feet": 400, "ending": "death", "escaped": false, "hp": -1, "max_depth_feet": 400, "player_turns": 4105, "silmarils": 0, "win": 0 }, "seconds": 8418.32487821579, "keys_used": 6709 } ], "notes": [ "All526 complete tool calls,42 visible assistant texts and55 available reasoning summaries were read. The completed exports exactly match the reviewed live evidence. All nine final Python files were read, including complete revision diffs; final notes and code snippet were read, and saved results match the service summary. Encrypted reasoning was not inspected and root never executed agent code or pickle.", "All ten games ended in native death, with no jewel or escape. Scored games reached450 and400feet. Exact replay reproduced all25819 native frames;22111 normal HUD checks had no discrepancies. All native distinct-message content and120 final keys per game were reviewed. The final game\u2019s1335 distinct messages are bound to six fully read contiguous windows by exact reconstruction against the completed journal.", "Practice games explored melee/evasion, smithing and song builds. Trials1and4 repeatedly rested under damaging plant or arrow attacks. Trial4 also had1490 fear-blocked inputs and a long aiming-prompt loop; the agent corrected those controller behaviors. Trial8 spent782 inputs bumping a door, then died while fighting stationary plants. These input counts are not equivalent to native turns. Some characters forged useful armor; others spent on smithing without using a forge. No controlled build-effect claim is made.", "Scored trial9 forged mail and shields, recovered after a Mountain Troll fight using Blocking, learned Delvings and reached450feet. It killed a Snow Troll and recovered to36HP before arrow damage and a routing loop. A retreat through a closed door met an Orc captain. The character drank an unidentified poison potion, then a stale inventory letter selected poison again. A later tried potion did not heal; native poison reduced HP to0 at3593 and terminal3594 followed.", "Scored trial10 used Alchemy and identified consumables. It survived several severe encounters: Light, Quickness, Warding and Elbereth accompanied an8HP descent to350feet and later recoveries; two retreats from400to350feet reached19HP and7HP. It killed isolated champions and trolls and returned to full or near-full health. These local successes are retained alongside the final death. Warding, light, speed and fear effects were temporary, and repeated Grave Wight encounters drained Strength.", "Trial10\u2019s inventory classifier initially omitted Studded Leather and retained heavy spare equipment. Manual drops removed slowing, but later Strength drain produced402 rejected movement inputs at the same native turn4064. The model revised its parser to confirm the player with Look, then discarded equipment to move again. At1HP, an additional Song point and attacks preceded both trolls fleeing; the character moved west, survived an Attercop encounter and reached5HP. Slowing returned. During the final attack\u2019s pending resolution, the Grave Wight hit for the fatal damage at6709; terminal6710 records HP\u22121 and playerturn4105.", "The controller\u2019s ordinary adjacent-attack return became unreachable in call315 because it followed a return inside the focused-attack condition. Setting focusedFalse later did not restore that branch. Other movement choices could still resolve as melee, and the model used manual attacks extensively. The final report\u2019s claim that Easterling/player color overlap materially corrupted navigation is not established by the inspected6500\u20136504 screens, which show playercolor11 and hostile@color9. No counterfactual survival or causal learning effect is inferred.", "Three nonzero agent-code exits and a further TypeError visible in piped output were reviewed. They do not represent engine failures. Three clipped outputs were reviewed only through retained text. All575 numbered screens and3671 additional public-data projections matched native sources. Thirty-nine controls accept original evidence and reject37 deliberate alterations. Full client views cover every native frame; there is no capture gap in this session.", "Native information has limits. The armor sidebar intentionally excludes Blocking while the character sheet can include it. Orcish Liquor heals and removes fear but adds stun; an earlier root working-note error about curing stun was corrected before admission and preserved in a correction record. Territorial recall abbreviates a line-of-sight pursuit condition, so its wording should not be read as immobility or a fixed six-square territory. The native description\u2019s omitted condition is disclosed; observed corridor pursuit is consistent with the pinned engine. No adapter corruption or material game-contract defect was found.", "All527 requests used Astra medium with128000 output allowance and997500 effective context; peak input524952. No compaction, model error, missing usage, boundary finding, rejected game request, retirement or resource guard occurred. The longest game took8418.324878seconds; maximum6709keys. Estimated request-priced cost was$267.639850. Reviews and direct play are by the development agent, with no independent human winning baseline." ], "observation_review": { "native_frames": 25819, "exact_replayed_frames": 25819, "matching_public_views": 25835, "unique_full_json_frames": 25819, "additional_missing_full_views_matched_numbered": 0, "not_captured_as_complete_client_views": 0, "differences_or_incomplete": 0, "additional_numbered_screens": 575, "additional_signals": 0, "supplemental_native_projection_checks": 3671, "normal_hud_checks": 22111, "workspace_snapshot_omitted_files": [] }, "estimated_request_priced_usd": 267.63985, "evidence_sha256": { "armor-display-review.json": "6258eb58f58998eb61d7c3d67d9e3fcbe1a30b7ef789f341f14abb6fdb36cd3c", "assistant_text.json": "f7bf0438cce5667a205d6c4088e4622fce83ed3adcdb33b2ef58ca840ec82484", "audited-reading-proof.json": "06e6c9cfbe39d2421ecb2ef7db70e73fff2a46b26d0ae03218febf8dbac993e7", "available_reasoning_summaries.json": "26d0b9dd1099b34a7e8052ccf26c8bce4e98ac832c05aa40975fa14bd32bd799", "controller-findings-review.json": "d84f1aff87cd8f017a306c4424f591aa011ab35b1e16a7e33d956cc09dee424f", "liquor-review-correction.json": "b03a236a68cd4dde7cb062ae1aebec53f664850a8ed9914d38725386b28407f2", "live-final-review-continuity.json": "43b70d405ea539019240b7842c155db833b4bfc8f52b282c7f780d23f5020829", "manifest.json": "d362a8d92e793fd8a6b719239cdd69ec16acf425a78e474ed7b81fc7cd0882d4", "native-message-reading-proof.json": "bda27f3e52e9d3d59ea603347f069c18ad21b6e8bc52c09ee613cc62846f34c9", "native-review-working.json": "906fb4103c16f1a5a4943b6f827a34846194ccb27c43f7b14986df20ec4cfbe4", "native-source-review/files.c": "3ff3a0fbee87ea13b4e753068a7a9afaf701a2cef525cd3adb8fac7323f4098f", "native-source-review/melee1.c": "85604072726db239ec23ad35dcd9e4824a3ab009511745178b64d92daa2bf9e3", "native-source-review/melee2.c": "a9c32e903e5f81c5f9fe1ffd71cbf95018d4960cc91e9447cd280b0891a8d91d", "native-source-review/monster1.c": "8673eca162e1185dc0a7de8554f1307c0cb9ed9ccc2a9f4ded0fe2c40ea01c21", "native-source-review/xtra1.c": "363c5e2e99c5dd7179552ec340a6790128b552885f2c21d5ee25232ca47a5aa9", "projection-counterexamples.json": "75a02149c0003544e863b060815fe29600498c0fc5420d385852f519138bde7e", "public_observation_audit.json": "6458e984ac82856ec96fd022a77cf2d73e5e341f6ff25286018b47298044c196", "qualitative-working.json": "1c3fa7b37760a0bac74a1fb66e547b99f3771b719eb3dff9ca4ecbc4d2a94b98", "replay.json": "25e685b3065de9ef8f17678ac14fc720599e26d6efc65370e19839e0ca260743", "review-scripts/audit_astra01_controller.py": "dfe362b3ae585714c22030b734df2a362e7b2e5849a5987764d917589f285bb5", "review-scripts/audit_public_observations.py": "a69757644ab0237a1a92a8e6e79c57c60c506dc1c5e391b6142fcdad1b2670ff", "review-scripts/audit_v3_controller.py": "f95a0132301d01dca26b2551ddc79a5b4fcb0010c0d5081ded10f366f0deaef7", "review-scripts/audit_v3_medium09_controller.py": "51b8d1a6a1a5f3a4e93aafecb1bc781bb4e323a8a05222bbea23f4ef33c84674", "review-scripts/audit_v3_medium10_controller.py": "be6ae7b30f88978aa0b72ad4ebc1d31e20e1aa8662e24894470efe18b2b71413", "review-scripts/audit_v3_medium10_projections.py": "46e86bbfd4f130c4a80c0060538cd4f75d0323519106be7c703fce00cd592d47", "review-scripts/audited_reading_copy.py": "8ebf1054285efef10d6292c9e8459a518e7075dd1cc1728b9252d413f231c6b7", "review-scripts/check_v3_medium10_projections.py": "6cfbf6416889fa116554b7877a9eb1571dc60266af4c8cd7802b4d7cb078a9aa", "review-scripts/compact_tool_review.py": "89e1ded44469d3b809a6dbba3f8df7a4f9798ce02d9bcfdd2bf5b11c7607f301", "review-scripts/compare_live_review.py": "ae2697297febc32a40b387efb20a50e37adbc78a9140dafa213affb46ebc783b", "review-scripts/fatal_key_review.py": "202d80d3644bcab4976588784444953bd39fae47efe6b0cf077080e6472485ba", "review-scripts/native_review.py": "0aaac921c55fc0629ef4414103e88c92a0d3d1da8300cf4e9be9c7abb1e2d573", "review-scripts/native_trial_prefix.py": "bee48b83424ef1d6cece7ef580909eef4c90ba7be9e84403e804617b5b286fe9", "review-scripts/reading_v3_medium10.py": "9c0e2deb9f46f00bb7eb9dbc8faf51e1ab6eece7f9cdbaec085d17c9453727df", "review-scripts/refresh_live_review.py": "2a1b26b3c6beef21fb484b29122382e2a36ffdfdfbd4913896f157f1986c7f84", "review-scripts/research.py": "2a46bdddc6a6d821c9f97876b4f4d1826cf68aa310641873c306d5fa7b9babf8", "review-scripts/source_checked_review.py": "54ae6c616c80b653dfbe98f8f7335dc3636c66f48f99d3e6d0d72df1be499531", "review-scripts/verify_medium10_native_reading.py": "bd548f253694cfa0d0f96d2279f3d39d1518004d208e809a9471c08630bc8dfd", "review.json": "c39db474957be3f14a8d9abceee139898708ba0fc71d0623ca3e9e0db947efb8", "source-read-audit.json": "71b490be0e47bad7440505cb749b5000e9599a5bca73c043167edded2f357e44", "state/events.jsonl": "50627f4728a874e833465548b611de965130009f99bf19da37f0eff9c8319ae9", "state/summary.json": "3002cb3d295bf2a32c374ab5768d99cc1832bd31b628220cb5e1a14a4be26fab", "territorial-recall-review.json": "23762d614d0587bdedccdd5e985d08830b43bcd6b3505774379cef207df17b27", "tool_calls_complete.json": "2ef5accab59c8fab201ed22d2f615b118e85ed25282d5968c2043d6e80c310f1", "tool_review_coverage.json": "b63fd5a2b93e59c06343527e9d63621ce88a092f490cdbfb366e3c8b269ec3b7", "trial01-fatal-keys.txt": "227b7624d73a8b0f0e2b29c5813a7f958b51f87ea5485c8f3938f2b94249b7d6", "trial01-native-messages.txt": "336f8587718023a6d9f7bdb336845da8a2ebbaaebfbac0f710f963be3c90c540", "trial02-fatal-keys.txt": "7f1e474ccfed1d4497f6b5732046a842427f2bf8551c03d97127430ee0fc4b3c", "trial02-native-messages.txt": "ff89b03144973c88eff8520157b86e66d9e32af9ef1c926e17fa6b06960b0d21", "trial03-fatal-keys.txt": "a4dbb33a039267bb1473494d8e2e03cf9084d3c29de095d45ff8ade80f0d7f56", "trial03-native-messages.txt": "030d50952b9a2ee5847fc14602629fbe445cb5fd0a93a47b5b157fee6956e979", "trial04-fatal-keys.txt": "def442f3ff0c865ea769f3d67e9574393f30dcc77382eee1b4f2b379ff059f29", "trial04-native-messages.txt": "b7387862342c312c1d1abc4a3acf6c65f88c2af790a9d1eece8709c33b01b073", "trial05-fatal-keys.txt": "8b0026136a212b1880abc88b9936dd8f89c270414a92573fe72c982a1cc4966d", "trial05-native-messages.txt": "647c98dec42f20f36ef1c6ec6639b8ecc2073fb7bc0b5f092a46b5ef90097273", "trial06-fatal-keys.txt": "098f52bea20dda6d98e44a4f45b0f584ce6b0209a7512964e152035af790fb02", "trial06-native-messages.txt": "e1a1e09af55fba8debb55846e13f5d9d4094af5021ccca0b75ad7a4ad924ccfe", "trial07-fatal-keys.txt": "95d276d1225e613e306de09c865fdafa191a47f11da26e6d1335e7b5ca5d6428", "trial07-native-messages.txt": "963f835ce3449db41a88dbe717686b13bf2f31ddb225c050e38e9583b11d1c08", "trial08-fatal-keys.txt": "3b647ab87fa3530a8382cb0e3223e4fa91f49f9f7dc05ce304c5413475d11e91", "trial08-native-messages.txt": "88c529b44e00a149af242864804c299859d2813fda3fe6d9c9af899621957701", "trial09-fatal-keys.txt": "f1ce23ff3e84c8748bb49f07880cc88888dfba9c7fbd2f326d7cdab20770007a", "trial09-native-messages.txt": "76dce2bd7a1426858f100643bd29e8640fcdb6051fbd69f1558b519e62f8b8ac", "trial10-fatal-keys.txt": "5d6b3da84f95b324f300df67c3eb15cdd0dd7e686d773beefaca9841fed0f2d2", "trial10-native-messages.txt": "88cdef62366af219c906ac4f716b466b22676d7726c1fd88696d92564d412b9f", "trial10-native-prefix-5000.txt": "d70429e721bbfecff8a0b8a59b2c69f9be42d11d2c72fbbe6afb9806d7930bb9", "trial10-native-window-5001-5784.txt": "b8e0fcb688dd99713889e1f1d0ed135bfe4f8f2abf56c76d5bbfbea1d6cb8d72", "trial10-native-window-5785-6500.txt": "b2af2187ef4e908b46673b0436fb85fef7b91077ae3c487abbf7a3946db8933e", "trial10-native-window-6501-6616.txt": "2151c774a711638b0e0a6b329d71d89e5a8f1aad96a98de6ed15e719641998eb", "trial10-native-window-6617-6671.txt": "9a0dab11abf83cd7ddf09ffc72be7eb4dadbde0cdc698a2e7c29413bcdeb9ecc", "trial10-native-window-6672-6710.txt": "e1ce856bb6762acbeca19e102b217473ac9c661106872c19c959c07086a36dfd", "v3-medium10-controller-audit.json": "be6f4fcc0c0333643fe4cb289e01086876e5ba8b232ffbe3a32e94592a523dc9", "v3-medium10-projection-audit.json": "c8fb504ba681da9d97ab1121c24d597369f507e017508938f91e19f9488cbf5e", "v3-medium10-reading-proof.json": "dcc100e33e1b4eb9c770001e13cc72c3aed87e5653ae388e76170e3abcaebdd0", "workspace-code-reading-working.json": "809cd86c7ae640b331b44815200130a66d2011f34ec59d169cb570559721b26d", "workspace-file-review.json": "c3b0703cc1526ac25e305a2ac463d1f0deb1289c9bd58335898dad63ee0a1ac0", "workspace-snapshot.json": "8662328572ba96e86448348e4aba7bcb94d3b21dca8e02cbc93a91bd18f0a708" } }, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "d362a8d92e793fd8a6b719239cdd69ec16acf425a78e474ed7b81fc7cd0882d4", "qualitative_review.json": "3161ee6b614e7c58d43aec9afe6754651191fbf890ab16607393e20c1e167643", "review.json": "c39db474957be3f14a8d9abceee139898708ba0fc71d0623ca3e9e0db947efb8", "replay.json": "25e685b3065de9ef8f17678ac14fc720599e26d6efc65370e19839e0ca260743", "state/summary.json": "3002cb3d295bf2a32c374ab5768d99cc1832bd31b628220cb5e1a14a4be26fab" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-01", "condition": "astra-max", "bundle": 1, "admitted": false, "status": "excluded_scope_reduction", "review_complete": true, "capability_result": null, "exclusion_reason": "After the user requested wrapping up, root stopped the remaining max session after about14.5hours. Seven practice games had ended; practice8 was interrupted alive. No scored game started. Both dispatched main max attempts remain in the denominator; no replacement.", "requests": 1021, "missing_usage_requests": 1, "estimated_request_priced_usd": null, "known_request_estimate_usd": 772.830639, "replayed_frames": 19540, "interrupted_trials": [ 8 ], "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "6af96af9ef1db4ad1532f26a74b17316320096b5e60370a6fb62dcfe94f37f9a", "exclusion.json": "f9c24121ddfb37583da4913a25f6a771aa30a881ce79a47fb2cdcb36bc05554e", "qualitative_review.json": "f8e0a90a9da86592c4c9417c1c8c0a2472267086de8ed3c753e6aea0b3d9e226", "review.json": "d247c48e479813f74c28c223e99929a299a8ff0073690ed8013d8ee9e9eae980", "replay.json": "803c8ff4d2f5ec1c25e02728956a52af32e11ae5fa0eb6b71d7c8bf88f3db38a", "state/summary.json": "b09f1e1936c3092490219361875abb24488baabfc0fea9f644a7957090fc2ef4" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-02", "condition": "astra-max", "bundle": 2, "admitted": false, "status": "excluded_api_failure", "review_complete": true, "capability_result": null, "exclusion_reason": "Two recorded API timeouts after practice trial3 violate the frozen no-model-errors rule; a third in-flight request was canceled. No scored game started, no replacement launched.", "requests": 267, "missing_usage_requests": 3, "estimated_request_priced_usd": null, "known_request_estimate_usd": 119.688187, "replayed_frames": 7343, "evidence_sha256": { "manifest.json": "b257b50452eba0ca5607474441460a0a909cfe70288c96fb28ad5da945db904d", "exclusion.json": "56795f80a7f117e6cac631ed966e8de055e31b37ba2c67a608f044b62d85186f", "qualitative_review.json": "3c4b6b3180d094669e8b4e4583691f2be7e76f8be8fad6a738ccd2728a5d9be7", "review.json": "8bba594d869a899d67c910c23060dd92ad7ef7b53bcee5483b89a2db12b41f3e", "replay.json": "f303bb7295f81444bd92d5a79d9ce1a20840501d2427ad7832551f038441e1a6", "state/summary.json": "eebd91099385a0da54e7a25dce131f753073e83905e4dc46b0d22fa0a63ec055" } }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-03", "condition": "astra-max", "bundle": 3, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-04", "condition": "astra-max", "bundle": 4, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-05", "condition": "astra-max", "bundle": 5, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-06", "condition": "astra-max", "bundle": 6, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-07", "condition": "astra-max", "bundle": 7, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-08", "condition": "astra-max", "bundle": 8, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-09", "condition": "astra-max", "bundle": 9, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-10", "condition": "astra-max", "bundle": 10, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-control-01", "condition": "astra-max-control", "bundle": 1, "admitted": false, "status": "cancelled_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-control-02", "condition": "astra-max-control", "bundle": 2, "admitted": false, "status": "cancelled_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-control-03", "condition": "astra-max-control", "bundle": 3, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-control-04", "condition": "astra-max-control", "bundle": 4, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-control-05", "condition": "astra-max-control", "bundle": 5, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-control-06", "condition": "astra-max-control", "bundle": 6, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-control-07", "condition": "astra-max-control", "bundle": 7, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-control-08", "condition": "astra-max-control", "bundle": 8, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-control-09", "condition": "astra-max-control", "bundle": 9, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." }, { "name": "research-silq-v3-astra-max-control-10", "condition": "astra-max-control", "bundle": 10, "admitted": false, "status": "not_run_scope_reduction", "pending_reason": "User reduced the sample; retained for provenance, not capability evidence." } ], "limitations": [ "Ten medium sessions were already complete when the user reduced the scope. Both already-dispatched main max attempts remain in the provenance denominator; no further sessions or replacements are planned.", "The two fresh controls were interrupted for scope reduction and supply no capability result or estimate of a practice effect. Any max comparison is descriptive and requires both retained sessions to be admitted. API failures and user-stopped sessions are excluded, never converted to losses; a surviving valid case does not represent the full attempted sample.", "Prior familiarity with a published game may contribute.", "Matched initial streams need not produce identical dungeons after different character-creation choices or later actions.", "Depth is diagnostic progress only; the native full retrieval and escape is the sole victory criterion.", "Costs are request-priced estimates, not invoices; developer inference and hosting are excluded.", "Reviews and direct play are by the development agent, without independent human expert validation." ], "scope_amendment": { "created_at": 1788857531.1012325, "reason": "User requested a smaller study while the first max batch was running.", "user_instruction": "We really only need one session, or three max per reasoning level. More is overkill.", "original_cohort_sha256": "390b2e6afb441f228c2de7c2456acf033f92baae354f63b1a3c0a880f91f53a5", "retain_completed_medium_bundles": [ 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 ], "complete_astra_max_bundles": [ 1, 2 ], "cancel_astra_max_control_bundles": [ 1, 2 ], "do_not_launch_astra_max_bundles": [ 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 ], "do_not_launch_astra_max_control_bundles": [ 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 ], "selection_basis": "Keep the two already-dispatched main max sessions, regardless of their outcomes. No replacement or third session is planned.", "analysis_policy": "Retain all completed medium evidence. Interrupted controls are reported as scope cancellations and cost evidence, not scored losses or capability evidence. No max-versus-fresh-control learning estimate will be made. Compare the two max sessions descriptively with their matched medium bundles and disclose the small sample.", "protocol_changes": null, "original_medium_gate_preserved": true, "wrap_up": { "recorded_at": 1788909190.1264699, "user_instruction": "Still not done? Can we wrap up soon?", "interpretation": "Root stopped remaining main max attempt to finish the research. No answer to the optional follow-up question was assumed.", "stopped_bundle": 1, "stopped_at": 1788908459.7189057, "both_attempts_retained": true, "max_scored_comparison": null, "game_result_for_interrupted_trial": null, "no_replacement": true } }, "scope_amendment_sha256": "1a5ebe4d3da019c7e15038bdb31e4db3089a3fd943a360d8630f15bf03a8d192", "planned_research_complete": true, "all_retained_conditions_valid": false }